C'mon. How does this mess amass 20 mins of penalties. Brutal night for fight fans so far

Its rare to say but announcer got it right. Ref had arm up with gloves still on, terrible call. Then Stewart yaps at Carkner after the soft move going right for the take down, what a joke.

To call this a fight is a misnomer.

Clean hit. Carkner has to be smarter. Gets a barrel of minutes for nothing. Stewart wanted no part of Carkners anger. A huggie bear fight, nada here.

Apparently that morning the refs and linesmen got an email memo from Commissioner Pipsqueak advising them to stop possible retaliatory altercations after clean checks along the boards.

That's an instigator are you morons blind?

Should have been two each for holding....

bad showing from big chris stew put mayb at end of shift would have liked to see a fight but hey oh well

Clean hit. No fight. Carkner got his gloves off and went after Stewart...takes Stewart off for 5...no one cares on the Isles if Carkner is off for 17 minutes. Chico R is an idiot...worse than Edwards.

Another blown instigator call, this fight had name potential.. gave it a VERY GENEROUS 2..

A sort of grapplefest draw. Not much going on here.

this fight was a draw.......not to mention a minute and 40 of my life wasted.

terrible, Stewart didnt wanna fight, the refs completely fucked carkner. just dumbness all around, and the fight sucked balls.

stewart wanted no part of carkner

What was that?

Bad fight, not sure I blame Stewart for playing huggy bear. I am giving it to Carkner, and not by much, little shots to the side of the head, and i stress little. Rated a 1.

That was weak Stewart, when a real fighter wants to go u do that? Big spot picker Stewart is

Hey Stewie - how come you ain't raising your hands after that one? Pick & choose the easy ones .... but hug and fall otherwise. Carkner all the way.

I vote Stewart to balance things out because it was not even a fight. It seems that Carkner got the 10 minute game misconduct so clearly Stewart got the better end of the deal. He wins by default. Crappy fight....but at the time I write this the voting is as follows: Carkner 55.9% Draw 41.2 % Stewart 2.9% Stewart probably even broke Carkners ribs when he landed squarely on top of him. I'd vote a little more honest but others here just vote for their famvorite team.

would have rather seen Carkner get 5min an Stewart 2min. not worth 10min misconduct

That's the Lucic of the West?

Half a hugfest, but Carkner got a couple noogies in. WHY Carkner got a misconduct is beyond me. Stewart didn't want to fight, but he dropped the gloves too. Up to that point, the refs were calling a pretty good fame, but that was a BS call -- the zebras never give the Isles any respect.

Awful fight

I'm surprised Carkner didn't get a concussion out of that... Stewart could be a great power forward one day if he ever decided to try a little

Win Carkner, Stewart wanted nothing to do with it.

Gotta go with Carkner since he at least put forth some effort!

some one wrote CHICO was worse than EDWARDS thats impossible. but BUTCH GORING was the color man here. not sure what the 10 was for, for throwing better nuggies .CARKNER wins

yuck, if that had kept on going I would put my money on Carkner but Idk wtf that was.

Not much of a fight. Give it to Carkner because he at least tried to fight.

Carkner because he was the only one that threw punches with little landing.

im giving the edge to carkner for punches to the back of stewart's head even though they looked soft.stewart wanted only to hug i agree with announcers.i dont understand why officials hand went straight up.there was no penalty at that point

Stewart should have kept his gloves on.

Hard to score a wrestling match but i give it to Carkner for throwing a few nuggies!

edge to carkner, stewart didn't land one punch lol in lazy hugfest, its like a brashear fight with no action! i remember carkner beating up brashear few years ago, always had his number carkner is pass his prime tho

Giving this a draw and a 1 -- but that it is because Stewart did not want to fight

That looked like two monkeys humping.

What fight?

Carkner reacted to that measly hit from Stewart? A joke ... like this fight ...

Sorry, but I'm not impressed with this at all, including Butch Goring's inane commentary.

Another crap fight. Gave it a 2. Win Carkner, ...but only because Stewart was obviously afraid of him and wanted no part of a fight. I think Stewart might have even soiled his hockey pants.

Carkner who overreacts to a clean hit inspiring a non-fight hugathon... ... is unjustly rewarded for his questionable judgement with a trip to the showers by a pack of jittery equally overreactive zebras