I give the win to McGrattan even though I'm a huge Shelly fan. I don't like the celebration at the end though. Even if it is your first game back in a while, show a little class.
Close fight. McGrattan landed a few power shots, and Shelley definitely closed strong. I can see someone giving the edge to McGrattan, but I'm going with the draw.
McGrattan threw more, but hit mostly the air. both guys landed couple of good shots. draw.
Mcgrattan
Great heavyweight fight. I'm not picking a winner from that, McGrattan landed some bombs, so did Shelley and Shelley is in control at the end of it. Draw Don't let blood and cuts fool you. Shelley bleeds more than a Spartan in 300.
Shelley, much like Rocky, can block punches with his face. McGratton landed more punches, but Shelley didn't seem to mind. Shelley got a nice one in to end the fight. Draw
McGrattan was good, Shelly came back. Two good HW. Draw!
good frist fight for Brian McGrattan to show he can still do that for a team.
Nice to see McGrattan back in the ring. Just a great heavyweight brawl and Shelley is really stepping it up lately with some bigtime fighting against major opponents, knocking on the door for #1 heavy right now.
domination by McGrattan...busher move raising hands in the air afterwards...paybacks are m/f...
What is up with Shelly? Got his ass whipped, sucker punches the guy in the end and then runs his mouth like a hero? That was not impressive at all for Ms. Shelly Big Mac by a landslide
McGrattan clear winner
wow a real fight its about time . every fight in the nhl today suck with the stupid jersey jab and the way they grab each others jersey by the neck so there out of reach of a punch. Win to gratts the time out this year helped him . he remembered how they use to fight
Nice W for McGratts to get going again, but c'mon a 7.8 this fight wasn't that good in quality. I gave it a 6 and I was being generous. BTW, welcome back big guy!
Mcgrats at the end is saying I'm back from rehab and I'm a better fighter for you Coyote fans than Dan Carcillo. After a few more losses, Jody maybe getting called Shelled. The helmet knocker punch from McRehab was the decider. Great to have him back and remember the credo "Thugs not drugs"
Good fight, win McGratten - landed the better of the shots. Good to see him back!
Even if Shelley landed that shot at the end, McGrattan still got the edge here. Neither did a terrible amount of damage by the looks of it. Called it a 6.
brian with the win!!! marked up shelley's face pretty good..shelley deserved the beaten seing all he does jersey jabs every fight and it gets so boring..its the only way he wins...every fight jersey jab jersey jab...everyone is going to be able to read the way he fights and he is just going to start losing them all
Shelley looked like Mary Shelley's Frankenstein after this one, welcome back McGrattan!
Nice return for Gratts. Glad to see him get the win.
Decent fight. McGrattan won the fist part of the fight while Shelly did well at the end. I called it a draw
over the top
Welcome back Brian McGrattan! Clear WIN for him here.
McGratts w/the win. Nuff' said...
was not going to comment but after 3 watches...thrashing by big B.M glad to see him back. Easy win!
Nice job by McGrattan, clear winner in this one.....
I hope McGrattan and Parros go tonight
Edge/Win Gratts..... he was fuking stoked to be back, hopefully he keeps it up.
Very Good to See Gratts back!! One of the Best Fighters in the league for sure.
Mcgrattan was in clear control the entire bout. and left shelleys mug even uglier than usual. W to Mcgrattan
mcgratton lets the bombs go here, It's a travesty though, how they are trying to eliminate his kind..Hopefully he doesn't disappear after 1 or 2 fights
McGrats tore him up. Nice shot by Shelley at the end but major bombs by McGrattan
McGratton throws shelly around like a bottle of booze...with ease! i think shelly will want to redeem himself if he gets a chance but that was a totall beat down.
wow. a couple of big dudes throwing bombs there. wouldn't want to take any of those.
nice to see brian back in the nhl.he gets the win in this fight.
Sorry Jody, but I gotta give this one to McGrattan. He had more punch than Jody. But much better fight than the Staubitz ice capade.
Mc Gratton clear win here
Good to see Gratts back doing what he does best.Pretty good tilt between two heavyweights gave it to Gratts and gave the fight a 7.
McGrattan wins the tilt on this one ,shelley toke alot of punches and ended up with some blood...the end part ,shelley tide McGrattans right and then got some cheap shots in cause he was looking bad. Shelley was mad after the fight cause he knew he lost the bout.... I hope we see alot more of Mcgrattan...just play your role McGrattan and don,t get into other issue,s.Your point is proven after a good fight.{good luck McGrattan}.
McGrattan just kept coming at Shelly. Good fight.
Shelley got owned. Hope he puts some ice on his face after the game.
