| Date / Time | Away / Home Team | Away / Home Player |
| Oct 25, 2009 | San Jose Sharks | Jody Shelley |
| 1pd 11:27 | Philadelphia Flyers | Ian Laperriere |
| Comments: Other Penalties: Shelley received an interference. | ||
| You must login to vote. You can sign up for free if you do not have an account already. |
| Jody Shelley | 89.2% | |
| Draw | 7.8% | |
| Ian Laperriere | 2.9% | |
| From 102 votes with an average rating of 3.4 | ||

Shelley wins the fight and he is expected to. Good job challenging him by lapperriere though