ther hair is beautiful

very entertaining

I hate to say this but i think the moderator of the fight overrated this fight. There were about 3 punches that were bulls-eye shots flush on the face. Other than that, many of the punches were just punches to the back of the head.

Draw.

good punches landed by both guys!

Very enjoyable

Very good fight. Draw

the both deserve the call of a draw. awesome fight!

What a great fight!!! Draw!

Good tilt back and forth was a draw in my eyes. Turn off the sound and watch what really happens, both guys banged and each got in some hard shots.

good leather thrown by both, carcillo early, dorsett late. power is lacking with both , though

What a fight!

great fight huggy bear are u watchin this is how to fight

Great middleweight bout. Too close to call a winner. Watched it 5 times and can't say either guy did enough to squeak out the win. Gonna call it a draw and wait for the rematch.

Good scrap. Carcillo can throw and take a punch, although I think if he hit my 10 year old sister square in the jaw with his 10 hardest haymakers, he couldn't knock her over.

That was a solid most excellent draw. Anyone giving a solid win to either must be watching something else.

I'm not sure how the majority thinks Dorsett won this. Hit the mute button to cut out the homerism. Great, EVEN fight here. Loved the ferocity and passion in this bout.

My favorite fight so far this year, hands down!

ok now that's a hockey fight.....1:20 second marathon bout......this is the FOTY so far IMHO.....i am going to call it a draw and say if there's a winner its the fans well done boys...hope they keep the 5'11" Dorsett up in the show because he deserves it after this effort

agreed oil fan!

Great fight....Draw.

The fight speaks for itself. Fantastic!

Both seemed to come back from great shots. Best fight this year.

Great fight! Both players landed same amounts of blows Draw

That fight was awesome. And both guys landed several shots. Had to call this one a draw.

great fight. draw. for the record carcillo didnt get dropped by the left hand as they said.. he slipped and dorsett missed both shots

That was sweet, both guys took huge shots and kept coming back. Both guys threw good flurries of punches.

awesome fight... 2nd best fight of the year behind the cote and godard fight. Had to give this one a draw.

WOW! what a back and forth fight. I had to give that a draw both guys landed a few good ones. Carcillo is really gonna ba good, he can fight, hit, score and take people off there game. Dorsett looks like he will be the same but not as good a point producer.

to me, the best one of the year so far is right here.

Best fight I've seen all year. Love these scrappy dudes.

thats a hockey fight.

i thought this was a very good active fight.

This was a great fight! Both players were connecting solid punches. Both players landed equal amounts of punches. Draw

Great fight too close for a victor DRAW

Fight of the year so far in my opinion. Both guys threw and landed lots. Wow.

What a fight?? Man there was some energy

Draw, agree that the announcer had pompoms and I don't care about either team or player. They both scored great shots and Carcillo might have scored his best one when he fell. They're both are going to feel this one in the morning.

Great toe to toe battle. Draw.

Fantastic....

Fight of the year, so far! And between two guys, I don't usually even care for! Best series of intro shots I've seen in a long time, by Carcillo, followed by a host of different suprise counter attacks by Dorsett. Friggin awesome! That's the way it's done. Had to call it a draw out of mutual respect for the stamina of both guys.

Great Fight! These guys were really working and fearless. Very entertaining. No edge from my end. Just a great job by both players.

Speechless. That was a battle for the ages!

DRAW

The most amazing thing about these fights is how many direct blows to the face/head these guys can take without going down. Awesome fight. Very gentlemanly of both players to take off the helmets. Dorsett may have landed one or two more solid shots but I'm still marking it a draw.

Probably one of the greatest fights thus far and it will take a lot to surpass this one. Great bombs and determination from both combatants. DRAW but a 10point draw.

Two words,fucking awesome scrap! Easily best fight of the year so far.DRAW

draw all the way

Outstanding! CD with the first two, DD with the next two.. and so on and so on and so on...

Awesome fight. Who needs heavyweight hugfests when you can watch this?

Huge fight!!

