karap fight

a draw

Hopefully everyone actually watched this fight until the end and see that Booger lands 1 punch to the helmet and nothing else of consequence. Shelley doesn't really land anything either. DRAW The Booger slurpers are obviously out in full force today. lol Should I expect anything less? The guy hasn't done squat this season but people still will him to victories despite him doing nothing.

i hate how boogaard got excited when shelley falls and he goes and tries to hit on him while he's down. i hate that crap

A draw for me. Shelley lost in balance at the end when he tried to land a bomb

fuck booooooooogarrrd

The only reason Boogaard wins is because he's huge. His balance is terrible. If you can duck one of his bombs then you'd be able to land a few against him no problem. His fights are boring, I'd rather watch a good tilt between two middleweights who know how to fight.

The size differance was to much for Shelley, who though game, did'nt get the job done against Boogaard. Nothing to be ashamed of though.

the Boogey man vs the Mayor of the lollipop guild He broke his helmet with a punch, thats a hammer.

Good to see the Wild step up against a good team. Boogaard easily controlled this fight. This fight didn't seem nearly as impressive as the announcers made it out to be.

Shelly wanted a shot he got his ass handed to him but its nice to see the big guys go at it especially when the game is still on the line

Boooooooooooooooooogard wins another.....how do you fight this guy? His reach is Jurassic! Im sure Christine Neil could handle Boogy though!!! Doh.... That was an ironic statement for enquiring minds! Cheers! LOL

Booger wins this one . Jody ain't no slouch though.

Nothing hard actually landed. Boogie did throw Shelley around like a little school girl at the prom. Winner Boogard

Actually I think Shelley does better against Boogaard than most.BUT that is not to say that he won the fight. Boogaard landed the best punch. Win Boogaard

Too bad the BBBooooogggie man won't attack it much easier to whack someone who is lunging at you. But they better run a catscan on Jody as he might have a concussion.

Boogard wins just by breaking the helmet alone, most of his punches didn't connect cleanly, but when you have the power to break a helmet they don't have to connect cleanly,.

Shelly asked for it and boogie gave it to him.. boogie wins...

Boogard is the most over-rated fighter in hockey. "Too big"or "too much" for Shelley? Booger's lost fights before, gents. Lost 'em bad. Look it up. He wins this one, but it's not "domination" if you don't land half of your punches. Win Booger . . this time, if he can stay in the majors long enough. ***tty hockey player. Seriously.

Glad I don't play hockey. The Boogie Man is a freak. Did he really break his helmet? Good God.

Stop messing with your bucket, Shelley and throw a punch! Tough match, but W to Boogard.

i love shelley......but boogard stomped on his ass........good showing by boogard.........the one hit knocked shelly's mouthpiece out...........win for boogart in this one......shelley is one tough mother fuc***........was very enjoyable to watch....way to go boys

Shelly is a trooper....Boogaard's hands are going to be like Joey Kocur's if he continues to hit helmets like that.

a textbook Boogy win not letting the shorter man get inside and get going....long bombs not sure if anything landed to the face but Shelly lost a piece off his helmet with one blow....Boogy is a load when he's motivated clear win Boogaard

Good scrap. Boogie with the win, even though he didn't land many clean shots, a lot of shots to the back of the helmet. Shelley is still a stud, takes the punches and keeps coming back and never backs down. Much props to Shelley.

Easy win for Boogie. First he drops Andre Roy with a punch to the helmet, then he breaks Shelley's lid. Someone has to keep the helmet manufacturers in business.

boogy with the iron fist sends parts flying off the hat of jody. win boggy. BOOOOOOOOOGUAARD BITCHESSSSSSSSS

Boogard is a Colassal. Shelley stood in there but Boogard had the better scrap and gets the W

Both guys were throwing but Boogs landed the "helmet" shot for my win. If it would have been face and not helmet it would have been a remake of Fridge.

Boogy won...

boogaard cracked shellys helmet! it was crazy...but shelly did hold up well good fight good game! WILD ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!

nice fight but shelley was slow...

boogard with the win decent tilt

DB is at a point that unless you take advantage of some balance issues by keeping him moving, he'll set up and launch bombs that can't really be stopped except by the helmet or your grill...

It was a pretty good fight, but since shelley was the one that wanted to go should have put up a better fight.

Boogard is a beast......He will kill somebody someday.....a monster.

Boogaard wins. Amazing how so many posters have to say something negative about not liking this guy, yet they post comments that make it appear they have a fight club man crush on him. I heard he is +5 for the season and I saw his one punch on Roy on here. No one cares if you like him, like his hockey skill....this is a fight forum. Shut up about his hockey skills. He is one of the top 5 fighters in the NHL. That is what he is paid to do and that is his REAL and ONLY role...so get over it and like him for what he is. OH, and being huge is one of his assets, so when someone says he only won because he is huge...idiot...doh...and he can punch so hard that he can KO guys, break helmets and slow the rotation of the earth.

Turn off the sound and watch the fight. Boogaard was the winner. The clubbing was mostly off side of the helmet. Shelley was stunned but I didn't see any blood. Of course , it would have been a different story if he was hit cleanly on the jaw. But he was not.

Boogaard dominates. Shelley hanging on for dear life at the end.

