| Time | Away | Home |
| 1pd 07:38 | Colton Orr (NYR) | Eric Godard (NYI) |
| Comments: The two come out of the penalty box and drop the gloves as they square off at center ice. Orr grabs on and throws two rights as Godard connects with a right of his own. Godard misses with a right before the two begin to go back and forth with hard rights, each landing a few. Orr throws two rights to the back of Godard's helmet as Godard connects with a straight right. Godard shakes off his elbow pad and the two start to exchange right hands again, each landing two. Orr misses with a right that Godard ducks under as the two wrestle around for a bit. Orr throws two rights and a jersey-jab before missing with a right. They exchange right hands once again before Godard lands a jersey-jab and Orr falls back, bringing Godard with him, ending the fight. Godard skates off with a bloody nose. | ||
| Voted winner: Colton Orr (50.9%) - Voted rating: 7.7 | ||