With both guys landing a zillion punches and standing at the end, I'm inclined to give a draw but it sure looked like May was landing better shots with both hands. Great fight!
10 for fun!!!!! Edge May. Looked that May landed a couple/few hard blows.
Great fight, i call it draw!
May was able to keep his head up and switch hands better. May lands more and avoids getting hit as much with his head up. Nice showing by Barch. Win May.
may definitely got the upper hand. great fight. may switched right to left perfectly. barch isn't strong enough to pull his arm loose, and he is not an accurate puncher. and he never switches up effectively. he hung in there nicely though. but ultimately may landed more and with more authority.
Great toe to toe battle here, I really like Krys Barch, he'll step to plate with anyone!. Draw!!
pretty nice scrap by both guys. Draw, hard to pin a loss on either with a good showing by both
Nice draw !
Great f'n fight! Don't think worth 9 or 10, but no punches slipped here! Great fight to the draw between old school and young stud.
no winner,a draw from start to finish
Gotta call that kinda scrap a draw. Very good fight. My hats for to both men.
Great tilt. If only they could all be like this. Gotta laugh at some of the morons on here like IMPEACH. Barch only landed two! Have you ever seen ice much less played hockey. Get out of here you idiot! This was a classic. Both players landed great shots. I called it a draw only because you can't tell from youtube which ones landed. Good respectable showing by each.
Great Fight...both landed and threw a bunch of shots, but clear winner...Draw.
slight edge to may
I wish we could see more hockey fights like this one!
That was a very even fight, with haymakers flying. That was great!
Nothing like two bums pounding eachother
Nice tussle - solid punches exchanged, good balance, and they went quite a while. May's best days may be behind him, but he can still chuck knuckles with the majority of heavyweights in the NHL.
Good fight May was just a little better than Barch Edge WIN for May
Great toe to toe bout possibly a fight of the year candidate. This fight is what its all about
Can you say Heavywieghts. Goodness they threw some monsters. Great fight and a draw for sure. Rematch I would pay to see.
AWESOME! May looked better....but I voted for a draw.
WOW. NOW THAT WAS A GOOD OL ASS KICKING ON BOTH PARTS. THATS THE WAY A HOCKEY FIGHT SHOULD BE NO HUGGIN OR DANCIN JUST STRAIGHT UP BRAWLIN. GIVE PROPS FOR TELLING THE OTHER TO WATCH OUT FOR THE GLOVE.
Solid scrap! Both landed some medium bombs. Funny how announcers called him "Kyle" Barch. Tools!
oh man!what a fight!barch landed couple of unanswered rights in the middle of fight but i call it draw
great toss both landed some bombs and took some as well. Needed more punches for it to be considered FOY but it should receive honorable mention
awesome scrap, hard to choose a winner. i'll saw draw but i'd score may by a hair if i had to.
A good toe to toe style classic tilt, the way it shoud be done. I cannot stand this defensive fighting shit nowadays!
This is great stuff!!! Both guys were ready to threw and did not hold back. Both showed class and respect, as well. Gotta give it a draw.
This is one of the better fights all year! No clear win for either one. This was just round 2 from their fight on Nov 21.
Loved it. Just a couple of big boys rocking and firing. Neither with the edge and both fired and took some bombs.
great fight. i cant say anyone lost after a great fight like that. great job by both of them.
gotta say a good scrap after a long hugfest period . my respect to both of them . go flames !
Draw..... why? May was swinging away to the side of the head which is somewhat protected by a helmet which obviously didn't phase Barch.... Barch was steadly landing either chin or body shots to the chest I'm guessing chest since May wasn't faded. Then the 2 each got some good slams in there. Looked like Barch had May by the throat (which would have been a bitch move, but no telling) Both some good blows... I can't see how anyone can claim winner
Great Fight!!! That is what respect is all about. Two guys that are out there to do a job,
Great to see May still has it in him! a great scrap! like the good old Probert days! :)
FEAR...kept the ZEBRAS at bay .....great tilt by two tough guys !
good tilt.. can't pick a winner cause they both showed up and threw some bombs..
let 'em fly, boys!!!!
wow what a fight, definitely a draw as both guys just were going toe to toe, this is what all fights should be like!!!
great fight. thank you mr. may and mr. barch.
FOY candidate here. Even if I see it as a draw.
GodDAMN do these two know how NOT to have a great fight when they square off against each other? If theres a award for Series of the Year, this just adamnbout HAS to be it! Beauty. Id have to say solid draw there, but by far the best scrap Ive seen in many months.
I loved the anouncer, "Neither guy plays defense!!!!" I love it. Great tilt, Draw for sure!!
Great Fight !!!