Great Fight. Candidate For Fight Of The Year Right There. Had To Call This One A Draw. Way To Be Carcillo And Dorsett

Thats old school hockey ,hate and passion i love it

awsome!

This is what I like to see in hockey fights. Just think in the good ol' days there could be two or even three of these going on at once! Both players were swinging for each others heads non stop. Think about that when people talk about penalties and suspensions for head shots in game action. Let them go I say! This was the best fight I've seen in a while. Both won in this one with a great show of hockey grudge matches. I loved seeing all the flying fists and the linesmen let them go for as long as they could without getting hit themselves. A great draw!

AWESOME FIGHT!

Great Fight!!! Too close to call

FOTY canidate

Great fight. I voted it a draw. Carcillo landed what looked to be harder punches, but Dorsett seemed to land more. Definite FOTY nominee

Now this is a fight. Lots of punching and little grappling. I gave this one a draw.

One of the best fights so far this year. I'd love to give both wins, so I called it a draw. Someone tell the announcers it was Carcillo swinging and missing that made him go down, not a punch. Great fight!!

Zack are you watching....

Too bad Dorsett broke his finger and is gonna be hung up for some time.

Wow, what a scrap! Both guys were throwing bombs...hard to pick a winner here.

VERY good fight the best ive seen this year better then the barch and may fight last year very good job by both guys. Carcillo got Dorsett a good one on the cheek right at the beginning.

Best fight of the year so far for me.

What a terrific fight, kept going and going and making me happier and happier. I vote it a draw, both never gave up and both kept throwing.

AWESOME!!! This is one of the best fights I have ever seen. Both throwing bombs from start to finish. No winner here, clear draw and props to both combatants!!

Great Fight. Draw. Dorsett broke his hand on Carcillo's head, He's now on I.R.

Who says Heavyweights make great fights? WOW!!!!!!!!

Now that is what I call a hockey fight! Carcillo did as expected, but man that kid Dorsett hung in there and gave it right back after taking a couple of broadside wallops to the jaw. Fight of the year so far!

unreal tilt

Fight of the year so far

American commentary sucks. It makes you wonder if they were actually watching the fight. Dorsett didn't land a left at the end. Carcillo lost his balance. They refs came in because the fight lasted a long time. Regardless, a great fight. Exactly what you would expect from Carcillo. And now I am officially a fan of Dorsett. Draw.

Great fight defiantly my choice for fight of the year... So far The passion and determination showed by both fighters is what makes hockey so great.

For sure the top fight so far this season.

WOW !!!!!!! Fight of the year, I'll watch this one 10,000 times. Old school bomb throwing with each gladiator landing jackhammer blows. My shorts are crazy glued to my abdomen after this one !

FOY candidate here!!! Now that is what we like to see. I call it a draw. Dorsett is busier, controls much of the fight and lands some great shots. But Carcillo seems to land more as well as the harder shots. Not sure what happens at the end here. But I am pretty sure the CBJ announcer gets it wrong when he says "He (DD) dropped 'em with a left there!".

ARE YOU KIDDING ME! Fing great show.

What a hockey fight should be - punches, not hugging. Great bout worthy of honor and impossible to declare either a winner or a loser.

This fight was back and forth. End the end Carcillo landed some head shots on Dorsett who started to "Turtle" I would call it a draw. IOnly comment was Carcillo went to pentalty box and Dorsett went to the locker room and stayed until the next period. So you can figure who won on your own.

What a scrap, Carcillo early then Dorsett then Carcillo then Dorsett again, helluva scrap gotta call it a draw.

Havent seen a better fight all year. How Dorsett took that first barrage is unbelievable. They both landed huge ones

Great fight. Reminds of the fights from the 70's and 80's.

what an fight toe to toe action great fight to both carcillo and dorsett does not get any better than that.

Un-freaking-believable. That was the best I've seen in some time.

It's christmas time !! and these guys are real giver !!!

Worthy of PPV.

