DRAW. Not a fight.

what a waste of time

Carcillio was upset that Bernier was throwing with his stick up, and rightfully so. However, he was plain stupid for getting involved as the third man. Not so much a fight as JR keeping Carcillio from getting free shots on a guy who was already engaged with someone else.

what a bunch of morons.

Brenier is the biggest coward of the bunch, drop your gloves p*ssy don't keep your stick in your hand.

How did roenick not get any kind of a penalty

Roenick is the biggest piece of s*it in hockey, but this time actually does something useful and tries to avoid a bad third man in. I can only hope that Carcillo returns the favor in their next meeting and beats Mrs. Roenick like a b*tch that she is. "whaaaa if you don't support our union, don't watch hockey...whaaa"...Someone needs to beat him, please do it Carcillo!!

I don't even consider this a fight. For once in his career, JR showed some class. He did the right thing on both ends of the melee. Stuck up for his team and helped a bad situation keep from getting worse and then showed concern for Carcillo when it was apparant Carcillo was hurt. Oh.. and he scored on the subsequent powerplay. hehe.

Again Carcillo trying to jump a guy from behind who is already engaged, just like he did to Clarkson a few games ago..I love Roenick..in his prime he would have crushed Carcillo =P

That was fun!!!!! how could roenick not get a fm??????????????? announcers right on with the winded call!!! lol Boneheads!

It is true that Bernier is throwing with his stick up (idiot), but if you notice Yandle of the Coyotes also has his stick up throughout much of the early altercation, so Coyotes fans should probably shut up. Carcillo is an idiot, and usually ends up on the business end of someone else's fists. Maybe jumping someone from behind will improve his win-loss stats.

Kind of a crazy scrap. Everybody going after everyone. Bottomshelf why don't you tell Carcillo he is a big baby. I have personally watched about 10 or so of his fights. He is a tough tough guy.

I'd give it a draw just because all roenick did was wrestle carcillo. This game was madness.

carcillo is the man for his teammates, but J.R. is a fair man for his teammates to neutral the madman

y would Carcillo go after atnoher person if hes fighting someone else

Roenick horsecollared him and choked him out.

Roenick cinched in an underarm hook and a rear naked choke. Nice move. Hand it to Roenick, earlier in his career, Carcillo would've had 6 kinds of dog sh*t kicked out of him. Now he was simply restrained. And the whole thing started by that b*tch Rivet. No need for the cross-check. A save is made, winger stops, play over. And the game is tied. What the hell is he thinking!?!?! And Bottom Shelf - you really are a dumb person. Please don't have kids. There are enough idiots now without you further contaminating the gene pool. Step on his leg...

roenick is the man

Carcillo is a girl, 3rd man in. then he gets slammed by Roenick and he ends up getting hurt. he was sprawled out on the ice for 2 minutes after everything stopped grabbing his knee. THATS WHAT YOU GET WHEN YOUR A PUNK AND TRY TO BE 3RD MAN

Roenick jumped him from behind? Carcillo is fucken punching people from behind you fucken asshole! Carcillo is squared up with Roenick and he bails from that to get some cheap shots in you fucken fag. Are you fucken kidding me?!! TRPAULSON, the reason Carcillo couldn't breathe, was his tampon got kicked up into his throat. You must be a Coyotes fan.

Roenick wins by submission via rear naked choke.

Roenick won hands down, Carcillo tryed to escape and Roenick landed multiple punches, followed by a take down with more punches.

JR way to go

Roenick beat him up

I'm giving it to Carcillo because Roenick jumped him from behind like the dirty coward he has always been. Carcillo had trouble breathing because Roenick had him in a choke hold from the rear.

A class move by Roenick to not only not throw punches, but to also call for the trainers and keep a hand on Carcillo's chest in a jesture of conscern.

Boring scrap. Carcillo is a big baby. Roenick should have just taken a class from Chris Simon and stepped on the big baby's leg! Oh...oh...his stick is up waaaaaa!!

this is just ridiculous but awesome

I can't really even call this match up of Roenick vs. Carcillo a fight...Carcillo just wants to go after the other guy and Roenick is really just trying to hold him back...theres some "punches" thrown but more so just so Carcillo can get away and Roenick throws a few in self defense...sucks he got hurt when Roenick pulled him back but he had to get him off somehow

Why is Carcillo a baby? He was pissed because his teammate was being punched while Bernier had his stick in his hand. I'm can't blame him for being about that........that's crap.

nice quote announcers....awesome... a barlike fight without bottles

How often do you see a win to the guy who didn't even get a fighting major.

Carcillo mumbled "I can't think". I think Roenick pretty much tied him up, lost him and then pummeled down on him. No fight really but because it's posted, Roenick gets the nod....surely you can't give it to the guy who had to be helped off the ice!

Roenick has certainly faded from the public eye (it seems like just yesterday he was in every single Hockey News issue), but he certainly does do a good job here, restraining Carcillo, who wanted to once again fight someone who was already engaged. Roenick certainly put a stop to that. No really good fights came of this, but it was exciting nonetheless!