| Date / Time | Away / Home Team | Away / Home Player |
| Dec 29, 2008 | New York Islanders | Mitch Fritz |
| 1pd 06:10 | New York Rangers | Colton Orr |
| You must login to vote. You can sign up for free if you do not have an account already. |
| Colton Orr | 62.2% | |
| Mitch Fritz | 21.8% | |
| Draw | 16.0% | |
| From 331 votes with an average rating of 7.6 | ||
| 1pd 07:48 | Mike Comrie | vs | Nigel Dawes |

I'm not a Colton Orr fan but yeah I agree he is nudging up close to the top as the best fighter in the NHL. To boot he is getting more ice time from Renney for being a better hockey player. I've even seen him on the Rangers power play this year.