Hey Dicktards! Hawks fan here...This is a draw. I would give Dumba a slight edge here if this was an Olympic Boxing Match but It is not. It is a Hockey Fight. If two guys continuously throw punches with most not landing or hitting equipment and one guys seems to have actually had one or two more, but they mutually stop throwing and the fight stops....DRAW all day long. I gave shaw a 6 and dumba a 7. Neither player was any worse for wear at the conclusion of this......SCRAP...not bout.
Shaw needs a haircut or maybe I'm just jealous. Seriously though, this was a nasty spirited scrap that was too close to call IMO. Draw.
Good, spirited bout and great effort by both guys, but this fight is a textbook example of what's wrong with the visor rule. Truth be told, if Dumba isn't wearing a visor he probably gets knocked out (Although Shaw, the midget, probably couldn't knock out a grandmother). Dumba got some solid shots in, but Shaw is the winner of this fight, if only because Dumba's "armor" saved him from about 4 straight rights to the face. Also, Dumba taking his helmet off immediately after the fight makes him look like a coward. Skate to the box with it Matt, so everyone can get a good look at your fearsome visor.
Shaw was more worried about his hair... Wtf
Must be a lot of Wild fans voting here. It's a draw.
Draw good tilt by both
Pretty good scrap. Not a big fan of the shield in a fight or any other time really. Hawks have a real need for some toughness on the roster. I agree there are too many Europeans on this team.
Shaw is hardly a fighter. Always holds his own. always does the dirty work. Great fight
Not sure why Dumba is a clear winner? A draw is what I see. Great one though. Lots of chucking.
Brewed for a while before, solid momentum for each during, and a pat on the back after. Draw in my eyes.
good toe to toe scrap with some real heavy blows that actually landed. I love it!
Did Dumbass land any punches? Nice visor.
The shield saved Dumba from Shaw's punches drawing blood. Shaw won this tilt. The was a BIG factor.
i hate shaw as well as you guy but im not gonna say he lost the fight because of it.if dumba didnt land them 2 solid rights in the second half of the fight it would be a clean win shaw.it looked like dumba didnt land anything except that.edge shaw but dumba seems like a kid who could improve in fighting
. . . Shaw assuming the role of enforcer is rather amusing. Dumbass is not event an upper tier light weight and handles him easily. . . Guess Dumbass will need to lay Kane out again as he doesn't need to worry about anything happening
Classic draw, however watching the replay from different feeds I have to say Shaw landed the best shots. Dumba didn't land the same quality.
Dumba with solid connects vs Shaws glancing blows. Win Dumba. Decent fight.
almost a yawn
Great scrap, edge to Dumba
Both landed some decent shots Looked fairly even but I'll give the slight edge to Dumba for standing tall, while shaw tried to take the cowards way out and lift Dumbas legs out
Rapid fire jab fest, with a few jarring pops.
WOW. Very good fight. Each landed some really good shots. Dumba finished up big time though with a couple of blasts that landed solidly for the WIN.
Enjoyable fight. Shaw is tough. Took a couple good shots and hung in there. Props to Dumba for a good effort. He would of looked good in black and gold. Win Dumba.
Bruins fan here, but agree there's not a clear victor. Not a fan of Shaw but he definitely threw above his weight class here give him credit even fight, even result.
Finally! A decent fight.
Hawks fan here but must give the edge to Dumba.
Really decent scrap--clear win for Dumba, but Shaw didn't embarrass himself.
It looked like Dumba landed more shots and some of them were pretty good ones too. I gave him a win here.
Surprising to see some good scraps at the end of the season. Two mighty-mites go at it. Will give Dumba the slight edge -- albeit a visor aided win
Dumba agrees to a fight with a guy 30 lbs less and can’t even win. Pretty sad.
Shaw lands more face crushers
Dumb and Dumba
Shaw turned it into a hug-fest once he got smoked a few times....which still didn't help stop the punches from landing. Clear decision to Dumba.
looked to me that Matthew earned his early lead but then kind of wilted behind the visor after Shaw warmed up... whatevs, that's the 'game' now, and I'm not griping... and a free dvd or 1 month membership to the first one who can tell me what Shaw is using on his hair thesedays... 'Bouncin & Behavin' maybe? I gotta find a way to drive the girls crazy again since this beer-belly ain't cutting it... Holla! #24 FTW
Good scrap at least someone on the wild will fight
Mathew Dumba is clearly the winner here. Chicago needs Big John back to protect Patrick Kane for the playoffs. Even a strong player like Hossa needs a team mate like Big John Scott at this time. The Hawks need to get some toughness soon.
Dumba leads with a clean shot on the chin. Couple more good head and body shots. Shaw connects with a couple. Decent dance.
