Dion Phaneuf vs Keith Tkachuk

Nice spirited bout here. Loved Tkachuk's first punch. Phaneuf controlled the fight from there but didn't do enough to get the win. Draw.

Phaneuf taked the narrow win over veteran Tkachuk.
He landed more.
He got away nice flurry on his right early on, but Keith landed a nice one for the answer early of Phanuef's flurry.
Another, but shorter flurry again by Phaneuf , that works.
A nice fight, but not a big one.

two very good fights in this game

Phaneuf wins. It was nice to see him shed that visor for a change. Surprising that he handled Tkachuk who usually does better.

I have newfound respect for Tkachuk after that display of agression

Phaneuf gets the win because Tkachuk quit. Keith is all show. He threw his one punch and then waited for the refs to jump in.

Tkachuk was the aggressor and he could not have been happy with the way the fight turned out, because it was Phaneuf who got in all the good punches. Interesting altercation.

Blueliner....don't be scared to substitute "punch" for "hit."

Good start to the fight - looked like tkachuk caught dion off guard at the start and then got nothing in on dion - good tilt

Phaneuf's my favourite player and while he was probably the better of the two in this fight I didn't see enough to give him the win. Draw

{haneuf got in the better punches, but Tkachuk didn't care and was full of energy.

Good Clean fight. Couple good rghts by Dion. Well fought.

Phaneuf Dominates Tkachuk... no contest

Draw plain and simple, neither did enough to win

win for phaneuf nice cheap crosscheck to the back of big walt's head. did someone say he is like john wayne???? overrated pansy he hides from the heavyweights