Glad to see the Boogeyman back in action! Wish he still was with the Wild. Orr landed a couple early, Boogaard landed a few more and more damaging blows than Orr. Win Boogaard

two respected fighters in the nhl! god bless boogaard !!!

My hockey bag smells like Cheetos.

a draw no biggie here - BUT after reading reviews on this my favorite site on the web - I have to ask all - Behn Wilson who always seems to get in the first review ???? 3 years ago I got kicked out of a Long Island adult non checking hockey league - A) i always wore my #3 Flyer jersey with Wilson on the back - I was in front of the net trying to put in a loose puck - when this a hole whacks my ankles - we start to jostle - we drop the gloves - I pull off his helmet & 3 rd shot right above the eye I split his eyebrow - they kick me out - I`m still trying to get my $450 back 3 yrs later as i did not start this - BUT the president of the league states - Who do i think I am BEHN WILSON of the Flyers - that I always skate around looking to bump & start something in a NON contact league - thinking I`m the second coming of Behn Wilson - was not true - BUT who is this Behn Wilson always giving an accurate review on the action ????

draw!!

The Boo was not aggressive at all. Orr had some energy, but the tall guy is not quick and in the same mood. Do we need an Orr or a Boogaard in an NHL team? I don't think so! Bring the real talented players!!

Maybe its me but Boogard almost looked like he didn't want to fight, but had too once Orr dopped them (looks like he didn't drop his stick and right glove till after first shot thown). Seems like he is getting a bout of "I don't need to fight to play" syndrome this year with his lack of aggression so far this season. Anyone getting that feeling? Happened to Brashear when he came to the Rangers too.

Orr was off the Mark quick but not really connecting, bogey came back with some head shots then Orr stopped it with the take down. Both fighters didn't do enough for win. So I'm going with the draw. Was all a bit disappointing in the end.

wow some guy we never heard of gets a lucky punch in on Orr last week and everyone thinks Orr is a bum. He is by far top 3 heavy weight in league and probably the best guy to watch fight cause he don't care about getting hit. sure he ain't the sharpest pencil in the box but man the guy as got balls Boogieman is overrated and i hope Chara gives it to him tomorrow night

very close tilt. must be a lot of ranger homers who voted.

guess orr thought the only way to beat boogie was to get the jump on him,tryed to cold cock him instead of squaring off.smart or a low life move,you decide.

Orr is a demonitorr.

It was a draw.......... They both landed punches, Orr took maybe 2 upside the head but Boogaard cant even stay on his skates for being the size of a building.... Bullshyt to see people right Boogaard as a winner...... U probably all just hate Orr for beating down ur teams tough guy in the past...

Orr landed some shots in this one as did boogie, just check out the red patches on BOTH faces after. Pretty much a draw, take down means nothing, this isn't ufc! Would like to see this one again as Boogie seemed hesitant, although I can see why as Orr beat him in their 2 previous fights in WHL.

Boogaard with a couple better punches, Orr with the better leverage and take down. Nobody gets hurt and everybody's happy!! DRAW.

DRAWWWWWWW

Damn close fight, draw/dge Boogy.

Draw... If u want to call boogey the winner that's fine My wings won last night but probably got their asses kicked all over the ice I don't know-I went to bed Anyone who fights boogey has big big ones! Btw-boogey should have won this fight; he's a lot taller and out weighs his man by at least 35 lbs.?

Orr early, Boogard middle, Orr late.

Easy draw, Orr started with a big one and Boogaard followed with a couple good ones. Big shots from two big guys.

when was the last time somebody got take down against boogaard?draw

How come every time Boogaard fights, people have to vote him the winner regardless of what really happened? This was a clear draw - both guys landed some rights and Orr got the final takedown.

I am not a fan of either team but this seems like a clear draw. Orr does give up reach and still was able to handle himself extremely well. Boogard does well against the other huge players in the league so I would rate him at the top or right next to it.

