Dion Phaneuf vs Scott Hartnell

Two of the least-likable non-fighter-fighters...
I'm giving the edge to the less hairy guy.

Hartnell got his hair parted in that one though the Philadelphia paper called it a draw. The bigger story was the non-fight between Colton Orr and Dan Carcillo, who looked genuinely frightened at the prospect of going at it with Orr. Orr got sucked into stupid penalties that cost Toronto the game.

Not a very convincing fight...I don't even think one solid punch landed except a wrestle to the ground. Have to give it a Draw.

that was funny

that was a messy fight. Draw

Hartnell may be the worst fighter I have seen..If he cant bite or scratch he loses. What a joke. A typical Flyer fairy goon. Actually even if he bites and scratches he still loses. He should wear a big W for Wussie on his jersey.

I'm unsure of an edge to anyone.

one bum fighting another bum. Not much of a fight. I don't think anything landed.

Hartnell is a puke that needs a hair-cut out of desperation, what a pitiful looking puke he is!!! His fighting skill is extremely sup-par as well. I would personally drag him down to the ice by that carott-top of his. Dion ain't much himself in the fighting category either.

Phaneuf with the win, good scrap for 2 non-heavyweights

Hartnell can't fight, he can only cheapshot and run goalies. Gotta love how the Flyers fake tough guys let Orr RUN OVER thier goalie.

Fanooof dropped the visor?!?!? NO WAY!!!!! Heartless dropped the visor too I see, what has come of the Flyers and Maple Leafs. Next thing you know they're going to be going for cheesesteaks together after the game

One has a girl's name, the other has a girl's hair. I love lesbian fights!

Broad star "Annie" does her impersenation of her first day on skates and crashes to the ice. Slight edge to Dion

were they slapping each other? anyway ,yes dion the peon drops his bucket, and then defeats the lead singer for nickleback