Scott Walker vs Michael Komisarek

This is case & point as to why the fighting instigator should be eliminated. Walker makes Komisarek eat the boards from behind(whom I normally view as a respectable player), and Komisarek sends the message that its unacceptable. What happens...ONe of the best Canadiens D has to sit for 10 misconduct & 2 min instigator for defending himself....RIDICULOUS

Walker wants to throw as Komisarek was passive.
Komi controlled, but Walker threw serious punches, early and late.
S.Walker got the edge/narrow win.

Not a great fight. Edge Walker.
I guess Komisarek did not like getting hit from behind, interesting, he does it enough.

It was a crap fight. I think Komisarek had a tough time with the big difference in height. Having said that, no excuse for him not spanking Walker.
Being a Habs fan, disappointed in this one !
Have to call it a draw

definitely should not be an instigator penalty in the NHL. at least Komisarek stuck up for himself, although it was probably a little anger to begin because halfway through he didn't look like he wanted it. edge Walker

What crap that Komisarek gets the extra 10!

Komisarek gassed when it got into heart range and wanted out of that fight by looking at the linesmen. Walker was still game. Walker wins the decision on aggressiveness.

Walker was busier and looked to land more so I give him the edge. Time to get rid of the instigator rule though. Enough is enough. Garry Bettman are you listening????? I didn't think so!!!

Walker beat him in a big-man-style fight. Admirable.

ok. i dont know why anyone would vote for walker. i understand the whole idea that he is gettign up there in age. and he put all his efforrt into it. but its clear and simple. HE SISNT LAND A SINGLE PUNCH. how would he win. Kom landed atleast three. so that make Kom the winner. god you peoiple really need to learn to actually watch these fights better. and stop seeing the winners s who you want to win. be un-biased for once

Komisarek was certainly justified in this one.Plenty of motive after a boarding,did a good job getting in a few while tying him up.Walker a much smaller guy though.

walker is a crap and komisarek takes 10mins to the penalty box because he was hit from behind

I think Walker got this one. He threw more and gave away a lot in size.

Walker landed some shots but none of them did some damage to Komisarek who is not a fighter

neither guy lands much. kman calls in the refs at the end, i dont like that