Draw I watched this over and over and I cant really see a clear advantage by the Boogey man. But he has some serious reach. No excuses for Orr being a smaller guy they are both Heavy weights and thats Orrs job. But Boogey man is one scary dude. And while I dont give credit on takedowns, its interesting how people who just dont like the Leafs and dont like Orr say his takedown doesnt count for anything but pull up any other fight without 1 punch thrown a smaller guy wrestles a Leaf to the ground and you guys will call it 100% victory for the player who did the wrestling. Just like everything 50% of the people on here call it from the fence 25% from the homers and 25% from the haters. Draw.

The fight was pretty even throughout until Colton threw Boog's to the ice.The only mistake Boog's made was going to the left hand instead of sticking with the right,that's when Orr lasooed him to the ice.Boog's did get one haymaker landed right to Colton's jaw,but that's how tough Orr is,especially coming from a guy who outsizes him by five inches and has a thirty pound weight advantage over him as well.Good scrap,wish they played each other everynight for that match up alone.O-6'ers all the way.

Just like you at the hotdog stand huh " Philadelphia " Big Dog " Collins....anyway, 2 of my favorite fighters in this league, a draw, lets see Christine Neil fight anyone of these guys. Christine's big head would sound and look like a ripe tomato. Woof Woof!

orr with the take down for the win,but orr has some scores to settle with a few contenders.

edge to orr, points and take down.

pfft! anyone who thinks Orr lost this fight needs to start watching golf or something. Orr landed a few good shots, but MORE importantly survived the battle against a much larger man, who would rag-doll most players in ANY league. Orr wins by a hair because he survived a scrap with the "boogie man" and didn't look too bad doing it!

I give the edge to Orr for being busier at the start and getting a strong takedown. Great balls from Orr to take on the man mountain after that upset loss last week!

Nobody did any damage, Boogard landed more helmet shots and Orr landed a few nothings at the start, can got the takedown. I can see it being called either way, but I'm giving it to Orr on early shots plus takedown.

Orr did nothing in this fight... really didn't land anything... Boogeyman with the win! Orr with the 1/2 trip at the end! Thats all he could muster up. Orr bit off more than he could chew here! Win Boogaard

Slight edge Orr.

Pretty even fight would like to see a rematch but with boogaards injury issues i dont think that will happen this season. Boogaard has seemed to have issues staying healthy as of late.

Considering the size difference, and the face that Colton Orr was the one who instigated the fight, and also controlled the fight. He, is the winner.

Orr with a couple early, Boogie with a couple in the middle, draw

Hugfest leading to a take-down...Orr.

I don't like Orr, but gotta give him the slight egde. He was aggressive and defended pretty well...

Even fight Orr gets edge with nice take down of the mountain at the end.

orr lands 5 before boogieman knows whats going on , boogaard comes back lands a few good power shots which orr brushes off then orr lands a solid short shot that buckles boogaard , i call this one close but edge to orr .

Orr, nice comeback fight from engellend......... booogard is tooo big. DRAW

Orr with the slight edge. We all knew he'd win. Boogaard is a Yeti! Jesus! I just scrolled down and saw the results of the votes. Are you people retarded? Orr controlled this fight, took a few but also delivered as well. Anyone see the Leafs feed of Boogaard skating to the penalty box with a nice rasberry under his right eye? Orr gets the take down at the end with a punch. Pretty simple vote I would assume. Pull your heads out of your asses people.

Nice win Orr. Landed more, got the take down

Colton gave em what for then he got the takedown win win Orr

Orr will go with anyone, least he isn't a bitch and picks his fights. Either way he goes out swinging win or lose, name some other fighters that go out n swing win or lose these days??? Examples: Orr bs carkner, Orr vs Engelland etc... Boogard is a liability that plug can't even skate let alone take a pass, make one, or get a shot on net... plummer.

why is orr so tough

Boogard is overrated and I cant wait to see Engelland fight him

mishaps don't happen twice..

colton orr looked very un-coordinated against boogaard.......that being said......boogaard wins this easily.

Boogaard win.

The Boogie man with the edge. Orr is lucky to survive this one.

