| Time | Away | Home |
| 1pd 02:31 | Brendan Witt (WAS) | Grant Marshall (NJD) |
| Comments: They start pushing and shoving in front of the Capitals' net and drop the gloves. Witt throws 4-5 rights to start things off as Marshall returns fire with two rights of his own. Witt throws another right as Marshall goes down to a knee for a moment. He gets back up and throws a few lefts while Witt is still throwing rights. Witt switches hands and throws two lefts before they get in tight and wrestle around, causing the linesmen to step in and end the fight. | ||
| Voted winner: Brendan Witt (65.4%) - Voted rating: 5.0 | ||