Crosby got one shot in. How does 43.3% think he won anything?
Ok... However admirable it may be that Crosby decided to take matters into his own hands and personally avenge... what he obviously considered to be ... a cheapish late hit... I have to believe that... considering the star's concussion history... ...Dubinsky must have "taken one for the league" here and held up on Crosby even allowing the Penguin's captain to land a few for good measure in the process It's the only explanation that makes any sense although the Blue Jacket would probably never admit it Of course every time Crosby fights the Penguins lose by virtue of his absence on the ice But would you really want to be the guy who threw the right hook that potentially ends his career? Silently self sacrificing win for Dubinsky even though he may have lost the actual fight
If Crosby would have stopped trying to pull Duby on top of him like a sissy, Duby would have kicked his ass. Instead, Crosby just tried to end it fast by falling down. What a sissy.
This is the biggest problem with this site... There is so much hate for the Pens and Crosby there will never be a fair rating. Even when Engo was on the Pens it was hard for him to get a fair shot. This fight should be a draw or slight edge for Crosby, but it's obvious how this is going. I could have predicted this outcome before looking at the fight or the votes
The hatred between these two boils over. Crosby landed the best punch but I can't spin this one way or the other. Draw.
I saw 1 punch land and it was Crosby's.
Haters gonna hate, hate, hate, hate, hate only significant strike was by Sid.... haters can sukit
Crosby got shrekt m8
Draw, nothing really happening
Crosby haters undoubtedly unite in the votes for DUMBinsky on this site. Only real damage done was by Sid, the clear winner.
Apparently Crosby's strategy was, throw a punch, oh crap it landed, fall down and let refs step in.
One punch landed by Sid, none by douchbinsky......sid's the winner
Some of the worst camerawork I have ever seen capturing a fight. Christ. I am calling it a draw because I can't really even see what happened for at least 20% of the "fight." Typical Dubinsky hug-fest.
Say what you want - both helmets were off which NEVER happens anymore, Crosby with the only punch to the face despite clearly looking for a take down. Have to give him the W.
Dubinsky didn't land any clear punches and even though Crosby almost lost his footing he was able to get right back up and counter with the ONLY hit I saw land which was a pretty solid head shot. If that hit wouldn't have landed I'd rate this a draw. However Dubinsky did a splendid job stopping Crosby's punch with his jaw so W for the Captain.
Edge to Crosby for the one and only punch. Hats off to him for taking on Dub. Not many super stars drop the gloves.
Not a Crosby fan...mostly because he is a whiner...He is the best hockey player in the world otherwise. This is another case of "What was the GM thinking". We all love it when a skilled guy, particularly one with the "C" drops'em. But that can't be in the best interest on the Pens...unfortunately they let their best response (Engelland) go to Calgary. Crosby man's up and lands a good right...the only punch of the fight...he wins. 4 for the fight.
As much as it perplexes me, I've got to give this one to the whiner. All Dubinsky managed was a couple of weak body punches which were more than countered by Sid's head shot.
Sorry but he dropped the gloves and immediately started trying to pull Dubinsky. Pussy move (as always with Crosby)....
The best player in the NHL is dropping the gloves.. Imagine he got hurt in this fight? Imagine Dubinsky knocked him square out!! That's a dangerous slope But, one of those test of compete and character I love seeing stars fight their own battles. I know I'm making a mountain out of this mole hill of a fight but, imagine the ammunition those anti-fighting rooster lickers would have gotten if this went sour for Crosby?? Fight was a 3 & Draw
I don`t really care who won or lost, Crosby should NOT have to fight, Pittsburgh as got to get a protector, that can play on the first line, to do this job. Would you pay big money to see Dubinsky play.
Crosby landed 1 punch, Dubinsky landed 0 but had the takedown. Boring draw
Did I just see teenage girls fighting after gym class?
Dubinsky starts off strong, then inexplicably stops allowing Crosby to land one. Ought to have finished the job.
crosby looks so funny and weak when he desperately tries to throw dubinsky down with no success...draw
I HATE Crosby but he dropped them with a pretty darn good fighter and in the interview acknowledge it was not much of fight, so good on him (can't believe I said that). Also good sportsmanship shown by Dubinsky whom could just pilled it on if he wanted to. He did just enough to protect himself and handle Sid. Also he was cool with his comments to the press. Nothing would been gained by tuning up Crosby or worse a fighter from the Pens goes after one the Montreal's skilled players.
