Nick Tarnasky vs Matt Carkner

Taransky wins the body-checking event with a clean, albeit awkward, hit,
while Carkner holds the edge during the scrapping section of the festivities.

Looked like a clean hit to run over Carkner..
A few rights by both but nothing serious.
Fall by Tarnnasky was a slip...not a knock-down.
A clear Draw.

win carkner....good hit little nicky

ha Draw

tarnasky steppin it up. draw here

kind of funny, you can see Carkner go f-that after a big hit and goes for redemption

Tarnasky throws a right and connects with Carkner's face. Tarnasky, though, is the one to drop. So, in summary, Tarnasky commits an interference infraction as he runs the vulnerably positioned Carkner, decides to fight with a guy much more skilled than he, then falls to the ice after getting knocked down by Carkner's face. Embarrassing, to say the least...

carkner gets hit and goes after the guy! get the hell out of the NHL! I give the win in this non fight to tarnasky for the hit

Tarnasky for sure, he had a couple hits and a solid knock down check to boot! Loss of footing, no nuttin' for Carkner here folks!

Draw, neither got any good punches in.

Give Tarnasky props he means business lately, and even the beating he took from Colton Orr doesn`t prevent him from going right after the next heavyweigt in Carkner. Uneventful scrap though as both get one shot in before earth gravity takes over.
Draw

Hard to judge a Tarnasky fight when he falls down everytime he gets hit or swung around. Carkner obviously the stronger here. Win for Matt.

Looking at his numbers, even with the 3 losses to Orr, Carkner has won more fights this year than the Leafs have games.

lot of swinging and some twirling and flash dancing little or no fight.

kind of a cheap hit,carkner was just getting up from check, not much of a fight but it looks to me carkner did land the shot at the end to drop tarnasky. leafs,your a douche,orr won 2 of the fights last one was crap and you know it homer......you still sniffin orrs jock?

Another funny one with Tarpansy doing his humpty dumpty sat on a wall routine. That's a new twist on the drop out of a fight routine. Looked like he must have stepped on te blue line. Draw in a crappy pushing contest.