| Time | Away | Home |
| 1pd 16:00 | Andrew Peters (BUF) | Jody Shelley (CBJ) |
| Comments: Right off of the faceoff the two drop the gloves and square off at center ice. They grab ahold of each other and Shelley throws two rights followed by a series of rapid fire jersey-jabs. They go back and forth with rights as they come up next to the benches. Shelley throws a few more jersey-jabs while Peters ducks down. Shelley throws a right that knocks him off-balance, allowing Peters to throw two rights. They each get in a short right and then fall to the ice with Peters throwing a right as they go down. The linesmen then quickly jump on top of them and break things up. | ||
| Voted winner: Andrew Peters (50.0%) - Voted rating: 5.2 | ||