Boogard looks rusty. Should have known Orr would jump right into it. Still win for Boogard. Lucic or Thornton will get the warmed up version.

The million dollar fighters go at it. Edge to Boogeyman for the direct shots to Orr's chops, though Orr came out much better than he did against Engelland.

Decent fight, but sooner or later (probably sooner judging by his recent fights) Orr will be seriously tagged by his opponent. He leaves himself wide open to haymakers. Admittedly, his fights are usually entertaining, but does he think that's worth getting helped off the ice like Ivanans?

Edge to Boogaard. Much respect to Orr for going with the Boogie man after he was dropped last time he fought. I think he learned his lesson of not leaving his chin completely open any more.

Giving the edge to the Boogeyman on this one.

Boogaard

Close

Still have a place in my heart for Orr......but the pull down doesn't constitute for a win...

Edge Boogey. Landed 3 Orr didnt land any. Why is Orr smiling? Next fight Boogey,s gonna knock seven shades of shit out of him.

Nice try by Orr to jump in before the fight started, but it still didn't work. Edge to Boogaard. Not sure what Orr was smiling about at the end, he wasn't smiling against Engelland last week.

Orr tried to get the Boogieman early, but to no avail. The Big Booger landed the better shots. Takedown was meaningless. Edge Boogaard.

close fight edge to the Boogey man

Boogaard win Orr just trying to hang in there...on the end of Boogaards extended arm. Lucky take down but that doesn't signify a win.

Boogaard was on top of his game that night.

Boogaard WIN For those of who give wins based on who falls on whom ... you are morons.

Minnesota misses the Boogeyman.

Boog with slight win. Orr didnt land a thing but threw him down pretty good at the end.

Have to give te slight edge to Booger in this one even though Colt got off first but seemed to miss (albeit barely) with the first 2 rights. It may have been a whole different outcome if he would have connected. makes you wonder on what intensity Booger was throwing those punches because a couple seemed to land on the money and did not seem to faze Colt where as Egghead dropped him. Anyhow, slight edge to the Red Oak.

Boogaard landed the better shots. Good scrap though.

Who the hell voted for Orr? Idiots.

orr lost again and compounded it by trying to get the drop on booogaard.

Win Boogie for landing the only clean punches.

No way Colton Orr won this fight. He gets hit several times in the face. The takedown was nothing more than Boogaard getting underhooked.

Boogaard is the winner...Orr fought hard, but it is all Boogeyman

Win Boogaard.

EDGE Boogaard for landing 3 hard blows. Orr jumped to Boogeyman!!

Winner Boogie. Close, but Boogie got in the best blows. Orr went for the quick don't let him set up approach and that saved his life.

Orr asked for it. he got it. W Boogie Man

Boogaard is a monster. Orr didn't have a chance.

boogaard gets the edge in this fight with the bigger shots landed.

Orr felt he needed every edge...even if it meant jump starting Boogie by 'surprise'. Boogie in control most of the fight , caught Orr with one solid right. I'm one who feels takedowns should at times be considered for brownie points but not applicable in this case. Win Boogaard.

Jumped him my A@@. Boogeyman is just slow and stupid.

Boogaard with the win by a slight edge. Its amazing how this totally one dimensional player got the contract he did. If not for his fighting ability.(biggest bad ass on the pond) This guy couldnt skate with Pee Wee's. His hockey skills are atrocious. He is the true definition of a GOON! Not surprising he's never scored a goal inn his NHL career.

Orr got in the first few shots but did nothing after that except get hit. Give Orr credit for staying on his feet after Boogy hit him with a couple of big shots. The takedown means nothing, Boogard with the win.

Good win for Boogeyman in a close fight

Orr got in quick but it didn't do much good. Once Boogard got situated it was all 94 until Orr got tired and took him down. Win The "BOOGIEMAN" good effort by one time Ranger Mr. Orr

Boogaard landed. Orr didn't. Edge Big B

Very close scrap. Boogie landed a couple of cleaner shots with Colton not really connecting because of the huge reach of Boogie. No hugging here, both these guys like to scrap, admirable considering these 2 prob have the heaviest hands in the NHL. Good tilt, glad neither of these warriors didn't get hurt.

