Shelley didn't even land anything here. Goddard landed the only solid punch and bailed because he couldn't see sh1t.

Bad move by Godard not tying his jersey down (?) Love the pens, but Shelley is a damn good fighter. They should go again. ASAP.

Posted by gmr133 on Oct 30, 2008 at 1:58 PM agree disagree Shelley wins. Is Pittsburgh missing BGL yet? .. ummm .....NO !

Shelley gets the win

Shelly better be careful takin shots on a jersied player, what goes around comes around...should be a better tie down to prevent that.....

That was very one sided, how can someone say that was a draw unless they are a penguins homer ??? Shelley with the win

No question. A win for Shelley.

Who was crazy enough to call that a draw??????????A DRAW? Mad sweater Jabs.

Was at this game and saw them yapping before the face off. Godard got a good shot in on the chin of Shelley, but once the jersey came up he was a sitting "penguin". Got to give the decision to Shelley. Rematch Feb 11 in Pittsburgh assuming they're both in the lineup... lostit23 mark your calendar so you don't forget they actually do play again this year.

not close at all

That was a good showing for Shelley. He looks like a new player in San Jose as opposed to when he was in Columbus.

A lame win for shelley pulling the jersey over Godards face and keeping it there.

slight edge 2 shelly but not by much here..better fight if godard could see

Clear win for Shelley

Not the winner I expected, but nonetheless, a good honest scrap between two legit heavies at center ice that Shelley, suprisingly controlled even before the shirt came up.

Like both these guys, Shelley looks alot better so far this year than the last couple, getting back into old form maybe. It was over after the jersey slipped up over the head. Whoever voted Godard on this one, hope that it was a mistaken vote

Wow...I've never seen jersey jabs work so effectively against anyone. Goddard got in one good punch before his sweater was pulled over his noggin...Shelley with the decisive victory!

Shelley really has got his game back after a disappionting spell as a fighter. Its too bad Godard got sweatered cuz this fight really had the making for some bombs to be thrown. Win for Jody for landing some hard shots anyway in a good scrap.

Not a great fight but a big win for Shelley, he really tagged Godard with those 2 hard rights and sends him reeling. Wish it could have gone longer but fights aren't always like that.

Shelley owned this fight. The jersey jab is for peewee.

Shelley! So far this year,,,he looks like he is eight years younger,,,with experience!

Great job by Shelly to beat one of the best IMO.

Forget the "draw" votes...who could have actually picked Godard in this fight? Shelley was a clear winner...and I hate him...

Good win for Shelly very suprised at Goddard getting humiliated that way it sure wasnt up to his satorial standards

Too brief. Win for Jody, but was anticipating more. Those jersey jabs really can be effective at times.

Nice tie down. Lucky for Godard to get out early. Shelley would own him.

Shelley won in a landslide. Godard's worst showing this season. Those "jersey jabs" are as honorable as kicking someone in the balls.

Shelley wins this one pretty easy, shelley threw some quick lefts and than a huge over the top right hand that connected.

very good start to the year for Shelley so far! shades of his rookie season here.

who the hell voted for godard!?

Shelley was better late. Godard anded the best punch. EDGE/NARRow win to goes for Shelley.

Well, no damage done but I still gotta say Shelley took it for getting the jersey over Godard's melon and chucking some major knuckles into his helmet. Hate the 'jersey jab'.

one of Jody's better; not one of Eric's....

Shelley dropped some bombs!

Can we PLEASE get rid of this candy arse "Jersey Jab" crap? NOBODY likes fighting more than me ,but when these guy's start with the rediculous jersey jabs and kidney punches than something has to be done. This isn't Boxing or UFC, throw your punches old school style and not like they do now. Most guy's don't "Fight" now, they hang on and are afraid to get hit while jabbing.

That is the way to use the sweater punch. They teach boxers to throw a jab and follow the jab with a straight right to the same spot that they throw the jab. That is what Shelley did. Shelley is having a good year so far. Godard is too capricious. When he lands the big right he hurts people. Too many times, he can't get anything going like in this fight.

Not Godard best effort

Win for Shelley.

Solid win for Shelly, he looked damn good and like its been said thats how you jersey jab and a great overhand right from Shelly to help Godard to his knees..... thats a fukin hockey fight Boiz

win Shelley.Two good fighters.Too bad Godards sweater got pulled over his head .they need a re-match..