That's not why you're on my fantasy team Sid....just stick to getting points, killer.
Good on both guys, Dubi being Dubi and Crosby standing up for himself. Crap fight and a draw but it's more than that, something this league sorely needs. Passion!
I feel like Crosby could actually be a decent fighter if he knew how to, instead of trying to just bring the guy down use your strength and hold with one and chuck a few with the other before you try and take it to the ice. Draw, nothing special, heat of the moment grapple
Wow. Crosby can't fight for crap. All he's doing is trying to get the sweater up over Dubinsky's face. At least Dubinsky was trying to actually hit Crosby. What a wuss.
More cream puffs in this vid than you'd find in a French bakery.
It was not so much about the fight. It was about there was a fight.
How is this not a draw??? Draw!
Not a Pens fan nor a Crosby fan but I like the spunk from the superstars. Oh Yeahh!
Very even; Both get the same amount of punches to land, and while Crosby wrestles Dubinsky down, it is a desperation move that lands Sid on the bottom. Both had had enough.
Dubinsky tries to take Crosby's head off with an elbow and Crosby responds.Fight was a draw!.What is wrong with Pittsburgh is why Crosby has to fight as his team mates do not come in and stand up for him! Gretzky never had to worry about this shit as either Semenko or Mcsorely would have killed Dubinsky.
Good for Sid for saying "I've had enough crap." And good on Dubie for just grappling instead of throwing. It is Sid Crosby for Christ sakes DrAW...
more wresting than fightig
Crosby is a sneak and a cheap shot. The little pussy trued to jump Dubinsky. Cindy can't fight. i am looking forward to the day she gets what she has coming to her.
Hold on for dear life hug fest. I heard they went out on a date after the game.
was that a fight??
pathetic, the one punch crosby got off was nullified by the several pulldown attempts he made to get them to the ice.....
Dubinsky plays a pretty gritty game, but I would never consider him a great fighter or even an overly tough guy, and everyone know Crosby is a poof..so there ya go, crap fight..I'm surprised the purses weren't brought out and sent a'swingin..lol
Anyone who voted for Cindy should have the fight card priviledge revoked,...throw 1 punch then jump on the ground, Dubinsky should have pounded that girls face into the glass..............
Duby gets the nod, but only because Sid freaked out when someone finished their check on him.
Brandon the win with take downs and a couple of shots .....crappy fight anyway lol
Crosby throws a quick punch and then pulls Dubinsky down on top of him so that he can't throw back. Just furthering his reputation.
It was embarrasing watching Dubinsky try not to hurt Cindy. Cmon really, if your gonna fight fight to win or dont drop the gloves at all.
Cant win if you end on your back ... pussy. Doobie held up like play fighting with his kids over a timbit.
Crosby never gets a vote because he is a pussy.
Crosby threw one punch, fell to his knee, then got tackled. This hardly counts as a fight.
Looks like a fight at high school between girls just pulling clothes.
Crosby's such a dick.
I have watched this 4-5 times. There are a few punches landed to the body by Brandon. And one good headshot by Sidney. Interesting and improbable fight . I am split but will lean towards Mr. Dubinsky. The close captioning on the broadcast listed Sidney Crosby as "Sidney Ashtray" at one point. Ughh.
Dubinsky got 2 decent punches in Crosby Got 1 decent punch in All in all it was a hug fest until Crosby decided to pull guard like he was in BJJ practice but i still think Dubinsky won the Hug-fest
Sneaky, whiny, cry baby Cindy Crosby. Isn't he due to be concussed again? This isn't a fight. Cindy jumps Big Nose and nothing happens. I give the bout to Big Nose.
Cindy needs to get a gender change and be a man. Dubinsky beats him just for tolerating the annoying big toothed creep.
at least cindy dropped em...still lost
Crosby oonly tried to drag Dubinsky down, when he couldn't, then Sydney throws his only punch . I agree with Benn Wilson
Princess Crosby trying to end fight the whole time by trying to pull Dubber to ice...pansy..
