Chris Neil vs Luke Schenn

Good job by the kid to go right in there without hesitation, but in the end, experience wins the day.

Way to go trying to end a player's season, Chris, with that terrible knee on knee check on Stajan. Schenn showed the Leafs he wants to stay and that no doubt earned him the respect of his teammates. Even with the loss, kudos go to Luke.

Tons of respect goes to Schenn for instantly sticking up for his teammate and having the balls to take on a guy he knew would kick his ass. You could tell during the replay that he was bracing to be punched before he even grabbed Neil's jersey. I give Schenn a standing O for what he did, but unfortunately he doesn't come close to getting the W.

Winner - Neil.

dirty hit neil.. . dink move...ls took his whoppin like a man

After watching the slow-mo replay, it's clear Neil moved the left skate over to clip the leg of Stajan. I Don't give a rats ass either way about either team or player, it was a low-brow move that could've injured the other dude badly. This was one of the rare responses by the Leafs fighter (who lost the fight) this year that was expected because of a dirty play.

Carcillo gets a suspension for reaching into a fight off the bench, and this choad isn't bounced for a clear intent to injure action? Lame.

Quick, ok fight.
Neil took over later, for the EDGE/NARROw win.

The easiest "W" neil is gonna get this year. about the hit: looks like a knee on knee to me although stajan does try to avoid the hit so i'm not sure this was intentional.

Schenn has become Stajan's personal body guard.......Isn't there anyone else on the Leafs that can fight or are they relying on the 18 year old? I mean this kid is no Lucic!!

Win to Neil, but many respect points for Schenn!

This isn't called pick the guy you like better..or give some lame excuse as to wy I am voting for the guy that clearly lost. Give me a break. Neil easy win.

the kid knocked neil down and let him back up should have done like the loser neil did and keep swinging, neil has so much class

Luke Schenn takes an exception to a knee-on-knee hit by Neil on Matt Stajan and immediately gets it on with Neil.
Both of them grab each other pretty fast and exchange a few punches, but mostly misses. Then Schenn tangles down Neil but lets him get back up on his feet. Neil, completely the douchebag he his, gets up and immediately starts throwing what looks like babykiller blows. After a few more exchanges, Schenn drops to one knee (due to off-balance) and Neil starts throwing real hands towards the now kneeing Schenn and the referees step in.
Despite the fact Neil didn't show any class whatsoever and didn't let Schenn come back up, one's gotta give props to Luke for squaring off in his first season, more noticeably with a guy like Neil.
Close fight, Neil might have had a very slight edge due to punching on a fighter who is down on one knee, but I'll score this a draw.

Schenner sticking up for the team as he always does. had the visor on so it was a low risk call. Good on him, but once the lid came off it was all Neil.
Edge Neil, but it coulda been worse.

Schenn wins by the curve, Neil is still and always will be the biggest P*SSY in the league. Please reference Neil vs SOMIK (of all people).

Schenn started strong then Neil's experience took over. Kudos to Schenn to stepping in. No matter how many times Schenn could have hit Neil's face he couldn't make him any uglier anyways, 24/7 "why me pout".

Enough about Neil sticking his knee out. He had stajan lined up and stajan tried to avoid the hit. It happens... Neil KO'd the kid, but Schenn knew it was coming and just wants to stay in the lineup.