I can not see how May is winning? I dont give a shit about when he was Barch's age. The fight happend last night... that is what you are suppose to vote on
What can I say but " GREAT FIGHT" May, one of the best all time!
i say this is the fight of the year!!!!
Slav and Gunslinger said it all. The kid showed great respect for the old man. It'd be a honor to fight either of them.of course my dentist loves when I say stupid shit like that ,lol fight was a 10
Great fight that no-one should lose. A tape of this scrap should be sent to every so-called fighter in the league. This is how its done!
Glad I was watching this game on Ctr Ice, especially where I don't like either team. This fight was worth the price of admission...one of the best fights thus far in the 07-08 NHL season! Got to call it a draw because Barch answered every punch that May threw. Just before the fight ended Barch put a really good straight right onto May's cakehole and May didn't answer back very well with that weak left...very close fight!!!
Great fight both threw some haymakers!! A draw for sure!
Great fight! this is one of the top 5 so far this year. Pretty even tilt so I give it a draw.
Great fight! Best I've seen all season. Their last fight on Nov. 21 was a good one too. I call this one a draw.
Great tilt - both standing in and landing some major league shots - Draw.
That's a hockey fight!
G R E A T!!
Good old fasioned hockey scrap! great bout!!!
Awsome Fight! All the enforcers in the NHL should take note of this fight! This is how it's done!
What a great fight! so energetic! and good to see the honor between the 2 fighters. as sayed on TV "THIS GUYS AR'NT PLAYING DEFENSE"
GREAT FIGHT!!! Thats how you fight...Beat the tar out of eachother...Followed the code...Textbook!
Great toe-to-toe bout. Aggressive and classy. These guys have a great rivalry this season. Without getting too technical its a draw. FYI - Stephane Robidas is a total douche.
This was one of the best fights you will see this year for sure, both May and Barch went at each other like it was their last fight ever!!! May probably gets the nod but Barch hung in there like a pro.
awesome fight.... no holding back there... nice shots from both draw
I say draw because i cant pick a winner it was a very good fight very good almost as good as at the end when brad may was going off the ixce when he started celebrating but it was a good fight draw they both won
Until the last segment of the fight I was ready to give it to May but Barch came back strong after taking a half dozen and more. Gotta love that Western conf!!
what a fantastic fight! It was like watching Rock'em Sock'em Robots! I was waiting for one of their heads to pop off! I love watching two heavies tradin'-em off! This is one of those fights you wished you were there for!
Wow, what a fight. I don't know how anyone can say either player won this fight. It seemed so equal. One of the best fights I have seen in a long time. I am glad they get to play four more times. Thanks for adding the vid. Awesome.
Haha, nice fight, heavy rights and lefts from booth players!
great fight..draw in my book and how about the announcer...kyle barch?? get it right you idiot
Standing ovation. Great tilt. Nothing more to be said... thats how it should be done.
WOW!! Now that is a fight! No clear winner though, this one is a draw.
What a fight.. Looks like May edged him but not enough to give him the win. I call it a Draw
Ail-Frazier, Zale-Graziano, Patterson-Johansonn now add Barch-May as the Greatest trilogies of All-time
I was wrong. This is definitley the best fight I have ever seen. Such a close one.
Barch and May respected each other. "Watch out for the glove" as Barch dances into a fight. May gives approval to Barch "Good job,kid"@! Awesome.
Think May landed more punches. The old boy just keeps going. Barch is gonna have a long career as a fighter too.
Good fight. Lots of punches from May, but Barch held his won for the most part.
I like the solid first punch by May.
Nice to see guys willing to take one to give one, but come on a 9.0! Has it been that long since we have seen a good tilt? It seems that the heavyweights are going the way of boxing, they kinda of suck because they don't really want to trade blows and you end up with a bunch of BGLs's that either jackhammer or grapple guys into submission in <10 seconds, whereas the light heavies (like these two) and middleweights are the ones to watch. Just b/c the Bettman era is below par, don't lose perspective. Type this in your browser, it's a 9.0+ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NxYOlRcwqiY
This is what a hockey fight is supposed to look like!
terrific !!!!!!!!!!!!! a real old time hockey fight.........
good fight. may wins, very close.
Mayday still has it, both hands. What we all expect to see: No Huggin!
solid back and forth but Barch didn't land any really clean ones
It looked to me that May landed more, so I gave him the decision. Very entertaining fight.
fkn awesome tilt!
AT THE GAME. FIGHT WAS SICKKK LIVE MY LANDED BETTER SHOTS
Great fight! May by 5-6 better punches. I hated to see him leave the Canucks a few years back....we could sure use his toughness now.
bombs dropping ... May day all day
Great tilt. Both looked good, May seemed to throw more at the start but did not connect.
