Dion Phaneuf vs Shane Doan

Great fight... ill say draw

That was a very good fight. Early on the both landed a shot at the same time. Phaneuf's shot was better. Doan looked a litte stunned, but he hung in there and got back in the fight. Later Doan lands a nice upper cut and takes over to edge Phaneuf. I think that both of these guys are easy to dislike unless they are on your team then you love them.

meh.

HOLY JUMPIN'.

DRAW

I'm a little confused why so many are voting Doan as the winner... I guess taking overhand rights to the face proves you're the tougher fighter.

"holy jumpin" good emotion, love to see the boys shuck the buckets and trade shots.

Draw .

People have been trying to appoint Phaneuf the new Scott Stevens since he was a Junior. He has the occasional big hit but he defnately is no Stevens when it comes to dropping the gloves. Called this one a draw, looked like it was going to be a good bout then turned into somewhat of a hugfest.

Nice bout for Doan

Wow, I thought the Flamers only fought witht heir helmets on...

Doan landed the nice upper cut, but Phaneuf landed a nice punch towards the end as well.
Draw.

Coyotes just suck.
So does the know it all goalie announcer.
Why do the skilless little people talk so much?

i dont understand why people think this fight is a 6.3 fight. it wasnt a bad fight but it was defintely nothing above a 4 or a 5 something has happened in the last couple years where if there are a few punches thrown and landed then it was a classic. what happens when a classic comes a long again and its rated the same that may vs barch was.

Doan was more the aggressor in this fight and probably was a bit better than Phaneuf, but call it a draw.

Good to see Doan still has it in him... he proved a lot! Made for one heck of a game... fights on the ice and in the stands!!! Wahoeee!!!

I love that they took off the helmets first. Now that's how you enter into a fight!