Boogey with the only 2 clean shots at 15 seconds and 25 seconds. Orr with a lifesaving takedown to get a roar from the crowd. Win for Boogaard.

2 guys who are/were considered the most devastating fighters in the NHL since 05-06. The late Derek Boogaard wins by Unanimous Decision.

Close edge to Boogaard. Glad to see Colton is still landing those sucker punches being the straight up tough guy that he is. Keeps all of Leaf Nation voting for him.

Orr is a has been heavyweight.Going after the toughest player in the league either takes guts or stupidity and in Orrs case its Stupidity!Perhaps the leaf fans who voted for Orr can tell us all the last time he won a fight?He tackles Boogaard at the end is all he accomplished in this fight otherwise all he was doing was catching!Easy win for the Monster!Anyone who believes Orr won this fight should see two doctors the first one being an optometrist and the second being a shrink cause your screwed in the head!

Tough call here for me. I'm a Ranger fan & an Orr fan. I'm going to give slightest of edge to Boog for power punces. But what balls on Orr! Wish Blueshirts had kept Shelley, at least he has some skills...Boogy, not so much.

boogeyman

Boogaard with the edge, three HARD shots to Orr's face/head really sealed it for me, Orr looked okay, but was outdone this time.

I don't get why so many people say Orr won because he did the take down, I'm a huge fan of Orr but he lost a take down doesn't mean anything, Boogey man landed more hits and with power, that being said I give credit to Orr for having the guts to fight him and he landed one or two but nothing really effective, edge goes to Boogey man on this one.

The only thing Orr did was punch him before he got his gloves dropped, and the takedown. Other than that it was only punches hitting Orr's head. Win Boogaard

We don't see this kind of stuff down in DC much. Very informative to see quality fighters fighting. I still would like to see either of this nice mean men take on either Cooke or Carcillo. Boog, while slower than the old days, still packs some hard punches. Since wrestling doesn't count, the winner is Boog.

Boooooooogey Derek Boogaard is a monster!!!!

Boogy got in the only significant shots and landed much more.....Colton took him down but didnt do anything else really

Better punchs by Boodaard, only a tke down by Orr. Win Boodgard. Toronto... ahahaha!

TOTAL DOMINATION BY BOOGARD! And he will beat the shot out of Orr each and every time. He tried to get the Boogetman off guard. NOT Gonna Happen! Orr got beat bad by Engelland abd is trying to re-establish himself and I give him credit for being one of the toughest fighters in the league. But he will get his ass kicked by the Boogeyman. Take downs just never count!

dear homers narrow win boogard

i love how orr always tries to get the jump, square off and man up. win boo

Orr DID try to jump him, Boogaard with many more punches landed and much better punches at that. You get squat for a take down, especially after getting your head slapped around like a sock puppet. Win Boogaard!

He's back.... Boogaards first fight of many thay he will dominate in the limp wristed eastern conference.Nobody will stay with him...goodsalary for atough guy.

Orr was thrilled to grab a takedown and get out of there. Boogaard gets the W.

at 0;57 boogaard lands a right while Orr was resting.. being a Rangers fan i miss Orr and wish they had kept him but DB made upf or it with this win.

That was a great a fight.. Orr gave up a lot of reach, just because Orr took him down doesn't means he won, just means.. HOLY CRAP GET ME OUT OF THIS REFS. Derek landed a lot.. I'm sad Orr made it.

First off, Orr showed a lot of courage fighting Boogaard. Boogaard doesn't always look so great in his fights, but he remains the most dangerous fighter in the league. Orr fought a very smart fight. He traded punches for a while and then knocked Boogaard down when the opportunity came. Seeing the big guy go down was seen as a moral victory for the smaller Orr by the fans and his team. All that said, I think it was a draw. If it continued Boogaard would have won it.

I gave it a draw - but I can see an easy aruement being made for Boogie getting the win.