Great turn-around for Shelley this year, his fights last year were subpar.

Shelley did well and gets the win. My man Godard was up for anything though. Looking forward to round two later in the season.

I'd like to nominate bluesrule08 for 2 awards: -wow.....did you watch the fight you ignorant d*ck -Godard bl*wer of the year WOW

Shelley appeared to get in a couple of more shots but nothing seemed to hit Godard directly. I'm not a fan of these staged bouts.

Godard dont lose many.... and I didnt think that Shelly was quite that tough although in Godards defence the early jersey malfunction and the slip on the ice was a huge factor (I guess thats part of the fight game tho) and Shelly owned this one after that... Id like to see the rematch!

And this is why Tie Down Straps should not be mandatory. I remember the days of Ray, Probie, Marty and The Grim Reaper. There shirts would fly off and a "Real Fight" would be on. I am a Pens Fan, but man, Shelley all the way. It happens. (Anyone wanna see Bettman and Campbell drop some mits against the boys on the ice. God, they ruined are beloved religion of the stick!)

Shelley rocked Godard. Shelley gets the win.

Shelly dominated. For everybody that complains about the jersey jabs, that is a technique in fighting on ice that some of the best fighters use. Look at DJ King, or Scott Parker and some of the others. It throws their opponets off ballance, plus its kind of hard to see what your doing when some guys fist is in your face. For the people that says it doesnt hurt, grab the shirt you have on right now and punch yourself in the nose and let us know how it went.

Clear win for Shelley.

Shelley broke Goddard nicely

domination by Shelley... art24- a rematch would be great, too bad this is the only time this season they play each other!!!

All Shelley

Shelley with the clear win.

Shelley stomped the mudhole in this one. Godard was smart for getting down when he did, because he was gonna get killed.

Shelley been looking pretty bad ass this year clear cut victory.

Shelly gets the upper hand in this one...jersy over the head and pow. Not hard to tell who gets the "W" here. bluesrule08 on Oct 29, 2008 at 2:13 PM clearly a win for godard..wow what a fight ?you must mean shelly right?

This fight reminded me of the days of Shane Churla, Stu Grimson, Tony Twist, Bob Probert, etc when heavyweights would just stand back and throw bombs. The only thing I disliked here was Shelley continuing to hit after Godard's jersey got up over his head. Still, you only see 1 of these for about every 15 wrestling, grabbing hugfests.

The biggest difference between Shelley this year, and Shelley last year, is his use of the jersey jab. it was on full display here, and he crushed a top notch heavyweight.

Did someone out there really think that Goddard won this fight?

Domination by Shelley. Love the over hand rights

Jody we sure miss you in Columbus!!!!!!!!

I wish they'd let them fight longer but understand that it had to be stopped since Godard couldn't see. Shelley very much won.

Shelly clearly...Loved that is was at center ice!!!! way to go Jody keep it up!

Godard did you have your fight starp on?

clearly a win for godard..wow what a fight

They landed a good right and a few jersey jab lefts. Did you count the shots to the helmet after the jersey came up? Punches to the helmet don't hurtthe other person only you. Draw.

I gave this one a draw because it looked like Goddard landed a sweet right and Shelley didn't seem to connect with much even thought he threw a lot more. Even in my eyes And can we outlaw this short jab BS. Its annoying.

Shellnation Domination

JS dominated

Shelley wins. Is Pittsburgh missing BGL yet?

Edge to Shelly he actually caught him twice when his head was trapped in his jersey

shelley used the jersey jab very effectively, even getting godards jersey to pop over his head. win shelley

shelley all the way

Shelley used all the tools available to him, a nice win for Shelley.

good use of jersey jabs...a few comments.....slshbleed gets word of the day w caprious,nice job.... stacyb a whatchutalkinboutwillis 2 u about the fixed fight comment..& last but not least battleaxe13 there are not many guys give up their advantage when fighting,its not lame win...i could not help chiming in

Made him his bitch.

I like Godard but Shelley landed the bigger blows and got the jersey up.

Nice shot!!!!

shelley pounded godard to the ice.

Godard goes to punch for the big one. he landed about 2 of them . but he gives up way to many hits when he does that. Easy win for Shelley. lol at the jersey jab infomercial comment from goon10.

That looked like a jersey jab infomercial.