Very close fight, I called it a draw. I think May did get in a couple of the better shots though. Almost swayed to go with May.
looks like a draw to me.. nice bout by both
Darn good tilt here. I fell asleep at the end of the first and missed this brawl. Both combatants went toe to toe and landed good hard punches. very good fight draw
Good Scrap! Draw
hell of a tilt! close to call, May looked to be in control to me.
edge to may
Great fight. Edge May, for 2 more punches cleanly landed.
way all fights are supposed to be close win for may
Great scrap. Good to see a hockey fight with some punches thrown. Close one but have to give the decision to May.
Awesome fight, slight edge to May.
Edge to May. Great scrap.
May early, Barch rest of fight. Good go around, edge to Barch (though, truthfully I hate May's sucker-punching ass so I may be biased, but I hope not).
great fight.. Close, but May with a few more lands. This one might be saved on the Tivo for a while.
Slight edge to May for landing the bigger punches. Great friggin fight!
Two light heavy weights that really threw it down. Great fight, May landed the most quality shots, still very close.
Well May certainly pounded him! They both took some shots! Good fight
it seems that on the balance May was hitting face and March more plastic than flesh
This was a slugfest! I give it to May. He landed some bombs. Great fight. I really think these two have hatred for one another.
Good effort boys! Bad Brad and "Kyle" Barch (WTF?) Thats how it used to be more often than not back in the heyday of punchups when I was a lad. Jay Miller and John Kordic would be proud of that one....
great fight, May's experience definitely helped give him the nod.
Great Fight, slight edge to May
by Brad switching hands he get the nod in a very close fight.
Great fight by 2 guys that know how to drop 'em. May connected more times than Barch though. Great respect for each other, too.
Wow one of the best this year. Had to give it to May though for landing alot more shots flush to the head.
candidate for fight of the year!
great tilt - both landed some quality shots - may got that left going and barch could only try and keep up - did a good job doing so - more scraps like this one are needed! Everyone gets fired up and brings the level of the game up - good scrap!
The edge to May because he can throw equally well with both hands. Fight of the year so far.
fight of the year so far, barch very game but an easy win for May
Awesome fight..loved the reaction by May after the fight. Winner May.
One of the best fights all season. Love it when guys can drop bombs then commend each other at the end. Class acts. Slight advantage to May.
pretty exciting and very close. I gave it to may because he seemed to be conecting more of his shots.
dude...i was at the game last night and what more can i say...best fight i've seen all year....mayday kicked some major ass.
WHAT A FIGHT!!!!! My God. Haven't seen one that good in a long time. Win May. Barch stood his ground good though. Give him Credit. He is moulding in a pretty decent scrapper.
Wow! That was a hell of a fight - old time hockey. May landed left after left and Barch was returning rights. May was the clear winner.
Great hammer fest. Edge to Brad May. Throw'em til your tired boys! A real fight for a change instead of a hug and kiss fest.
Great Tilt. Gotta give the slightest of edge to May for having more mustard on his punches. AND WHAT IS UP WITH THE PEOPLE TRYING TO DISS DUCK FANS AS BEING IGNORANT? So what the announcer call Barch "Kyle." What the Ducks have been doing is great for hockey. They not only bullied their way to a cup last season. They are setting the tone for old time hockey. Fighting & penalty minutes are up all over the league. They have great fans and sell out crowds every night. Look at Detroit this year, the place they call "Hockeytown." The team is winning like crazy playing the boring style of getting 1 or 2 goals and sitting on it & no fighting or physical play what-so-ever. And their own fans don't give a sh!t about boring wins.
Great fight, I wish they were all this way. Give the edge to May
These boys earned their five minutes. Classic fight and then some. Playoff intense. May a close victory.
Buy these guys some steak dinners. May might have the punch stat here but lets give these warriors a damn near draw. This is the kind of fight you congratulate your opponent for not wimping out and hugging. This will wind up in the top 10. Large Intestine Campbell even might have liked this one.
Closest and most entertaining fight ever.
Awesome fight. May switched it up and landed some great shots...Win to May.
outstanding!!! Slight edge May....
Great fight about time some peple started throwing blows instead of this huggie bear pussy shit most nhl fights have become
This was one of the best fights this year. Gotta give it to May although it was a close match.
if you didn't see the game May was interviewed at the end of period and said that he felt that Barch is where May was years ago trying to find his way in the league. if Barch has any career like Brad's we are going to have many great highlights coming. BEST FIGHT IN YEARS!!!!!!!!!1
Now thats how it's done!!!
I Agree with slshbleed, May seemed able to get make em count, and not get hit by any either.
