| Time | Away | Home |
| 1pd 02:34 | Colton Orr (NYR) | Donald Brashear (WAS) |
| Comments: Brashear runs into Orr at the blueline and shoves him just before the two decide to drop the gloves. They grab onto each other and Brashear throws a flurry of seven unanswered lefts until Orr eventually falls to the ice. Brashear gets in another left while Orr is down and the linesmen quickly rush in and grab the two, ending the fight. | ||
| Voted winner: Donald Brashear (92.1%) - Voted rating: 4.5 | ||