| Date / Time | Away / Home Team | Away / Home Player |
| Apr 05, 2006 | Ottawa Senators | Brian McGrattan |
| 1pd 16:38 | Buffalo Sabres | Andrew Peters |
| Comments: The two drop the gloves and square off at the blueline right when the puck is being played up ice. McGrattan grabs ahold of Peters and they hold each other at arms-length, exchanging a couple of jersey-jabs each. Peters throws three rights that hit McGrattan's helmet and McGrattan returns fire with a right that comes up short. McGrattan then throws two jersey-jabs and a right while Peters tries to lean away from the punches. Peters connects with two rights to the side of McGrattan's head before McGrattan throws a jersey-jab-right combination. They exchange jersey jabs, allowing McGrattan to throw a right that misses. They then throw two rights each, one of McGrattan's knocking Peters' helmet off. McGrattan throws another jersey-jab-right combination and the two go back and forth with a few long rights. They then tie each other up and stand there until the linesmen come in. | ||
| You must login to vote. You can sign up for free if you do not have an account already. |
| Andrew Peters | 45.9% | |
| Draw | 43.0% | |
| Brian McGrattan | 11.1% | |
| From 135 votes with an average rating of 6.0 | ||
| OHL | Mar 07, 1999 | 1pd 14:50 | McGrattan (SBY) | vs | Peters (OSH) | Details |
| AHL | Mar 05, 2003 | 2pd 11:24 | Peters (ROC) | vs | McGrattan (BIN) | Details |
| NHL | Sep 19, 2003 | 1pd 06:28 | Peters (BUF) | vs | McGrattan (OTT) | Details |
| NHL | Oct 08, 2005 | 3pd 07:56 | Peters (BUF) | vs | McGrattan (OTT) | Details |
| NHL | Nov 02, 2005 | 1pd 03:14 | McGrattan (OTT) | vs | Peters (BUF) | |
| NHL | Feb 04, 2006 | 1pd 05:59 | McGrattan (OTT) | vs | Peters (BUF) | |
| NHL | Nov 18, 2006 | 1pd 03:03 | Peters (BUF) | vs | McGrattan (OTT) | |
| NHL | Feb 24, 2007 | 2pd 03:44 | Peters (BUF) | vs | McGrattan (OTT) | |
| NHL | Jan 04, 2008 | 1pd 02:43 | McGrattan (OTT) | vs | Peters (BUF) |

Not a slugone but there was good punching anyway.
Peters landed more but McGrattan took over later though as Peters fights in difficult position in the end.
Still it looks to me SLIGHT Win for A.Peters.