Grattz looked strong throughout the fight, Parros is next on Thursday night
welcome back Brain McGrattan!!!!!! Love it when Shelley gets his ass kicked
I give Brian the win here. Awesome to see him throw punch after punch. Brians punch(es) when both were active beats the hell out of Jodys almost cheap punch.
great win and comeback for McGratts. after looking at Shelley's face, how can ANYBODY say DRAW or that Shelley won? are you not watching the same scrap?
wecome back Mr McGrattan not enought tough guys in the NHL
McGrattan scored better hits and more often. Good stuff
2 loses in a row for Shelley
brian was big winner fun to watch
McGrattan took Shelley to the brick oven and made pizza out his face
"He goes Big Ern on him"-- Yotes have the best announcers in the league, hands down.
welcome back brian mcgrattan........mcgrattan put the beat down on shelley and just plain kicked his ass
I told you guys mcgrattan was one of the best fighters....Shelley just avg
helluva fight! welcome back grats
welcome back mcgrattan. clear the winner
Considering Shelley has been out there all saeson, he got worked in this one...folks are rating it low...This is a great showing compared to some ofther recent fights... McGrattan may see Parros tonight!!! we'll see
good to see lunch box back in action,Jody looked good too but mcgrats was landing big time,jody was lookin pretty bunged up,hopefully wayne-o likes lunch box enough to keep him around he is one of the best. welcome back lunch box. lookin good.
"Welcome back Brian McGrattan" is right! WOW, great scrap from McGrattan as he absolutely DOMINATES Shelley, who is no slouch himself. McGrattan landed 4 or 5 haymakers whereas Shelley landed nothing. This is as lopsided as it can get without a knockout!
For some reason couldn't access the video, was at the game and fight right in front of me. McGratten won the fight, simple as that. After McGratten wore his hand out on Shelley's helmet/head, Shelley hit a couple on Brian when he had slipped and on one knee. I am sure they will meet again.
Very good fight, nice to see McGrattan back at it again . Very close but edge to McGrattan
I usually don't vote for a winner if there's no loser. This was close to a draw by two definite gamers, so I looked at Shelly's face and go to this question: Which guy would you rather be at the end? Answer: Grats won.
Good fight but Mcgrattan gets this one.
nice tilt by McGrattan. Too bad his shoulder is screwed again.
McGratton shows why he fit in so well with the Senators with his theatrics after the fight. Please move the Coyotes to a hockey town.
Wow Jody took a couple heavy shots McGratton for the win
Hit the one in the middle Brian!!!!! I wonder how it felt to fight sober....or was he even sober....clearly a draw
I think Shelley gets this one as he had McGrattan in trouble at the end.. Up until then it was a slight edge to McGrattan.
welcome back mcgrattan!! in teh ahl he was one of hte most feared tough guys on the iceee. and im glad tos e him back. what hapepned to shelley. he was so strong 1st half of the year, hes been getting into some questinable decisions lately. what happened to grats anywayss? first fight in over a year, wha hapepnd?
that was a slugfest mcgrattan gets the edge
Win for McGrattan. Jody is starting to tire out this season. Oh well-I'll never stop supporting him PS: What is this, AA? Ass Kissers Anonymous? Nauseating.
Nice to see Grats back
McGrattan by decision. Too far ahead on points when McGrattan went for the pad at the end.
Welcome back Brian McGrattan! Glad to see the big man got through the substance abuse program! Can't wait to watch him fighting again! Solid comeback fight, gave the nod to McGrattan in this one! Congrats on getting healthy!
Nice to see the coke snorting Grats out of rehab ,back in the NHL. He was a beast when he entered the league with the Sens, then turned into Miley Cote, the league's punching bag. He layed a nice beating on Jody Shelley (two chick names? Come on!), leaving his face a tad lumpy.
McGrattan - convincingly. I'm a Shelley fan but, he just looked out-classed in this one.
nice to see grats back...with the win too! love to hear panger describe a fight...holy jumpin'!
Good ol Shelley, finally getting in a punch as McGratton is bent over. LOL at the joker saying Shelley is "knocking on the door for #1 heavy". Are we watching different fights? I've been watching Shelley since his early Bluejackets days. He's average. Nothing more. Oliwa used to toss him around like a rag doll.
"Shelley gets this one as he had McGrattan in trouble at the end" You have to be kidding. The only punch Shelley landed was when they were finished and McGrattan was on his knees. That's why McGrattan held his hands up afterwards. He wanted to rub it in because of the late punch.
Good to see McGratts back!!!!!
Welcome back McGrattan.
grats hasnt lost it , w to mcgrattan in an ok'ish bout
im a huge shelley fan...but, a big win for mcgratton...nice job manning up gratts & takin charge of life...MG setting a good example....a 7
McGratten win. With at name like McGratten how could he possibly lose on St. Patrick's Day?
Grats with the win. Shellys face looks like lasagna. Thumbs up to the cameramen with the b-cam shot of the cheerleaders.
Nice fight,Mcgratten with the win, no knocks to Shelley, good fight from both, McGrattan landed the bulk of the shots and better shots too, not to mention the cheerleaders, someone needs to set up a site, www.hockeycheerleaders.com, it would be near as popular as this one.
mcgrattan slayed em
McGrattan handled Shelley.
I now have a reason to watch the Coyote's. Still not used to the #22 for Gratts, though.
McGratton, a ''poor-mans' Godard'' in the day, makes a triumphant return at Jody Shelleys' expense. I liked the ''Domi'' move at the end.