brokenleg makes me laugh...keep up the good work! :)

Edge Phaneuf for at least holding his bearings sloppy sloppy scrap

Draw all day

Fight? What fight? Nothing really.

Draw. Crap fight between two of the sleeziest.

Shoving match really, they just sorta ran into each other,

Really surprised that these 2 fags took the visor off

Wrestling Match

"The Perfect Storm" Two assholes collide. At least Phaneuf "manned up" and took his protection off. Too bad Hartnell is all "sizzle and not steak."

Hartnell is so good looking he makes Lindy Ruff look like Sloth from the Goonies! Rocky Road?!?!!?

one bum fighting another bum. Not much of a fight. I don't think anything landed.

Called it a draw as nothing much landed from either. I am surprised they don't have the Comcast replay on here as Hartnell was mic'ed. It was funny hearing the want to go, here?, and the right now.

funny

I'm unsure of an edge to anyone.

Not a very convincing fight...I don't even think one solid punch landed except a wrestle to the ground. Have to give it a Draw.

Only a homer would vote one way or the other. Draw. Non contest.

that was a messy fight. Draw

Helmets off..gettn excited...circling around...then they slap eachother? I guess...dion w the takedown..no clear winner DRAW!

1 punch landed by "The Wool", the leafs can't even win a fight.

whoever voted for hartnell should be banned from any future votes. why does carcillo keep declining Orr yet continues a steady diet of Jeff Finger types ? i remember when Keith Jones had some respect as a player and as an announcer. Now he is just another pawn in the Phila Propaganda machine. The truth is that the Flyers were run out of their own building by Colton Orr....again !!!

Broad star "Annie" does her impersenation of her first day on skates and crashes to the ice. Slight edge to Dion

Hartnell can't fight, he can only cheapshot and run goalies. Gotta love how the Flyers fake tough guys let Orr RUN OVER thier goalie.

Phaneuf with the win ..only because Hartnell looked like he had epilepcy .. what the hell was he doing .. shaking all over the place .. with his head down .. looked like he was scared. Phaneuf was just getting ready couple punches thrown .. Phaneuf with a win even though not much of a fight.

hartnell fights like an epileptic clown. get a haircut hippie

Hartnell doing his Billy Ray Cyrus look-a-like and fighting like Miley. What was that anyway? Phaneuf wins for having a cool last name. A nothing contest. A phight to the phinish.? Naw...

There she blows ..pretty well sums up most Hartnell fights.

They were fighting on lava.

whats Dion thinking, hitting a lady?????? Woof Woof! Philadelphia Collins belches as Miss hartnell falls to the Ice, belch.......woof woof! Free Bart powwow...the school yard bully!!! LOL

Hartnell can flip those red rockstar locks around as much as he wants but he will still get his ass handed to him anytime he squares off with anyone of merit. What a clown.

phaneuf landed more so he won the fight.

The cowardly lion (Hartnell) can't fight. I like how he has to put his hair behind his ear before the fight. What a fairy. Get a haircut for god sakes. It doesn't make you look cool, it make you look like an a$$. Edge - Phaneuf

Nice energy, but nothing really got going because Hartnell lost his footing early. Would have been nice if they got going and held their balance. Phaneuf got in a couple quick shots then both went down. SLIGHT EDGE TO PHANEUF.

phaneuf won for sure

What's with the DO?!?!?!? Gimme a break, you don't deserve to wear that jersey. This years installment of Philly Punks is shameful and an embarrassment to hooliganism everywhere!!!!

Hartnell got his hair parted in that one though the Philadelphia paper called it a draw. The bigger story was the non-fight between Colton Orr and Dan Carcillo, who looked genuinely frightened at the prospect of going at it with Orr. Orr got sucked into stupid penalties that cost Toronto the game.

hartnell needs to stick to his hitting from behind fights and looks like a woman in the circus!!

I love the Flyers, but Hartnell is the laziest hockey player i've ever seen, no wonder the fight started at the blue line he never goes in the defensive zone.

Hahahaah! Hartnell is tryin to wrestle, Phaneuf lands a right hook. Dion wins.

Harntnell is a Pu$$y! He's okay guys, he fell on his hair!

Edge to Phaneuf. Hartnell showed the balance of a deer on ice.

Hartnell is a puke that needs a hair-cut out of desperation, what a pitiful looking puke he is!!! His fighting skill is extremely sup-par as well. I would personally drag him down to the ice by that carott-top of his. Dion ain't much himself in the fighting category either.

phaneuf pounded on that scumball hartnell.......hartnell is such a puzzy.

Fanooof dropped the visor?!?!? NO WAY!!!!! Heartless dropped the visor too I see, what has come of the Flyers and Maple Leafs. Next thing you know they're going to be going for cheesesteaks together after the game

Lots of emotion but not many punches really landed. Have to give the win to Phaneuf as he was the agressor and he may have landed a few.

I hate to say it, but Celine Dion won.

Two of the least-likable non-fighter-fighters... I'm giving the edge to the less hairy guy.

no contest

Good feeling to see Ronald McDonald get his ass kicked.

dion gets the win in this fight.

Not the best view but looks like Phaneuf landed the only punch and put Scotty down.

Nothing Better than SIDESHOW BOB getting schooled

Hartnell may be the worst fighter I have seen..If he cant bite or scratch he loses. What a joke. A typical Flyer fairy goon. Actually even if he bites and scratches he still loses. He should wear a big W for Wussie on his jersey.

first and foremost, Dion won that no doubt. hartnell was too busy being suffocated by his own hair. secondly, stopping hating on Phaneuf everyone. he's a good fighter and a good player and could easily kick any of your asses. so stop being losers. if you're going to comment on a fight, comment on the fight. don't complain about how you don't like the players because of other things.

1 punch, downgoes Caveman......... Anyone see how "side-show" Carcillo totally bitched out when ORR challenged him?Wouldnt even look in his direction.....

Win Dion Phaneuf.

PHANEUF: Dion got caught by one early, close one, edge Phaneuf.

Phaneuf with the win, good scrap for 2 non-heavyweights

Harntnell wanted to get in close fast and that didn't help him in this one. Easy win for Dion. All you clowns who yap about Phaneuf and his visor can finally shut your cake holes - at least for a night anyways.

hartnells hair was all over da place. W Dion

phaneuf gave that ginger a beat down

that was funny

That was embarrassing.....................

I saw this as a draw. It appeared that the weight of Hartnell's hair pulled him down to the ice. Hartnell should stick to the Geico commercials...

"Hey, let's seizure together!"

Another crap fight, if anyone gets the W it's Phaneuf. I gave it a DRAW

Phaneuf is a Bitch....

Huh. This is what happens when two pieces of crap fight......PowWow. Buttslam Bart!!

Neither one knows how to fight.

Slinging hair adds thrill to a fight - I gave this a 3. Otherwise it would've been a zero! Draw.

Nothing really happens.

What was that?

were they slapping each other? anyway ,yes dion the peon drops his bucket, and then defeats the lead singer for nickleback

Not only does Hartnell look like a girl; he fights like one too!

One has a girl's name, the other has a girl's hair. I love lesbian fights!

Phaneuf gets the win in this lower than average fight. I do appreciate the intensity of the two though

Phaneuf turns that butt pirate Hartnell's azz into a hat rack ... and "Dirty Sanchez" sissy Carcillo runs from the heavyweights and picks on girlie Finger ... what a PUSS ...