good tilt......draw at best......i thought carcillo would get pummeled....but came back strong

Great Fight !! Call it a draw....

good fight. good job by Strudwick to hold Carcillo at bay with the rights, but Carcillo did LAND a shot, you can see Strudwick's face grimace. look at the clip again. 54 seconds. i'm saying draw because both fighters landed good shots. i loved also how Carcillo dropped his stick and gloves real cool, one at a time.

great fight .nothing more than a draw. strudwick missed alot of punches that i guess people think landed. feel free to watch it again.

draw

Strudwick just had to much of a reach advantage in this one. He out throws and outlands Carcillo, who showed well none the less.

Win Struds..... not even close.

not close, win Struds.

Carcillo knew he was in for a beating, especially after he failed to get the jump on Struds. He threw but ran out of reach. Total domination by Struds although the kid's got a chin. I think Struds was the Oilers best pick-up as he can play anywhere defensively and obviously fight. Let's put him in net and see what happens!

fight looked liked they got tired from throwing and missing

Strudwick with the code! Sticks up for team weenie, beats a tough old school fighter in Carcillo and then show class by letting up when he knows Carcillo's done. Gotta give the props.

Strudwick won that with his reach. There was no shot of Carcillo laying a decent hit on him, 'cause if he did it would've been a different match. Carcillo's a monster with a well-earned history of one-punch knock-outs.

Strudwick hammered him

Good tilt. Carcillo throws 'em, but is so weak he can't hurt anybody.

Strudwick dominated Carcillo in this fight. I lost count of how many lefts he landed after 20.

wow what a fight.but only strudwick lands and is clear winner

struds took this big,though carc is smaller,still great team player.wish he was still here in NY.

great fight. i hate to say it but i carcillo can fight. strudwick has a good left and used it well. strudwick the win but it was close.

win Strudwick....massive size difference in this fight and Strudwich looked good Carcillo is a gem.....hockey player fighter who is one of the most entertaining all around guys in the league....when he fights he actually fights.....a bit like Cote he seems incapable of having a boring fight...what i like about him is he always trys to land...he is a throw back player that would have been great in any era really fun fight to watch

I guess Stortini didn't feel like a holdfest, so Strudwick had to show him how to dominate...

Well fellow Ranger fans??? Can you say Sather you ******* idiot!!??? Let go of a good defenseman and one guy that never backed down and always protected his team mates??? We get stuck w/ 2 crap!!! defenseman in Redden and Kalinin while Jason alone is better than both of them! Good for you Struddie, I miss you as a devoted Ranger Fan. Easy win in more than one way, Struddie!!!

Carcillo simply couldnt reach. Great fight though. W to Strudwick

I had no idea Strudwick could throw them like that. He dished out a pounding. Carcillo may have gotten a few in, but not enough. Big win Strudwick.

strudwick is a soldier..he should give stortiniweenie some pointers

win for strudwick kimocoyote,are you saying this now that carcillo is with philly,not a fa danny boy got distroyed in thsi fight..not even close carcillo was throwing but not landing,maybe one shot at best

Good old fashioned bout that took up a good portion of the rink ! Strudwick with the decision.

Strudwick is probably the best team player you'll see in the nhl. He doesn't back down to anybody, always sticks up for guys on his team and really knows how to scrap. I miss him in new york a lot. Gotta give strudwick the win here, clearly handling carcillo nicely with the left hand. Nice bout.

Carcillo got pumped!

All Struds in this one. Carcillo ate alot of lefts in this. Give him credit for going with the bigger guy but did not expect anything different then a one sided fight.

Good fight but Strudwick with the win, he used his reach well

Strudwick just landed punch after punch.... he gets the W.. great fight

real good fight. strudwick solid win. carcillo took some shots and showed a good chin.

Carcillo tried... but he was Strudwick's pinata

carcillo did not land anything..easy win for strudwick

fantastick fight! strudwick with a W over one of the leagues best middle weights.

as much as I like Carcillo, he got schooled here. But man i liked his hit, mainly because it triggered a great fight. High point for Carcillo for not backing down and for throwing alot of punches, higher points for Strudwick for standing up for his team and landing alot of the punches. HUGE points for both for putting up a great fight!

Carcillo...nice cheap shot! What goes around comes around! Strudwick takes care of business...no muss, no fuss. A draw...??? Only if you are in the spirit of Christmas giving!

great fight between these 2 guys.

GREAT FIGHT, but J.Strudwick gets the W-great energy in that fight

No way I can not give this to Strudwick. Danny did hit him direct in the face near the end of the fight and knocked Strudwicks head back. End good big man will generally beat a good smaller man. Not by a lot but Strudwick won but look at his face when he went to the box. It wasn't that lopsided. Like Louie DeBrusk said "Dan is a wolverine" A lot of heart how anyone knowing hockey can say he doesn't have heart doesn't know hockey as well as they think. No power in Dan's punches ask Barch of Dallas if he does.

great scrap, strudwick won but carcillo showed alot.

How do people call this a draw,.. or even a win for Carcillo? Good thing the Oil have Strudwick..... it makes up for Stortini's short comings Strudwick totally dominates this fight...

Wow, Strudwick looked great, big win for him!!! Carcillo is a good fighter, but he got owned on this one...

woweeee

Yes, I love it when someone kicks Carcillo's ass. Beutifull.

Slight edge to Strudwick for connecting. Canidate for Fight of the Year.

NICE..........Edge Strudwick.

Rock em sock em...i like both these guys...grt fight...

Strudwick wins -- commendable effort by Carcillo but he looked over-matched.

Yeah Struds.

stay in your weight class Danny

That was a great Miley Cote impression by Carcillo. Anyone voting draw or carcillo is a complete moron. Strud pounded the little weiner

sweet fight win for struds

Strudwick has been awesome with the fists this year!

Great scrap! Lots of big punchs

Strudwick beat-down

Strudwick clearly won and credit to him for easing up when he knew Carcillo was spent but Carcillo has to get props too. He didn't back down, even when he was fighting out of his weight category. He's such an exciting player to watch and, as the announcer said, he will back down from nobody. Great fight.

No contest, Strudwick all the way.

wicked sick fight........strudwick has always been 1 tough underrated mf.....great job DC throwin with a guy with more weight & time in

Fight of the year candidate. Strudwick lands a lot more punches and takes the win.

WAS A CLOSE ONE BUT GIVING THIS ONE TO STRUDWICK!!! GREAT FIGHT BOYS!

No reach for Carcillo, total domination by Strudwick.

nice to see carcillo eat a few after not getting called for the hit.