| Time | Away | Home |
| 1pd 07:37 | John Erskine (NYI) | Colton Orr (NYR) |
| Comments: Orr poke-checks Erskine along the boards, causing Erskine to trip over Orr's stick. Erskine gets back up and skates over to Orr with the two waiting until the puck moves away from them before they drop the gloves and square off. Orr grabs ahold of Erskine and throws a right, pauses, and then throws another right that clips the top of Erskine's helmet. Erskine returns fire with two rights that cause Orr to lose his balance. Erskine falls on top of him and the linesmen are in there quickly. | ||
| Voted winner: John Erskine (70.8%) - Voted rating: 4.2 | ||