Cindy trows a temper tantrum .... falls..... and cries ... waaaa
Glad to see Sid drop the mitts, but he needs concentrate on getting points other than PIMS.
playful little scrap.... Dubie wins
Cindy pusses out again to avoid a beat-down. Win Dubinsky.
Dubi pulled up thinking lines men were coming to Cindy's rescue.
Crosby landed a good hit, looks like Dubinsky landed a couple inside uppercuts and also wins the wrestling match.
Cindy gets rag dolled. Not much happened here otherwise.
Crosby is a little bitch.
Sidney scored one punch pulled Dubinsky on top of him. He is such a hard guy to like and certainly not the face of the NHL like Bettman wanted.
HOW DID PEPOLE SAY CROSBY WON CROSBY GOT SMOKED
Duby wins by decision
It was a lot of positioning but Dubinsky put it to Sid.Sid got in a good punch at the end but really he didn't do much in this one.
crosby is a punk and a diver
Haha Dubinsky almost got dummied by a girl. Dang Dubinsky not much get to fight sindy crosby,you should have blasted his teeth out but you barely handle him.Dubinsky your a weak ass sissy
Crosby w/ the slight edge but Dubinsky took the Pens best player off the ice for 5 minutes so good job by him.
By some modern miracle on ice Dubinsky manages to lose a crap fight to Sid the kid using some form jackie chan style falling over kung fu. Case and point this is why dubinsky isn't on the rangers anymore.
Close but a win for Crosby Not a fan but I appreciate he dropped the mitts as a captain
Hate to say it, but Syndie the best shot in.
At least Crosby did get ONE in.
I've always thought that Dubinsky was pretty much a wuss....this shows it. The player he likes to torment the most just took him to the woodshed. Too bad Crosby haters had to watch him handle himself just fine against a guy that is bigger and fights more than he does.
Crosby gets the best shot in, Dubinsky throws more but they are landing on equipment or are glancing blows. I give it to Sid on a forgettable scrap.
Dubinsky landed nothing= loser
I'm voting a win for Crosby just to off set those who are voting for Dubinsky. Should be a draw.
World's best player actually lands the only punch in a fight with a B grade player who fights often. Once they moved that stick out of the way that Crosby was slipping on, he showed his strength and won over Dubinsky. Also, Crosby slipped on the 2nd stick at the end, he did not pull down Dubinsky to try to "save himself". Win Crosby
Few punches thrown. Ok Fight
Dubinsky started out well. Crosby didn't want to fight he tried to throw Dubinsky to the ice right away to end it.
Ben Wilson ....your insane if you believe what you said ....lol DubDub has been feeling tough as of late ....I suspect he will soon get that knocked out of him
would not even call that a fight. BORING
WASTE OF TIME FIGHT( LIKE MOST 0F THE COMMENTS ) ONE IN PARTICULAR
Like he said, it wasn't much of a fight.
this did not live up to the hype... it's was weak and embarrassing. draw, but the real loser was me for sitting through it.
Not much of anything, Crosby trying to wake up his troops
Hard to call that a fight. I've seen better in girls' hockey. Draw.
I agree with Behn's review. Very odd looking scrap, but Crosby did stand up for himself and dropped the gloves. Draw
I don't know how anybody calls it anything but a draw. There were Crosby landed the best shot, but it wasn't a winning shot. A crap, nothing fight like this should never have a winner assigned to it. Draw = 18%? Should be more like 90%, allowing for homers and such.
Crosby pulls Dubinsky down before anything can really happen in this fight. Dubinsky landed a couple soft uppercuts early, then Crosby landed a decent over hand right and then decided he had enough. Typical Crosby fight, throw a couple then fall down before he can really get hit. This one was a clear draw, anyone who says otherwise is a homer.
. I love the tools who voted for Sid because too many voted for Duby...Thank you for being the moral compass of the fight site. Draw. A 2. ...1 punch and a tackle doth not equal a win lads
Dubinsky didn't get any shots in and Crosby had two or three strong ones. I'm sorry but that "takedown" wasn't enough. Winner Crosby.