Die hard Sharks fan, but this was DB's win. Shelley goes with everyone and did the right thing in trying to spark the Sharks. Both will go to pick the team up. Shelley did, and DB took care of business

I don't care much for Boogaard, but man is he great. Every time he fights I think more than any other fighter out there right now, there is such huge potential for a KO. The guy's a monster. Not that he dominated this fight really, but I still gave him the win. A scary man.

boogy all the way

shelley just hasnt learned his lesson boogaard has kicked his ass so many times, but i do give shelley credit for continuing to take the beatings boogey throws him.

Boogaard broke Shelley's helmet with a right.....wow..... Win Boogaard

this wasn't the runaway victory the anouncers made it out to but but the boogey man still gets a "W". *boogey needs to work on his balance he looks like a newborn calf wobblin around ou there...*

boogaard kicked shelley's butt,if you start a fight don't you think you should do a little better?also,i think the announcer started the party a little early,thinking it was a tooth instead of a piece of helmet.

pretty good fight between 2 heavyweights.

I am not a "Boogie Man" fan but what a shot. Against a guy like Shelly got to give him his "props"

Boogard just too fuckin big!

Boogard definitely got the better of Shelley even though he didn't kill him. Close but no cigar.

i wanna see boogaard takes on Artyukhin too... just want to see someone with similar size fighting..

Boogaard: The bane of helmet manufacturers everywhere.

Shelley just couldn't handle him. Boogaard has too much size. He should be destroying everybody!

I was actually at this game sitting right in front of the fight, it was bomb. Boogey owned on Shelley and you could tell at the end of the bout that he didn't want it to end.

Derek Boogaard with his best fight of the season. This was fun game to watch, almost with a playoffs atmosphere. The Wild fans were all pumped up and you'd have thought they were going to explode when their team won in OT.

wow...domination by boogaard as usual and against a big boy.....i cant believe he broke his helmet thats a first...boogaard is a f*ckin beast i love watchin him fight!!!

good action boog to big shelley has heart

did i hear someone say it would be a good match for boogaard to take on Evgeni Arthukin? The russian may look like something feirce but until he fights someone who is a true heavyweight he is nothing to mention........

good fight

Boogard is a beast but so is THE RUSSIAN on the lightning who bench presses over 400lbs and can throwem, with or with his visor.. He will give boogie a battle

Boogard. They both did damage but Boogard handed out more. Still props to Shelley for rocking with Boogard. Note Shelley lost that tooth long time ago.

Clear win for big Boogaard

Boogyman just made Shelley his BITCH

Easy win Boogaard

Easy win Boogaard

Edge Boogaard

Bye bye to half of Shelley's helemt

shelly is a salty dog. hung in there well but win Boogaard all the way Boogaard has just proven once again that he is the best toe to toe fighter in the NHL.

Boogaard ownage!

Win Boogaard... No question

winner=boogaard

Boogaard plain and simple

Win Boogaard

boogy is the man

Boogaard absolutely won this bout!

Boogie all night! The big man worked Shelley in this one. Kept his composure and choose his punches very well. RIP Boogie! Unforgotten!

Boogaard with maybe a slight edge, closer to a draw. Nobody lands a real solid punch. That said, Boogaard is still one of the worst, least talented hockey players in the league. It's pathetic.

On sportsnet the replay showed Boogaard breaking Shelly's helmet. Cool. Shelly is pretty tough for a guy with two chick names (Jody and Shelly for you Flyers fans)

You know, I was really dreading this game. Although I have no respect for The Mutant as a hockey player (but that isn't what this forum is about, is it?)-there are tough guys like Probert, Shelley, McSorley, even Brashear that can, or could play some-he's so big and strong that I knew my guy was in for trouble regardless of how good a year he's having. At least he was willing, as he always is, and didn't get killed. Win for Boogaard. Gee Cambric, thanks for clarifying things. What a fool.

Boogaard won the fight but most of his punches didn't land.

Win for boogaard. Check it out, a lot of the boogey hater comments are from 'nucks fans if you look at their profile.....Go figure.

Shelley showed character ( Lucic take note) but Boggaard clearly the winner.

Shelley had nothing -- looked way over-matched. Easy win for Boogaard but still needs better balance.

While Boogaard controlled the fight, nothing serious landed. It looks like Shelley could have gotten a charging penalty, at least judging from the short clip at the start. Shelley looks invigorated this year compared to his last few seasons with Columbus. You have to wonder if being on a winning team for the first time is have any effect on his performances.

Boogey dominates with the fists and in front of the net

Win for Boogard but not nearly as impressive as the announcers made it seem. Went from bloodying Shelly to knocking out a tooth to knocking a piece from his helmet. I think Boogard is one of the most over-rated fighters in the league.

Shelley is a glutton for punishment! The Boogeyman pummeled him.

slight edge boogeyman....shelleys still badass,comin in with cannonball 2 get it started

boogard with the win, but man, i don't think jody shelly can really be hurt,it must be like punching a stump

Wow good fight. Im a SJ fan and even i have to admit that Shelley got owned! Gotta give props to Shelley though for hangen in there but total domination by Boogaard

HAPPY NEW YEAR!!!!!..........Boogey made Shelley his girlfriend......is Boogey the current champ? Boogey vs. Laraque?......can't wait!

A decent fight. I liked the end where Shelley went down and Boogaard literally picked him back up to try and throw more punches.

The Boogeyman has got to be the #1 Enforcer in the League now..