Did Orr start throwing before Boogaard dropped his gear? It looked that way to me, but whatever. Fight was a draw, I'm shocked that one right from DB didn't drop Orr.

Guys, calling us Ranger fans homers doesn't work on this one. We LOVE C Orr, he's an absolute stud, fearless, warrior. This guy did more damage in his 4 or so seasons than anyone we ever had. Concussed the then Islander heavy; knocked out cold the then Flyer heavy. This guy was nothing short of awesome as the Rangers' enforcer. Watching this fight was uncomfortable at best. Called it a draw.

I'm callin it a draw.......yep! maybe could have gone Boogey man But ORR's my man!!!!!! I think it was a good fight and a super show of Balls by ORR after sleepy time last week!!!! Thats why he is SOOOOOO exciteing.....He ALWAYS GIVES HER!!!!!!!! COWARD is not in this mans Vo-Cab Juha 82 What are you watchin????? Boogard gives Orr the first shove and Orr responds and gets his gloves off first....... If this is called Jumping a person ........Go to Hakim optical where you can get 2 pair of glasses for the price of one......YA NEED EM!!!!!!!!!

Very close.Not a whole lot landing.Slight edge to Boogaard for the two hard rights.Still miss Orr in NY.Most exciting brawler in the league.Win or lose...

Ugh idk im a die hard ranger fan...i absolutely love colton orr i wish sather re-signed him so bad but sather is an asshole but thats another story...every time orr fights against the rangers my instinct is to root for the ranger but my heart wants orr...so i have a REAL hard time rooting against orr so idk draw i guess...

i'm goin for the draw! good shots landed by both guys but i think draw is fair

I can't choose between the two so I'll call it a draw. Props to Orr for going toe to toe with Booger.

Orr with the take down. Didn't seem to suffer any ill effects from his previous KO. The Dude has a serious set of NUTS don't he?

Pretty close--Boogaard gets the edge with a few more, better punches. On the flip side, how sad for the Rangers fans--first that lump Brashear in a Rangers sweater, now one of the league's most one-dimensional useless players in Boogaard? Sad.

Orr gets the jump, starts punching before Boogaard's gloves are off, and still loses. Orr loses alot, Brown can't fight at all, and Lucie Schenn gets plowed. Leafs suck.

Orr was getting beat,...realized he was in over-his-head and bails with the "take-down" move --- ( can't believe the announcer actually called him the winner - was pretty funny ).

BOO 5

slight edge Boogeyman...had to watch it a bunch 2 make the call....nice to see the top contenders go finally..we need more

Orr with the takedown!....and the loss.

Boogaard with some solid punches in this one. Orr realizes he's overmatched and wrestles him down, which doesn't mean anything other than he was through. Boogaard gets the win.

edge boogard, and i'm a big fan of both of these guys, I'm not suprised that it was this good a fight. so if you still think that godard, or king are contenders for the crown, you'll find out soon enough, that they aren't. since most of the monsters are in the east this year ( john scott in chi-town is the sleeper) so there won't be any more excuses.

The mighty reach of The Boogey Man wins the day yet again. Still, Orr wasn't dominated by any means, which is a testament to his toughness.

Edge to Boogaard in a very close fight.

I wonder if Orr has a concussion? anyway the man is tough...but I say he tackled Boogey to avoid the damage that was coming from one or two more sledge hammers. Tackle = win for Boogeyman.

Orr started well, and hung in there as best he could... against a lethargic-looking version of the behemoth. But once he realized that his better moments were behind him... he took the first ''bail'' opportunity that presented itself. Still, no shame in that... and guts-galore just for initiating it, in the first place... much less hanging in there long enough to earn a legitimate draw. I'll bet the smile on Orr's face at the end, was because of one, of two things ... A) he was genuinely happy to have survived a close encounter with a Sasquatch, and to have come out of it, virtually, unscathed, or B) he realized that the take-down at the end might fool some people into thinking that he actually won the fight. Either way, props for an admirable comeback after the Engelland mishap.