Ottawa at Tampa Bay 3/29/11

[suckerpunch]

Originally Posted by Bileur

It's actually only 2 or 3 Lighting fans that are in denial about him saying i'm done. Everyone else actually goes by what Downie said and accepts the reality that Downie wanted the refs to break up the fight.

AKA bailed.

[Rugged]

I was just thinking, maybe the words "headbutt" and "I'm done" are one in the same for hockey doc?

Waiter: "How was your meal, sir."
hockey doc: "Excellent. Thank you"
Waiter: "Could I interest you in some coffee or dessert?"
hockey doc: "No, headbutt."
Waiter: "I'll bring you the check."

[suckerpunch]

Originally Posted by Rugged

I was just thinking, maybe the words "headbutt" and "I'm done" are one in the same for hockey doc?

Waiter: "How was your meal, sir."
hockey doc: "Excellent. Thank you"
Waiter: "Could I interest you in some coffee or dessert?"
hockey doc: "No, headbutt."
Waiter: "I'll bring you the check."

LOL
This.

[Juicys1]

So when a guy says "i'm done" in a fight he's bailing, I agree with this and therefore IMO Neil wins, the guy that bails, loses. Funny before Christmas when engelland says that same thing in the rematch with Orr while Orr(like Neil) continues to swing, I was roundly criticized for giving the fight to Orr. Engelland bailed therefore, Orr wins.....

[bigty]

Originally Posted by Juicys1

So when a guy says "i'm done" in a fight he's bailing, I agree with this and therefore IMO Neil wins, the guy that bails, loses. Funny before Christmas when engelland says that same thing in the rematch with Orr while Orr(like Neil) continues to swing, I was roundly criticized for giving the fight to Orr. Engelland bailed therefore, Orr wins.....

So I punch you 10 times in the face then say I am done, but you still want to fight because you have not touched me means you win right?

Not saying that happened here, but that logic, like most fight judging logic, has flaws.

[Juicys1]

Originally Posted by bigty

So I punch you 10 times in the face then say I am done, but you still want to fight because you have not touched me means you win right?

Not saying that happened here, but that logic, like most fight judging logic, has flaws.

I dunno, if you punch me ten times in the face and it has the basic effect of a mosquito bite and I catch you once on the nose and it makes your eyes water and rattles your cage and you say " I'm done" while I continue to swing, my logic is not flawed , evidently.

[DaveBrown69]

Chris Neil vs Steve Downie-Draw/Edge Neil.