I gotta go with Shelley. More damage inflicted. And when was the last time the "Other Penalties" section listed "xxxxx received a too many men on the ice penalty"?? Bench minors don't normally breed fisticuffs.
Westgarth stung Shelley with the sweater punch. Not everybody can throw the sweater punch and do damage. Also, either Shelley's punches didn't land that flush or Westgarth has no pain receptors in his head. I think Westgarth landed the more quality shots.
Shelly wanted it more at the start but it was an even if not spiritied bout. Obviously the kind of fight where partisans can pick and choose good moments for either combatant. In my book that means a draw.
Great show by both man in this good scrap.
Both sneaked in several shots, shelley landed mostly better.
Its either draw or edge Shelley but i choice a DRAW because Westy actually landed some impressive uppercuts.