Not a great fight, but Crosby landed a hell of a right
Dubinsky instigated the fight and got the starters edge So he basicly jumped Crosby then when Crosby started to Pound on him Dubinsky Sat his Fat Ass on Crosby but Crosby definetly won the fight
it's not even about who won or got the most punches in, it's about the time of the game and the heat of the moment, Crosby as a captain took matters into his own hands to boost his team and that's why he gets the upper hand in this bout, a very captain like move on sids part ..
Wow. Terrible terrible fight. Neither of them look like they've thrown a punch in their life
That was a total waste of time.
You know how you hear about these guys that dream about sleeping with a girl, and dream about sleeping with a girl, and dream about sleeping with a girl, and then, out of the blue they end up in the sack with that girl? And then they can't get it up, because they're so surprised it actually happened? Looks like that's what happened to Dubinsky. He's going to spend the rest of his life thinking about the time he got to fight Sidney F'in' Crosby, and he just couldn't make it matter.
Syd got a couple of partials in. Nobody did any damage in this tug o war.
Sid can't fight and Brandon would catch a certain kind of hell if he rung him up. <shrug> crap fight.
I see every Pens fan rang in to night. To the fight it was about time Sid the "Kid " drop his gloves I thought they where glued on. Very weak fight draw.
Eh... just more Sidney Crybaby getting upset when Dubinsky tried checking him against the boards and missed. Both players get maybe one punch in, but it's obvious Sidney didn't really want more than to rile up his team, and Brandon didn't want to kill him.
I have to say this is not sid's job to be fighting although I think Dubinsky does a heck of a job on Sid everytime they play!! Bring the darn old NHL back!! Also I remember early in the year Steve Downey saying this wouldn't happen to Sid or Geno, I haven't seen Downey win 1 fight yet this season! For the fight draw!! Bring back Big Mac!!
At least Crosby didn't go "angry chimpanzee" on Dubinsky unlike a previous fight that Crosby was in. Couldn't pick a winner here.
Draw. Cyndi got the best of Dubinsky but Dubinsky got Crosby off the ice for 5 minutes. Dubinsky should be ashamed of himself for fighting a girl.
A lot of Pens fans voting...Crosby pull Dubinsky down to stop a beating his way...Good player, but a cheap shot artist......Draw PS: how is this fight a 3.6
You could tell Sidney was thinking "I've made a terrible mistake" from about 5 seconds in. not as bad as Kessel swinging his stick like a bat.
Nice to see Dubinsky knock the lid off of Sid after Crosby got a little chippy with him. Too bad the fight was a little lackluster. Win Dubes.
Crosby was holding on for his life. Dubi went soft on him.
Only one significant head shot landed by Crosby near the end. Dubinsky did land a good body blow.
crosby landed best shot. pretty much a draw.
Close tilt. At least Crosby shows some spirit on a team that is sleepwalking through the second half of the season.
Bitch and moan about Crosby is a wimp and when he actually steps up, it's the same mularkey
I give the edge to Crosby, landed two good ones, Dubinsky got in a good one. You know its bad when your star fighting, you got a problem. Good for Crosby for stepping up, good for Dubinsky for not turning away. However, this should send a message to management that the pens need someone tough, but it won't, because of the Pen's crusade on fighting, which will haunt them for years. 4 fight, very close, both combatants a 4, Crosby voted winner. Could go either way, or even draw.
Have to give it to Sid because he didn't wait for any other Pen to get things going. I am sure some knuckle heads will still call Sid names. Makes them lower than whale poop.
Decent fight, Crosby got a good shot in.
Not much of a fight, but Crosby landed the only punch. Happy to see Crosby drop his gloves.
Sid finally had enough of Dubinsky's BS and fought. Did OK.
Crosby with win! F you haters! The right wins!
Boring......wish that Syd would've tried to exchange a bit, but he still gets the weak nod over the joke dubinsky.
Fight wasn't exactly a thriller other than who was involved. One punch connects, thrown by Sid. Edge to the hated 'sissy'.
Crosby win... lets not over think this.... i was at the game and still have no idea how they dont ride off into the sunset with a 5-1 win with how that building was rocking after the fight.