One of the best fights I've seen this season. Both combatants deserve praise for the effort. Wish more fights were like this one.
best fight of the season by far
May by a nose. Great fight.
May did the most damage. If that were me - I'd be out, goodnight.
Very good fight, voting should be 80% draw, at least.
As the announcer said...."good scrap."
took a while for them to get started but May had it in the begg. but then Barch took the end with those punches to the chin!!! wish they didn't end the fight like that someone needed to take each other down!!! Pretty good fight!!!!
Barch held his own in this one. May threw a bunch of punches that really did no damage. I felt like Barch fought a good fight. As close to a draw as it gets. It was nice to see a real fight. Lately it seems more like two guys just holding on to one another and spinning around. This what fighting in hockey is supposed to be.
Wow! The exchange was terrific but Barch dotted more "eyes".
One of the best scraps of the year. The homers are obviously out in force for Anaheim. There's no way to call this a clear victory for either combatant, and I'm a big time Dallas fan. It is nice to see Barch not getting his ass kicked for once.
Once again May gives in and let's the refs separate them. He knows Barch is gonna swing until one of them goes down. May needs to hang in there or not accept the challenge, he's gotta have the refs step in every time....Watch the video of the fight before this one and read his lips "I'm tired, I quit"
A great fight between the two. I give props to Barch for sticking it out as well as he did, but May deserves the W in this one because he simply had more good hits than Barch did. A close one overall and one of the best fights of the season so far (it was awesome live, the crowd went nuts) but the win belongs to May.
the old man still has it
I thought it was a draw. There is often a problem with the announcers shouting out each time their guy throws, whether anything landed or not, and not mentioning some of the punches thrown by the opponent. It was a great fight though.
Great battle....plain and simple.
now that is entertainment! this has to be one of the best fights of the year.
Now that's a fight. Draw.
Great fight! What a scrap.
What a TILT!!!!!! I called it a draw but if I had to pick a winner with no draw it would be May!!!! Just because I think he is better with both hands . Classsic fight...Class act by Barch.........PRICELESS :) THE WINNER FANS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Great fight. That's old time hockey right there. Willing to take a punch to deliver one. I dont know if you can declare a winner in this one. Draw.
Barch tellin May bout the glove is almost as good as when Laraque was mic'd!!! 10 and a DRAW
great fight. definite draw. even though May is like 65 years old he can still throw 'em
That was an AMAZING fight. So good that I can't decide a winner no takedown both threw and landed lots of great shots! Thats probably the best fight i've seen all year!
Great fight, these two put on a show when they go, swing for the trees and play zero defense, now that's a fight!!!
Great fight! May with the victory. Both show class.
May gets the win. Someone should show this clip to Brashear amd Laroque the so called heavy weights. Instead of all this wrestling and trying oto hide your face, these gys went toe to toe...Good scrap...
Two super-willing guys just absolutely slugging it out. I have to give this one to May for the early, clean shots. Ouch.
great fight. both guys throwing some haymakers. definitely got to give it to May for landing more shots (not to the helmet).
Slight edge to May, I thought he landed a little better, but GREAT effort by both guys.
Wow, great fight, no wrestling. One of the best this season. Win for Brad May, but there was no domination.
Now this is what hockey fights are all about. Great scrap! draw to slight edge May
all you dumb asses out there we know you can't spell win for may and the only word you know is draw-may clearly gets the winand just think 15 years ago when may was barch'es age may would knocked his ass out.............
Looks like May dominated... Barch maybe snuck in one or two, but he should get 5 minutes for receiving.
"Kyle" fukkin idiots!!!! Read your screen you have up idiot!!! Great fight, gave the win to May.
Saw it live, great fight - MUCH better without having to hear Hayward at the game! They called Barch "Kyle" in the first fight these two had this year (in Anaheim, of course). Worst announcers in the league, least knowledgeable fans in the league, but they are entertaining to watch. May looked like it was '96 right there. The fight, aside from having split the other two fights this season, was a build-up from May absolutely levelling Zubov and then Robidas got in his face but wouldn't do anything about it. Barch came to the rescue late but the refs had already blown the whistle and got in between the crowd.
quhockey10 says "Anaheim has least knowledgable fans" O.K. smart guy, since Dallas is "hockey town U.S.A." I know that when Anaheim won the cup, it was out-rite. When Dallas won, they changed the rules for a game and handed them the championship. If you want to learn something, go ask D. Hasek or any one of the Sabres about it. By the way, since Dallas is the heart of hockey, how many NHL'ers are you guys putting out? Oh, zero. Do you know why? You don't produce kids from fucking farm animals
stortini,eager at el-this is how you do it!