| Date / Time | Away / Home Team | Away / Home Player |
| Jan 15, 2000 | New Jersey Devils | Krzysztof Oliwa |
| 1pd 16:43 | Philadelphia Flyers | Sandy McCarthy |
| You must login to vote. You can sign up for free if you do not have an account already. |
| Not enough votes to display results |
| NHL | Feb 22, 1999 | 1pd 03:08 | Oliwa (NJD) | vs | McCarthy (TAM) | Details |
| NHL | Oct 30, 1999 | 2pd 14:33 | Oliwa (NJD) | vs | McCarthy (PHI) | Details |
| NHL | Dec 22, 1999 | 1pd 14:10 | McCarthy (PHI) | vs | Oliwa (NJD) | Details |
| NHL | Feb 23, 2001 | 2pd 06:56 | McCarthy (NYR) | vs | Oliwa (PIT) | Details |
| NHL | Mar 12, 2001 | 1pd 10:51 | Oliwa (PIT) | vs | McCarthy (NYR) | Details |
Sandman with a NARROW win in very good and long battle.
Oliwa tryed to throw first in his long rights but missing many of them(almost all).
Sandman got in a great flurry at the start, landing them perfectly as he ate one from Oliwa.
Later of the fight they started grappling, tying up to each other but Sandman took over then in the end pounding Oliwa to the ice.