Not a very god fight. I give this a draw as both landed a few of their own, nothing to special.

Good scrap, draw

Zebra's end it to early to get a decision.

I could probably give Boll the edge as he seemed to land a couple solid shots more than Carcillo, but as they are both such rockers and neither wanted it to end when it did I am calling it a draw.

I give it a draw. Carcillo lost balance to start the fight but recovered well. I think although not this year we will see much more of these two.

very nice fight two nice guys

these two will probably be 1 and 2 in PIMS at the end of the year. Too bad Carcillo isn't with the Pens. Godd scrap. Draw

Wow Boll controlled carcillo well in this one. I didn't think that was possible.

Win to Boll even though I do'nt think that either guy did a lot of damage.

Who was the Phoenix player that "slipped" on the ice and fell just before the fight started??

Good fight. Edge to Boll.

Boll controlled both the tempo of the fight, and dominated the balance game - no real contest despite Carcillo being a willing partner.

nice effort by both. nice fight. Boll wins

J Boll narrow win

Carcillo's win streak comes to an end. I like how he charged him while swinging though........

2 of my faves going at it here. Great fight in terms of spirit and match-up, but just OK in punches landed and the length of the bout. I gave Boll the edge, he was the only one who landed anything meaningful. Damn, they should have let these 2 go for a minute and a half. Bummer. BTW, Very quietly Jared Boll is leading the league in FMs again.

Boll with the win. Both let em fly, though.

I'm so happy for Jared - he finally won one . . . in convincing fashion, too. Nice fight. I think these guys could have gone on and on and on. They seemed very upset with each other.

boll with the big win.see carcillo can't win them all,not as good as everyone makes him out to be but hell carcillo is one tough cookie and can take a shot

Boll did exactly what you have to do against DC..avoid that right hand. Win for Boll.

boll with the win. but you have to give carcillo some credit he is willing to go with anyone since there is no one else on the team who is willing to go.

decent scrap

Good move by Boll to avoid the first two throws. Looked like Carcillo was begging him not to hit him anymore.

edge boll for better start

Boll getting better each fight. He gets the nod.

Carcillo is the biggest goon in hockey. Beware of the BOLL>

Great fight. Boll with the edge

have to give boll the slight edge in this fight.boll has been fighting pretty good lately.

boll just wins great fight

Boll wins this one: more punches, esp. a couple of uppers. Bummed about the finish, though.

Nice fight, Boll definately landed the better punches. Boll wins

Boll got started quicker, then it was pretty even. Both guys throwing, trying to go, linesmen come in too soon again. Narrow win by Boll.

I agree Boll has been fighting pretty good lately. He did his homework on Carcillo. Carcillo likes to throw that big first punch. Of course he clocked that guy with one punch last year. Boll was ready for that first one, slipped it and got into a good position against Carcillo. He got a few good shots in. The linesman was in the way. Too bad they didn't have a different camera angle right then. Carcillo did well after taking a few and got back into the fight. I have to give the edge to Boll. These guys match up well.

Good scrap!! Boll with the win, great uppercuts.

Decision Boll.

pretty good scrap

carcillo did not want the fight to stop?i guess he wanted to get his butt whupped some more.boll manhandled carcillo and delivered only good blows of the fight.carcillo's landed to the back of helmet.big win for boll.

As a "Yotes" season ticket holder it hurts to say but edge goes to Boll. It might have been different if Boll had his helmet off but give him his due. It was close and Carcillo as typical was coming on. Will wait for rematch next year. Coyotes cleaned the season though 4-0

win boll, worked all angles and stood in there toe to toe not afraid to take a shot.

Very interesting fight. Really energetic for both with Boll getting the nod

GREAT SCRAP! Boll "W".

Not a fan of fights on the boards.

LOL the announcers cracked me up here. They didnt waste no time getting into it... only half the game! :) ha ha they were pretty excited about the scrap too. i gave this one a draw.

screw the zebras

Draw ( almost gave Boll the edge ). Pretty good fight - nice to see a couple guys get right to it and throw punches - no waiting-around, grabbing and spinning.

Hell of a fight

I'd pay Carcillo to fight on my team. I'd pay Boll not to fight on my team--he's got to be among the most embarrassing "fighters" in the league--parros, stortini, peters, etc. In the rarest of rarities, Boll with the win.

Boll gets it but a good scrap by both guys. Lots of energy expended without a ton of punches.

Love seeing Carcillo get beat even if it is against lame @ss Boll

Who's directing the cameras in Phoenix? From what I saw, Boll with the win.

good scrap... boll throws more and lands more

Slight edge to Bol. Great fight though, no hugfest and dancin here!

cmon ref!!!...boll with a win in a close one...some of u guys r stingy with ur ratings that middleweight rumble was an 8..allday

really good fight, tough call,i'll have to go with boll