| Time | Away | Home |
| 1pd 18:20 | Darren McCarty (DET) | Kelly Buchberger (PIT) |
| Comments: McCarty elbows a Penguin, and Buchberger immediately comes in and challenges McCarty. McCarty starts out with three rights. They wrestle for a little bit then Buchberger lands two solid lefts. Both guys begin to throw wildly with not much landing. McCarty then lands a couple of more rights on the hunched over Buchberger. They wrestle a little more and the linesmen break it up. Other Penalties: McCarty received an elbowing. | ||
| Voted winner: Darren McCarty (87.0%) - Voted rating: 5.1 | ||