| Time | Away | Home |
| 1pd 05:22 | Dion Phaneuf (CAL) | Ian Laperriere (COL) |
| Comments: Phaneuf crushes Brett McLean into the boards and Laperriere comes over and gets his stick up high on Phaneuf. Eric Godard has his stick between them as Phaneuf immediately drops his gloves and starts throwing punches at Lappy. Phaneuf gets in a couple of rights before the two start to wrestle. Phaneuf attempts to take Lappy's helmet off, but is unable to. Phaneuf then throws a few more rights, with one inside shot possibly connecting. They grapple and skate down the ice as Laperriere tries to get his right arm free. Laperriere attempts a right that doesn't make is as Phaneuf counters with two rights of his own. Laperriere then gets off a left and takes Phaneuf's helmet off. Laperriere then lands a short left as the linesmen come in. Other penalties: Laperriere received a cross checking. | ||
| Voted winner: Dion Phaneuf (79.3%) - Voted rating: 5.1 | ||