slight edge to konopka
Albeit a Flyers fan, I call this one a draw. Konopka started out better, but Carcillo evened it up as the fight went on. Great effort by both guys.
This ones too close..both threw some that landed..no clear winner
Nice 10rounder right here with some vicious haymakers. Give Carcillo credit for hanging in there. Konopka had him down but actually couldn`t finish the job .Call it a draw though for Carcillos persistence
Slight edge to Carcillo but easily could be called a draw.
Excellent scrap between two evenly matched fighters (i.e. average skills) who got going, and just refused to quit. Carcillo started out typically ''Carcillian'' with some cheap stick-work, followed by allowing himself to get out -positioned, and finally punched to the ice... But then... faster than you can say ''pop goes the weasel'', he springs back up channelling Mel Bridgeman, and proceeds to launch an impressive comeback using both hands (somehow) effectively... Draw out of respect for the great effort from both guys.
Awesome scrap! These two did a heck of a job and I saw it a draw...
Awesome tilt, had to call it a draw out of respect for both of them going forever.
Lots of punching back and forth, hard to pick a winner. I say its a draw.
Good fight, draw
Good bout between the guys...I've seen Konopko fight in the AHL....don't remember him being this tough
Good go between two agitators.Both landed some good shots.Draw in this tilt. When is Carcillo gonna step up in weight class? Alot of people talk about Lucic picking his spots but has Carcillo ever gone with a heavy?
dear homers draw signed fan of neither team
word to your moms, i came to drop bombs
Good fight I dont see how have of you idiots thought Carcillo won because that was a draw in my right opinion
first contender for fight of the year
This was a real good fight. Konopka got the early edge and carcillo finished up strong. I called it a draw.
Draw edge to Carcillo
old school hockey fight!
all konopka......easy win for konopka....... carcillo had to go and get his face stitched up while konopka went straight to the penalty box.
How do u a holes think carcillo won he got his ass kicked
Carcillo won this fight, end of discussion.
Traded same amount and ferocity of blows. The man-handling of Carcillo by Konopka to the point of tossing him into the boards, shredding his jersey, and the take-down gets him the win in my book.
KONOPKA WITH THE SLIGHT EDGE THAT PUSS BOY CISSYRILLO WITH HIS JERSEY OFF AND ARM FREE STILL COULD'NT MUSTER A WIN
Konopka won this close fight.
Great bout. Z with the split decision
Wow, Great fight overall
Konopka had more hits, but Carcillo definitely had his moments. It will be very interesting seeing more battles (and we will) between these two. it's so good to see there two slug it out, instead of wasting their energy playing hockey.
great long tilt!
I don't see how Carcillo won this fight. All he could land were short lefts while Konopka gassed himself landing haymakers on Carcillo. Still, they both held their ground, but I think Flyers fans are so ardent about winning, they'd see a different story if they just watched the fight.
im a flyers fan and carcillos my fav but im honest and konopka won u guys got this one wrong for sure
Car Bomb got in a couple of heavy shots. Zero Can't Fight Ya was trying to rally the troops with little effect--the Islanders were run off the ice last night.
Tough to see early cause the stripes were in the way, but the fight was even until Carcillo landed that hard right. Very slight edge to Carcillo in a good tilt.
carcillo gets the win in this fight.
Carcillo takes this one.
solid fight . . . to all of you philly haters, kiss it!
Very good tilt. NARROW WIN Carcillo! He took over clearly later. Konokpa had good moment early on.
These 2 are average weight and a little over the top with the shenanigans but they have a good honest rockem sockem bout here. Carbomb comes back from an awkward position to get the better of the fight as it rumbled on-- got some good shots in later in what was other wise a close marathon. Outside of Orr- Engelland, one of the best fights this year. Kono gets clocked with several big rights because he ripped Carbomb's jersey, freeing up the right bombs. Kono clearly not happy about this outcome and his team getting clobbered in the game.
Great tilt. Once Carcillo got back up he was able to take over and earn the W.
Carcillo is sweet
Slight edge to Carcillo with all the jabs. Good tilt.
Carcillo - slight edge - excellent fight. Wish they were all like this.
