| Time | Away | Home |
| 2pd 12:33 | Colton Orr (NYR) | Riley Cote (PHI) |
| Comments: | ||
| Voted winner: Colton Orr (91.2%) - Voted rating: 7.5 | ||
| Time | Away | Home |
| 2pd 12:33 | Ryan Hollweg (NYR) | Jim Dowd (PHI) |
| Comments: | ||
| Voted winner: Draw (58.8%) - Voted rating: 3.0 | ||
| Time | Away | Home |
| 2pd 12:33 | Fedor Tyutin (NYR) | Steve Downie (PHI) |
| Comments: | ||
| Voted winner: Steve Downie (86.0%) - Voted rating: 5.2 | ||
| Time | Away | Home |
| 2pd 20:00 | Brandon Dubinsky (NYR) | Mike Richards (PHI) |
| Comments: | ||
| Voted winner: Mike Richards (93.7%) - Voted rating: 5.7 | ||