| Date / Time | Away / Home Team | Away / Home Player |
| Mar 21, 2009 | New York Islanders | Joel Rechlicz |
| 2pd 17:06 | Ottawa Senators | Mike Fisher |
| Comments: | ||
| You must login to vote. You can sign up for free if you do not have an account already. |
| Mike Fisher | 38.9% | |
| Draw | 37.4% | |
| Joel Rechlicz | 23.7% | |
| From 131 votes with an average rating of 5.4 | ||

And although Fisher seemed to hold a slight edge throughout,
Rechlicz didn't seem any worse for wear afterwards.
All things considered, you'd have to go back to the McGrattan days in order to find the last decent Senators' scrap.