Mathieu Roy vs Jody Shelley

Pretty Good fight. Shelley Threw a good hard body check seperating the man from the puck. Roy did a good job stepping in to defend his teammate but bit off a little more than he could chew.

Could not disagree with wallsy more. Just because it is the "new" NHL does not mean that you skate with your head down. Contact is part of the game along with fighting. Good players and goalies are getting "run" because the "new" NHL is trying to curb the physicality and fighting, therfore, there are no repercussions for these actions (i.e. having to fend for yourself in a fight after cleaning a skilled player's clock). I respect Roy for stepping up. The NHL needs more of this and more old time hockey.

Mathieu Roy vs Jody Shelley

Shelley puts a big hit on Smid, Roy takes exception and goes after him. Roy throws a couple lefts, as Shelley gets it going with a few rights. Shelley rips Roy's helmet off, and throws a few solid rights that connect. After that, Shelley wrestles Roy to the ice, and the linesmen move in.

Good job roy you have to protect your teamates.

Oilers are sure missing the heaveyweight champ Laraque, the Mike Tyson of hockey fighting. Oilers Should never have let big George leave.

Nice hit by shelley. Not cheap at all wallysy1. I gave Shelley the edge in the fight for the first right before the camera cut and the takedown. Close fight though. Good job by Roy, he did the right thing.

Shelley should have mopped up the ice with Roy. bad showing if ya ask me.

It was a clean hit by Shelley, and a nice looking one at that. I think it was obviouse that Shelley was the victor...... people on this site don't tend to vote very fair. At leaste we got this one right.

Shelly proving yet again hes dirty as well as ugly.

I like this fight because you have stick up for your teammates I'ed like to see more of it but with the new rules there eliminating the physicality of the game and turning it into basketball (he hit my hand before I shot thats a penalty) whaat happened to hockey I guess it has to be a G rated games so church folk come to watch on sunday (Dont mean to affend anyone its a phrase to discribe the paly of games now) we as fans need to change what we want to see because the leauge wont

What a hit by Shelley Wau!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Nice job by Roy in sticking up for a teammate. Didn't hesitate in going after an established fighter. The fight itself rated a draw. Shelley may have snuck one in but between the camera coverage being slightly late, from a distance etc, it was difficult to see what landed so i called a draw due to an even punch count and no damage done.

pretty much a draw here I think. Good for Roy for stepping up though.

another case of a goon going after a skater.
the one guy is holding the kid--while shelly cheap shots him--no chance.
thats a load of crap...