| Time | Away | Home |
| 2pd 09:57 | Arron Asham (NYI) | Matt Barnaby (NYR) |
| Comments: The two are talking before the faceoff and they drop em once the puck is dropped. They are over near the Isles' bench and Matt is jawing at them while Asham is swinging. A few punches that don't connect, then Barnaby decides to try to throw a few. When he opens up, Asham does the same and starts to hit him pretty good. They exchange with Asham definitely doing better, but nothing devestating. They go down with Asham on top. | ||