I give Crosby credit for standing up for himself. The thing about Crosby that is not mentioned very often is how strong he is. It was a close fight but against a very good fighter in Dubinsky, Crosby showed he can do pretty good for himself. Slight edge to Crosby.
How on Gods green earth does anyone rate Dubinski as the winner in this? Style points? I don't think he even gets those. Crosby kept the taller guy off balance and landed a big right right into Dubinskis mush. You guys are embarassing yourselves.
Good to see Sid the kid mix it up!
You can twist it and turn it all you want...wasn't much of a fight, but Sid held his own and then some against a guy who is bigger and more experienced at fighting...and landed the only decent punch...win Sid
Crosby got the shot that took Dubinsky down. That's why he gets the win.
I would say it was a draw fight
dubinsky is what he is, a punk. Only landed by Crosby, easy win for sid
since when is there :30 second ads for these videos? faaakin lame
Love seeing Crosby drop the gloves Great seeing one of the best players in the NHL stand up for himself by throwing punches against a pretty tough guy This is Crosby's 7th career scrap So he's not really a stranger to this.. Still, I think Dubinsky gets the dub here Now I dislike Crosby as much as anyone else There's no reason for him to bitch and moan like he does For God sakes he's an exceptional hockey player But ya gotta love seeing him show this side of his game
crosby trying hard to pull himd one down. did land one in panic mode, then threw himself down quick.. ha ha
Sid landed the first one. Dubinsky threw the next few not sure what landed. Then Crosby landed the best punch of the fight at the end. Majority of fight was pulling and position finding. Crosby gets narrow win for landing best punch of few that connected.
A lot of Sid haters on this site.....Dumbinsky with the big size advantage gets his ass beaten by an angry goal scorer.....what a loser....Crosby takes the win. Why all the votes for Dubinsky....he did nothing
Hey, Dubinsky; didn't your parents teach you never to hit a girl?
Not much action to judge by...Crosby lands one to the face, Dubinsky may have slipped an uppercut in. Crosby wins a close one.
Nice try, Sid. Next time, let the big boys handle the fighting. 'kay?
Anyone who says Crosby won is blind he landed one glancing shot and Dubinsky landed one or two.
Crosby decides to take matters into his own hands, then instantly sees the error in his ways and changes his mind mid-sissy-slap-fest... Shades of Shane o'brien vs the boogeyman
I've seen this fight from like 5 different angles by the time this video was posted. I can see the rage and hate from both Crosby fans and haters already. Not a great fight, but come on, when you've got someone like Crosby fighting, it's pretty entertaining. Each guy really only landed 2 punches, and Dubinsky might have a close edge here, but because I'm a biased homer, I'm gonna vote draw. Loved the fight for the entertainment value though.
Cindy pulled him down just in time, too bad. I would LOVE to see her split open.
DUBI cant even beat CINDY
No matter how much I may want to vote for one gentleman or the other, I objectively see this as a draw. While Bettman's (and Mario's) heart may have been in his throat, this is what makes hockey the best sport out there. I am almost tempted to Crosby-bash so Pens fans can send me erudite and well crafted prose . . .
How could anyone vote Crosby?
Dubinsky didn't land a single punch yet he has 45% of the vote lol
Although it pains me to see a pollock take a loss, Dubinsky lost one here. First of all Doober, pick on someone your own size. Secondly, I bet you didn't know that, even though it's far and few in between, Crosby (our captain) has never lost an NHL fight, and won this one as well. and third, well, err, hey, JCFring: Chiuda la vostra bocca.
Dubinsky won the fight, landing a decent uppercut and then kind of let up a bit after that...but still embarrassing to not destroy Cindy, lol.....
This was pathetic, looked like an old episode of Love Boat. Crosby sure is struggling on the score sheet , something just doesn't look right with him.
Lots of Penguins homos here....
Go Dubinsky, I've been waiting for sidney to drop the gloves. Sorta hugfest until the end where dubinsky clearly got the takedown
Crosby only want to drag Dubinsky down. Dubi with few upper cuts and the win.
Everyone voting Dubinsky is a biased moron. He didn't do crap! I was going to vote draw, but voted Crosby to compensate.
Kinda slow, Sid got the better of Dubinsky though, Dubinsky never landed a head shot and really only threw one punch into shoulder pads.