| Time | Away | Home |
| 1pd 15:08 | Riley Cote (PHI) | Arron Asham (NJD) |
| Comments: Right off of the faceoff they drop the gloves and square off near the blueline. They grab ahold of each other and immediately start going toe-to-toe with lefts. Asham goes down to a knee, but gets back up after a moment. They start going toe-to-toe with lefts once more until Asham finally lands one that sends Cote down to the ice. Asham falls on top of Cote and the linesmen jump in as well. | ||
| Voted winner: Arron Asham (58.4%) - Voted rating: 8.4 | ||
| Time | Away | Home |
| 2pd 10:25 | Ben Eager (PHI) | Sheldon Brookbank (NJD) |
| Comments: Brookbank bumps Eager into the boards. Brookbank then shoves Eager and they decide to drop the gloves. They grab ahold of each other and wrestle around for a moment. Eager gets loose and throws an uppercut inside. They exchange short rights before grappling some more. Eager throws two rights and a body shot. Brookbank pushes Eager up against the boards and throws a right. Brookbank follows up with a right cross that lands. They continue to wrestle around until the linesmen decide to intervene and end the fight. | ||
| Voted winner: Sheldon Brookbank (63.9%) - Voted rating: 5.2 | ||