To this day, still the best fight I've ever seen.

dorsett won hands down

Great fight that alot of heavy's could learn from. Very entertaining bout with lots thrown and alot caught. I give the edge to Dorsett for landing the harder shots.

Has to be one of the best of the year. For anyone who asks what happened to old toe to toe hockey fights, look no further Both threw em, both took em, then threw some more. From start to finish non stop action. Dorsett lands at the end and takes the W. Hell of an effort by both.

Gotta love western conference hockey.

Danny boy gets his ears pinned back!

Great tilt there, lads. I've gotta give 'er to Dorsett though. It looked like he had control longer in this fight and didn't hold back trying to avoid shots like Carcillo did. Plus, he had Carcillo off balance more than once and the shots that Carcillo started throwing wildly at the end of the fight only connected with the back of Dorsett's head and shoulders; a desperation move as the refs moved in. To the obviously American announcers...please don't call hockey players "gamers" ever again. That is all. :]

the western leauger won this great tilt,nasty must of gave dorsett some pointers,ah hell that might even be a draw,but they sure left it on the ice,took no prisoners.

Good scrap. Not so much of that pansy grab and hold we see from so many other "fighters"

good solid fight slight edge to dorsett

Great fight win Dorsett.

That was a good one. Very energetic, not much sleeve tugging, just blow after blow. A slight edge to Dorsett who landed the better punches.

Great scrap, Had it as a draw untill that last flurry from Dorsett took down Danny. what a Beaut.

WOW. Dorsett landed so many KO punches but Carcillo would not go down till the end. I laughed so hard with the first phantom punch Carcillo threw.

I think Dorsett landed more and better quality, may have surprised Carcillo with his ability to throw with both hands. Very entertaining. I would like to see Rypien get healthy again and take on Dorsett, (went with Carcillo already and won) in a middleweight battle.

wow very good bout...sure contender for the fight of the year !

One of the best fights so far. I would give the edge to Dorsett. He landed the better shots, but a close fight.

FOTY so far

wow awesome!!

Very slight edge to Dorsett for dropping Carcillo at the end. This was going to be a draw.

Fight of the year so far! Carcillo has a knack for getting a quick punch in before they grab a hold. A lot of people try this and miss ending up off balance. I think they both landed about an equal number of shots. Dorsett landed the better shots. Slight edge to Dorsett. You can make a case for scoring this one win lose or draw.

Dorsett broke his hand and is now out indefinitely. I'll vote for the guy that landed the most quality punches. Win to Dorsett.

Dorsett with the W. Props to Carcillo for being able to take (& give) a punch. The heavyweights are fun to watch, but these guys got busy fast & kept at it. I believe Dorsett was right up there in PIM before he got caught in the numbers game and came back down to Syracuse (didn't have to clear waivers).

GREAT SCRAP,FIRST REAL GOOD ONE IN A WHILE,YEAR GOT OFF TO A GREAT START AS FAR AS QUALITY FIGHTS GO,BUT THERES BEEN A LULL LATELY,LETS HOPE THIS IS THE CATALYST FOR SOME GOOD HOLIDAY FEAR

I gave the edge to dorsett he landed more clean punches! great bout by both.

Holy crap, what a fight. I love it when 2 guys look at each other and take their lids off to scrap instead of those guys who grab each other right away and start hugging. Loved it. Fight was close, but I'll give it to Dorsett.

FIGHT OF THE YEAR EASY!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Classic battle of epic proportions.... both guys landing bombs ...... slightest edge to Dorsett....WOW

big boys take notice! that's a FIGHT!

A hell of a fight even if there not heavyheight that was crazy

I disagree with it being a draw. It was a great fight one of the best in a long time. But I believe Dorsett got a few more and better punches in and not a TKO or KO but a win for Dorsett anyway on points!!

TKO, win dorsett. great fight, they way a fight outta be. toss the helmets and throw some bombs. so many pseudo "tough guys" in the league could learn a lot from this middleweight fight.

One of the best fights I've seen all year. They threw bombs for a while.

