| Time | Away | Home |
| 1pd 10:03 | Ryan Hollweg (NYR) | Garnet Exelby (ATL) |
| Comments: Behind the play the two drop the gloves and quickly grab each other. Exelby throws six straight rights to start things off while Hollweg attempts to block the punches. Hollweg throws three rights and misses with another just before Exelby goes over the top with an overhand right that causes him to lose his balance and fall to the ice. The linesmen allow the two to stand back up and Exelby throws three rights until he switches hands and connects with a right uppercut. The two then hold on and the linesmen intervene shortly after. Other Penalties: Exelby received a slashing. | ||
| Voted winner: Garnet Exelby (87.8%) - Voted rating: 5.8 | ||
| Time | Away | Home |
| 3pd 09:06 | Colton Orr (NYR) | Eric Boulton (ATL) |
| Comments: The two meet up at center ice and quickly drop the mitts. They grab ahold of each other and quickly start throwing punches, exchanging simultaneous right hands. Orr throws two rights followed by one that misses over the top just before Boulton comes back with a right and an uppercut. They then exchange rights and Orr's shot connects right on the button, sending Boulton crumbling to the ice. Orr gets in another right while Boulton is on his knees, but the linesmen are quick to get in there and push Orr away. Boulton quickly gets up and each skate to their respective penalty boxes. | ||
| Voted winner: Colton Orr (96.3%) - Voted rating: 6.2 | ||