| Time | Away | Home |
| 1pd 19:27 | Grant Marshall (NJD) | Serge Payer (FLA) |
| Comments: They start talking while skating back from the New Jersey net and drop the gloves at the blueline. Marshall throws a quick right before they grab on. Marshall throws a right as Payer comes back with a couple of rights of his own. Payer then misses with a right allowing Marshall to switch hands and throw a flurry of lefts before they start exchanging punches: Marshall with lefts, Payer with rights. Marshall was able to get Payer's head down and started throwing numerous uppercuts. Payer returned fire with a left before the two wrestle each other to the ice and let the linesmen come in. | ||
| Voted winner: Grant Marshall (82.9%) - Voted rating: 6.5 | ||