Good long fight.. Great endurance by both. Had Konopka early till Carcillo got his right arm free from his gear. Shows here that Konopka has a good chin and can take a few without getting rattled. Slight edge to Carcillo.
great tilt. was at the game and saw it first hand, carcillo landed much more than konopka. two great fighers going at it...but carcillo with the win
I'll give the edge to Car Bomb on heart alone.
atta boy carcy
konopka thought he was gonna kick carcillo's ass.sure it looked like it at the beginning but carcillo earns decisve win at the end.....gave it 9
Carcilo EASILY. Landed more punches, simple really.
awesome fight.... i wish the refs let them finish what they started at the end
Prett darn good fight
Clear win for Carcillo. No doubt.
Awesome Fight. Slight edge Carbomb. But it was pretty damn close
whole lotta toughness from both sides, carcillo edges him out in an awesome bout
Carcillo with the win. The retarded chemical experiment gone bad "Zenon Konopka" got his ass whipped in this one, since Carcillo did not want to fight, with the Flyers whipping the bastards from Long Island big time.
early nominee for fight of the year
Man, I hate Carcillo. However, I must admit that the dude can scrap.
Car Bomb with the impressive come back. Great tilt, can't wait for more of these later in the season.
Carcillos the best . Middleweight champ of the NHL
One of the best fights this year. Both going toe to toe. Long fight with an edge to Carcillo
Da bomb went off!!!! Konopka cant say shizzle about him tough mother f er!
Great fight with toe to toe slugging!Best fight i,ve seen this year!Give the edge to carcillo for landing and throwing more!
Beautiful, Win to Carcillo in this one but Konopka in the later fight.
This is the carcillo i love to see, not the pussy he;s played as ever since he got to philly
unbelievable effort by carcillo
Great fight, glad the linesmen let them go, especially since they both went to the ice at one point. Carcillo gets it for landing more punches.
Car Bomb was working both hands against Konpka and got in some big hits, def. give this one to Carcillo
THESE BOYS GOT IT ON GREAT FIGHT i GAVE IT TO dANIEL FOR THE WAY HE CAME BACK AT THE END AND LANDED BIG
Clear win for Carcillo.
Great fight, went on forever
Carcillo was good as usual!
Draw, great fight by both combatants
Wow I love Konopka, Carcillo took some shots early on but came back with some bombs of his own. Finding it hard to pick a winner so I'm sitting on the fence in this one.
Pretty Damn good fight gave it a draw
this was a great fight. Both guys throwing some good shots and a long tilt as well! To close to call. It s a draw! FOTW im sure!
WOW ! Great fight 10/10
I'll give this one a draw, but overall for the night Konopka goes home the winner.
I don't understand where the 8s and 9s are coming from for how good this fight was. Is it because it went so long? Because Carcillo had his jersey torn? Because Carcillo is hated and got beat up? I just saw a lot of spinning and dancing and Carcillo landed one good punch, and Konopka landed several. Easy win for Konopka.
Konopka with the edge
Great long fight, not too many landed though, but a good fight. Konopka landed the better punches, Carcillo landed more. Draw.
Ok, who's on crack and voting this fight an 8???? May Joe Kocur come to your house and school you on what a good fight is. This is ok--but just because they swing a lot and keep swinging and mostly missing for a long time doesn't make it a good fight. Both guys show they're not really that good at this. Draw.
Draw, both controlled at different times. Carcillo got an arm loose from the jersey, up until then Konopka had the win hands down. Carcillo is still a full out tool.
Nice effort by both -- draw ( one of the few times I've seen Konopka do more than just wrestle ).
Great endurance by both,cudos to the stripes for letting them finish.
Wow! A rare Carcillo win.
great fight and as much as i hate to write it, win carcillo!
Great job by Carcillo. One of the best fights Ive seen in a while! The CSNPhilly feed was better with a more overhead view.
Comeback Victory for DC Comics....good tilt
This was a really nice fight and effort from both guys.......I believe Mr dirty definately landed the more effective punches.....Come on Big Behn!!!! He was pulled to the ice ...Not punched....i do like the Bridgeman mention tho!!!! Mel was a Rock em sock em fighter back in his Philly days and supremely Dirty!!!!! Excellent TILT!!!!!!
I really like Konopka and can't stand Carcillo, but I have to give the win to the latter.
Really good fight, great stamina by both. Dumb ass announcer said he needed to get worked on in the locker room....his jersey was ripped, he wasent bleeding or anyhting
Great fight. FOTY possibility. Win Carcillo.
Great Fight! Carcillo was on the ropes but came back with two devasting combos...wow!
Konopka early, Carcillo later...I give a slight edge to Carcillo in this round.