DD survives the first DC right that shook his head quite vigoriously. Carcillo usually uses his left for staright arm grasping, so Dorsett suddenly gets the advantage by throwing rights that won't reach then blasting Carcillo with lefts. When DD lands his best, DC then gets an advantage back with overhand rights but they don't land flush. DC does get in a right cross or 2. I almost lost count on the punchstat here. The fact that DD can land both lefts and rights gave him the edge in the end. Looked like they both missed when Dc went off balance with two of the hardest thrown shots in their bout. This is certainly a thanksgiving fist feast and one of the best scraps this year! One hopes to see DD take on other season middleweights.

Both players showed up for this one. This fight had great offense and believe it or not, great defense. The offense was just that much better though. Good to see them remove the lids before they got started. Good to see the linesmen stay out of the mix until it was necessary. Textbook all the way around.

I was at this game and just got home from being out of town and back to my computer to watch it from a better angle. Awesome fight. It went forever. I loved it. I put Dorsett with the win with the final knockdown and better punches landed, but GREAT FIGHT!!!!

Awsome dance

Great tussle, edge to Dorsett. I was tired watching them slug it out.

Great fight. Dorsett with the slight edge.

Best fight of the year so far. Win Dorsett.

Awesome fight. Dorsett landed better shots. Slight edge Dorsett.

Carcillo got owned!

great fight

WOW!!!

wow

I was at the game...even better in person

Not often do you see a player come on the ice for a shift and go right to a guy, throwing down on the way. Dorsett took a few more shots, but landed more quality shots. Now he's put on IR with a hand injury. Slight edge to Dorsett for overall toughness. That's how a hockey fight should be!

Watch your ass if you mess with the BJ's cause Dorsett will kick it!

Dorsett clear winner here... comes back after taking a few and doesn't try and tie-up, unlike carcillo... Also heard Dorsett broke his right hand half way threw and just went lefty... unreal.

Dorkshit barely landed any, i give an edge to Carcillo

Lots of flailing after the first 20 seconds... don't agree about the "fight of the year" thing... but pretty entertaining. Edge to Carcillo for the solid hits at the beginning.

Great fight!! Edge to Carcillo on the last punch. They are both entertaining!

great fight. carrcillo threw more and landed more. nice battle for both

very good job by both. EDGE CArcillo winning on the points.

Dorsett left the game with an injury from the fight, so Carcillo gets the win. Very close fight though.

Carcillo by a bit. DC connected with more shots than DD. Great fight but have to give it to DC. Danny loses his balance was the only thing he did badly in the fight.

nearly domination by carcillo.dorsett was fighting like a cat with claws

Danny boy by a hair

Carcillo landed the more powerful and effective punches.

im giving the edge to Carcillo

TKO win by Carcillo!

Carcillo with more shots but Dorsett may have landed the 2 best shots. Really good scrap.

Awesome tilt between 2 decent fighters. Both landed nice shots throughout but Carcillo started fast & landed a big right at the end. Very close. WIN = Carcillo

definate homer commentators on the phoenix broadcast the replays told the real tale carcillo landing more. either way really close great fight

FOTY candidate great exchange i sure enjoyed it

I was at the game, blue line, 12 rows up. From the "live" perspective, it was all DC. It seemed much more violent in person and the crowd seemed a bit taken aback that DD got physically moved around the ice and seemingly rag-dolled. The TV announces (who are both Canadian and not "American" as some posters have implied - Jeff Rimer from Toronto and Danny Gare from Nelson, BC and NHL All-Star with Sabers) make it seem closer as homers, but it wasn't that close. The PHX bench was also more pumped after the fight and the CBUS bench appreciated the tilt, but was a bit more subdued, again evidencing the "live" perspective of a DC win. DD busted up his hand and thus loses his ticket to the Show. It wasn't Probert Coxe, but a nice moderday tilt.

