Good bout,May landed more often,give him the decisive win.

Watch it again and pay attention to Barch. He throws a ton of air-hooks. May was smiling on his way to the box because he was almost untouched. Lots of activity but May gets the win.

A CLEAR DRAW... I LOVE IT WHEN THE TWO FIGHT///

Jesus, don't these guys take fighting seriously. I hate when they're laughing and gigling with each other afterwards as if it was a game.

Draw.

Good fight, it is always fun to watch these guys throw down!

How can you IDIOTS not say this is a Draw???????????? C'mon you morons, this was a classic barch v may slugfest that came out in a draw. What gave May the edge? Nada bitches

I had to score May slight win. He looked as though he enjoyed it.

listening to redmond is priceless

Good one, looks like May took that last throw right on snot locker. Wish Downey was still on the Wings.

Graet fight by two buds, Draw

The Red Wings announcers are so right! They are #1 in fight entertainment. PRAY FOR BARCH-MAY VII !!!!!!!

very good

speechless this was one of the greatest fights of this year

wow! episode 6 in the epic series that is barch vs may and this is a beauty of a fight. all offense and a true slugfest. i gave it a 9 and a draw. winners are us who get to see the bout- both warriors deserve a pat in the back and a raise of salary lol

#24...... Gives you super powers. Win May.

Nice tussle , win to May-Day

Very close... good to see ol' May day scrappin'.

piss on all the experts who routinely poke (dare i say 'jab'??) fun at the smaller screappers in the nhl!!! you impugn their heart as well as fighting ability and then vote their fights highest so far this year. when is the last time bGL (no longer will be receive upper case status for that first word) had anything higher than a 6??? and don't claim that is because people are afraid to stand toe to toe with him...that is PRECISELY why he gets so many invites (those making the appeal need to prove themselves). i'd rather have either of these 2 or someone like ian lapierre, , brandon prust, or dan carilllo on my team. these men are warriors, not some oh so specific tool to be used in a instance so few and far between that their presence on the team hardly makes a difference. may and barch tangles have the highest rating (avg, mind you) of any duos in the last 3 years.......

draw. both are true warriors

Great Fight, these two always put on a show!!

good draw.

God, what a fight!!!

I figured May would be retired by now--nope, he still likes to fight.

May punched Barch's face, while Barch connected with May's fist... Win May.

May landed a little more than Barch The edge to May

if you watch barch misses most all === if one were to score this 'punches thrown'--it was a draw. but may lands many, many more.

Again, Barch (the worst) heavyweight fighter in the league can't even take down a man almost twice his age. it's a draw but may did land some good shot and barch landed nothing!

May by a nose. Good active slugfest. What is this, about the 50th time these two have locked up?

Watching Wings games is so much more tolerable these days now that May is usually dressed.

What, Barch and May got into a fight? That never happens. Another solid bought of rock em sock em hockey between these two guys. May had the edge.

Brad May IS Return of the Living Dead!!!!! May throws everything but his Walker at Barch in this highly rated bout and a win. All accolades go to May

Good tilt. May = Warrior!

Outstanding. I'd like to pop the announcer, though. What a douchebag.

Win to the old guy, both threw alot and Barch is looking better as the season gets longer, but May seemed to land a few more. Good scrap!

c'mon this is no draw it is a win by May clos fight but a win by May count the punches landed you will see...............homers stop voting unfairly.. For the record I am a fan of neither team

good fight edge to may,these two know what to expect from each other!BRAD MAY ALL TIME GAMER!

good fight!

Great fight. W for May

Rock em sock em. great battle.

Just a nice fight. Gotta love May. He always gives a good show.

Great fight Edge May

Great scrap.I loved the expression on Brad May's face when it was over. At least there's one Red Wing who is'nt a wuss.

Hope the Wings get a few years out of May, he's a great addition to the squad. He gets the win here in a close bout.

May is the only player in "Dead Wing" country that is worth his pay. Great scrap!!!!

edge may in a fantastic fight. seemed to be watching every punch he was throwing for the first half while barch more had his head down while he was chucking them. very close fight though, these two are amazing head to head.

Nice return to classic era of NHL tru tough quys brawls :-) Slight edge May and 9

very good fight between these 2 guys.alot of punches were thrown.

Great to see Old Man May still gettin er' done! Good fight with plenty of action. For those of us who have watched may since Buffalo, what a warrior, eh? Close win, May.

May gets the edge, great fight!!!

brad loves the game, knows his role and beats barch- hands down. Way to go Brad.

Great tilt. May with the slight edge. He had better connection.

Great fight. May still proving he is one of the elite heavies in the game. He's made Red Wings respectable again.

may these two never be on the same team.

Another great, spirited, solid go between this two - edge to May for landing more shots

It is amazing to watch Brad May in action, what a veteran warrior! The Red Wings are very lucky to have his leadership and toughness with all the injuries and young players being called up from the Grand Rapids Griffins. This is more than likely his last season and I am happy for him he is playing such an important role ... he will hang up his skates with his head high.

I saw more punches from Barch that landed.

How can you say May won that fight when he bails at the end? You cant win a fight if you ask for mercy.

they both lost. what a bunch of weak punches.

May is a tool

Nice dance with little big time hits. May is little more than a Don Quixote wannabe!

Even outt, lots of pepper aka jabs. Draw.

rocky 6....2 old pals throwing down again...draw...good fight boys

poor fucking crowd...idk y there werent goin crazy when they were firing non stop for most of the fight....

Good fight. Nice to see the acknowledgment from each other. Well done draw.

Good old fashioned throwing match. I thought Barch carried it, but Draw. Looked like Barch had to switch hands after banging up the right on May's helmet quite a few times.

I never cared for May when he was younger, but I do now. The guy is something else! Edge to May

clear win May. not close Don't think Barch connected even once.

They are great together!!!!!!! Like pea's and carrots!!!!!! How can a true fight fan not like May Day regardless of who you are cheering for???????

I don't think I even saw Barch land a punch till almost the very end... entertaining for sure but May got the decision.

I bet the have Christmas dinner together. great matchup, as always. edge May.

slight edge to may in a scrap that both guys seemed to enjoy

Great job by both, May gets the better of it for landing more.

Just a flat out great fight between two great fighters.

Great fight. Dont think May will be fighting tomorrow

Great fight between these two. Slight edge to May in a very close fight.

Barch, how does it feel to get your a$$ beat by somebody nearly twice your age? You're a puke and always will be. Win for May and pride for hockey in general.

these two never disappoint........

may day all day every day