Great to see Dumba actually win a fight. Despite the fact that his hit against Kane was clean last time these teams met, and shouldn't need to answer a bell for catching someone with their head down, but he did.
Payback fight for Dumba's hit on Kane, but Dumba won the fight. Some solid shots.
Love seeing the dirtiest player in the league getting thumped. Dumba with the clear win.
People do realise that there is a visor rule if came in the league within a certain time. Most players don't have a choice, so get off of Dumba's case. He isn't even a fighter, so why would he go without anyways. Some of ya need to stop acting like tards. Listen to yourselves. What about legit fighters with visors. Are they just straight up pussies? No, they don't have a choice. Now I know why I don't come on much anymore. To many morons on here. Dumba with the edge.
ALL RIGHT!!! After a couple of weeks of real turkeys we finally get two guys that show them how its done. Toe to toe, blow for blow. No serious damage but a great fight anyway. I'm giveing it to Dumba but it's real close. Shaw or Draw works too.
Love the square up at the beginning. Love the chucking by both guys. Love the refs holding off from jumping in. Love everything except for the voting results on here. Win to Dumba.... Hell of a scrap & 7
Solid scrap between to willing oponents,good techical punching/counter punching by both fellas.Dumba on stronger at the end
As much as I'm a Hawks fan, I'll have to give Dumba the slight edge. But Shaw gets a bonus point for not wearing a visor, and Dumba gets a point taken off for....his last name! (But I think the Hawks have bigger concerns than trying to win fights, unless this is their version of rope-a-dope before the real season starts).
Dumba landed 5 clean shot, and Shaw with 2 MAYBE 3 clean shots. I watched it 3 times and that's the count I got, thus Dumba with the win. How can there be so many draw votes here since Matt landed 2x as many shots? Sure sounds skewed....smh...and after further review people like "Slambo" are the homer jack-asses "claiming" Shaw got more shots in and/or won the fight?! FIRST OFF-Put down your Hawk Kool-Aid and actually COUNT square shots hitting the other's face...then "ANYONE" with 2 good eyes and a " NON SLANTED perspective" would see Dumba landed nearly TWICE as many...Christ .....
Big ups to Dumba answering the bell like that… for a clean hit. Kane is soft.
Shaw landed some hard rights dumba never landed
The fact that Shaw has to do this for this pacifist team says a lot about them and their poor prospects for the playoffs. No heart or grit on this team, especially on defense is a huge issue for them. Shaw is no bigger than Kane, yet he has to get revenge for the hit on Kane. Too many Swedes.
Dumba clearly won. And of course voting here is skewed with trolls, homers, etc. I guess the hit on Kane has now been paid back?
Dumba takes it by a very narrow margin. I have no problem with a draw.
Dumba only had a couple of good shots, and Shaw, who I thought was the biggest pussy in the league, had just as good. Dumba just had his sissy helmet and visor protecting him, so maybe not as much effect. draw/5
you Hawks fans must be stoned to say Shaw won this tilt, Dumba with the win
GREAT fight-especially in this day and age. Hard to remember the last fight I rated this high. Probably a slight edge to Dumba because I think he landed an few more but both landed several bombs. Great spirited bout. p.s. It looked to me like Shaw tried to do a leg takedown near the end of the fight. Wouldn't be surprised.
Dumba with a clear win here. Landed more. Don't know how Shaw got so many votes. Guess hawks fans are clinging to anything lately.
All Dumba here as Shaw looked like he was just hanging on. Why are the linesmen in so close and always putting hands on guys in the middle of the fight? Back off, let them go until they tire out or one needs a rescue.
Hey Hey decent scrap fellas Isn't it crazy that scraps can actually be exciting these days? All it takes is a little anger and punch throwin! Dumba has been terrorizing the 'Hawks all year, physically And the only person to stand up to him prior to this bout was... You guessed it! Artemi Panarin.... Even though Mashinter has played against Dumba 3 times He never tried to mix it up with him.. Because like most tough guys that come to the 'Hawks Mashinter was neutered You guys probably saw me bitching on here the last year and a half about how badly I wanted Mash up in Chicago Well he got his shot.. Played in at least 30+ games Aaaaand he fought.. twice... ANYWAYS, enough with my bitching Good scrap here Gave it a draw I'm not very biased when it comes to my 'Hawks I love to see good fights and I call it like I see it Not sure why Dumba is getting so much love from the voters Side note; Shaw has been very unimpressive this year Losing to Jackman, Chiarot and drawing with Dumba? Not good Expected a lot more from him when he first came up Still love that he's a 'Hawk though Fun guy to watch boy I'll tell ya what