Carcillo with a slight edge here. Typical homer commentator saying Dorsett clocked him with a left at the end. Not one of those lefts connected. However, Carcillo's wild right connected. Didn't hear them talking about that. Great scrap.

i dont now why some people are giving this to dorsett he got tagged a couple of times right at the beginning, then took a flurry of punches in the middle and received the best punch of the fight at the end, edge carcillo

fight of the year candidate? Carcillo almost dropped Dorsett with the 1st right hand, after that, Dorsett takes over, then Carcillo, great fight. big shots all around but i think Carcillo won this fight, not by much, but i think he shots were bigger.

Great scrap, take note huggers

Very great fight. Love that first flurry by Danny and love him coming on strong at the end. Love Derek's calm clean shots.

Im' guessing alot of the voters went with Dorsett cus of the ignorant analyst saying he dropped him with the left. The last punch landed was by Carcillo and it threw him off balance. Slight edge to Carcillo for landing the first and last solid punches of the srap.

Great tilt ,dorsett more shots , carcillo the better ones,edge carcillo

The announcer stated that Dorsett Dropped Carcillo at the end. I watched it over and over...he did not. Carcillo slipped. Great bout but I give it to Carcillo. Big points to Dorsett though. I saw him for the first time at the Thashers/Jackets game and he struck me as all yap then. I guess he wants to stay in the big leagues pretty bad. That passion will keep him there. But no, if you think he won this then stop being a homer and just admit it when you boy gets pounded...and it will happen.

Great fight! Give the edge to Danny. Very close!

this fight sucked!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! joking of course

Both fighters landed some solid punches, with the edge to Carcillo. Dorsett ended up on IR from fight!

Very good fight, Got to go with my boy danny on this one if he doesnt fall at the end he connects with a few more punches. Very close fight slight edge carcillo.

GREAT fight..edge Carcillo.

Best fight of the year. Can't wait to see carcillo in a flyers jersey. Edge to him in this fight.

Definately FOTY so far. I say a draw.

fantastic battle by both heroes. DRAW

Nice fight. Good to see both actually willing to punch. Almost looked like the edge going to Dorsett, but a draw seems fair.

Great fight. No winner. Draw.

GREAT FIGHT! That a way Danny boy to keep swinging! This Dorsett kid is great. And i called it a draw too. Just to close and a see saw battle.

nice one

great fight. edge to dorsett, but i'll mark it a draw.

love the way carcillo came throwing with both hands.

this goes in the books as one of the best fights of the season so far, hands down 2 gamers.

real good fight..draw

Close one but gave it to Dorsett. Good stuff.

This was a great fight......and a respectful one. Well done boys.

Excellent tussle. Dorsett gets the slight nod

carcillo started off strong but I think Dorsett caught up and then some. Edge to Dorsett... great fight!

Great bout

Grt fight. Drop the cans and swing. I gave this a Dorsett win. The next Matty B is here. Fcuk the HW's. This is the best division.

I am Tired!!!!!!

Both players landed some good shots. Edge to Dorsett.

fight of the year for sure..great battle

Good to see Carcillo get his ass kicked; dirty player...

Props to both for neither ever falling fully out of it. Pure determination. Gotta go with Carcillo though if I had to choose one, but it was too close and has to be a draw

Carcillo gets the win here but very close. turn down the sound and the homer announcers. DC lands bigger punches.

Good fight! Both players landed some heavy punches.

announcers are homers. watch this without the audio. giving the edge to Carcillo

I know most on these boards hate Carcillo, but I think he took Dorsett in this one.

What a FIGHT! Probably the best scrap of the year! Well done boyz!

That was unreal, I thought at the start of that Carcillo stunned him pretty good with a jaw shot and didn't think Dorsett would come back as strong as he did, but returned the favor with a bunch of nice lefts and scored that take down in the end. I don't see how people are voting Dorsett over Carcillo here though I think Carcillo landed the bulk of the shots and was pushing Dorsett around the rink, forget the take down at the end, and really, watch the fight with out the announcers jabbering on about their team. I score this a draw because Dorsett does land fewer shots but they seemed to count more than Carcillo's did.