Daniel Carcillo vs Tim Gleason

I don't think it is fair or makes any sense to evict a guy from the game for coming over and dropping the gloves with a guy that just completed an illegal hit on your player. I think if the hit is clean - then go ahead and call an instigator if you want (or delay of game) but if it is a dirty hit then an instigator shouldn't be called. Let the guys stand up for each other when someone goes over the line...then clamp down on all the stupid fights last year that occurred after every clean bodycheck. A fair trade?

They say they're cracking down on staged fights and dangerous takedowns, but Laraque didn't get kicked out of the game the other night. Gleason challenges, Carcillo accepts after a dirty, dirty hit, and somehow Gleason's the bad guy here? If you're going to allow fighting, please give me an example of a better time to do it. Zebra's on the menu tonight boys, let's go hunting!

Gleason stuck up for Ray Whitney. "One punch and done" Carcillo pretty much missed his one punch, neither did anything. Draw.

crap crap crap you can't even call that a fight. 2 minutes each for roughing

Reckless and dangerous hit by Carcillo. Bad injuries can happen this way. Gotta love Gleason stepping right up. DRAW in a bummer.

im a penguins fan but gotta love this boy carcillo, ugly hit, draw

Wait let me take a look at this closely. I see someone getting hit from behind---and there's the Flyer jersey! Some things never change...This is the kind of play that keeps the Flyers as the doormat of the NHL elite teams. Oh, and he lost the fight of course because that's done face to face!

good job gleason its a good fight at a good time for a dirty hit and with a guy who can throw them

Both guys hit the deck. Just couldn't stay on there feet long enough to make this a fight.

you have to defend your home ice.

Whitney a 10 for taking a dive? Really? He got boarded from behind standing stiill by a guy 25 lbs heavier than him who was skating towards him. Dude, WTFU! GLEASON LOVES STICKING UP FOR HIS TEAMMATES!

Carcillo is the MAN. Finally our boys have a guy that the whole world HATES. I Love it! That hit wasn't even that bad. He pushed the guy and he dives head first into the boards. I give Whitney a 10 for the dive. I also give a 10 to Gleason for sticking up for his team mate.

Too short to call anything. Nice to see Gleason stick up for his teammate tho.

draw. Both got one hit in and ended with a tackle.

Carcillo got 2 solid quick punches in the beginning. Gleason really didnt have any standout punch in the fight. i give it to carcillo