NY Rangers at New Jersey 3/6/12

[rtocchet]

Originally Posted by hockey doc

50 lbs. and 8", just who was this beast he fought?

Good job by Janssen of hanging in there with Scott, draw. Funny how Scott has to force Janssen to fight but can't force Chara or Lucic?

clear as day win Carter, Dubinsky got his a$$ handed to him. I guess the weasel will be saying crap in the media about Carter now.

"I guess the weasel will be saying crap in the media about Carter now"Kind of what you are doing to Dubinsky on this "media" site.

Win Carter of course. Dubinsky needs some lessons from someone real quick before he takes on someone who really knows what they are doing. At least he is game though. If you don't give him that then you are just plain useless.

Edge Scott. Not really liking this guy. He is a poor man's Boogyman. Both guys were physical monsters......but at least Derek knew how to use that to his advantage. Scott is a Jay Caufield at best. I just hope that he doesn't cause the team an important goal come playoff times. He looks like he should still be playing pond hockey somehere.

[Philly Fan 27]

so did dubi run from clarkson all game or what? didnt see any of it

[Isles4life]

While the Dubinsky-Carter fight wasn't some massacre like some are describing it, it also wasn't particularly close like a couple posters are now trying to claim. It looked like Carter did a pretty good job of bouncing his fist off of Dubinsky's face a couple times, and he picks up the clear win.

I'm more curious to see the next episode of the Brandon Dubinsky Talk Show and see what he'll have to complain about from this game.

And Scott-Janssen was an ok tilt, Cam did a good job and was able to land a couple despite the reach disadvantage, but Scott still controlled enough of the fight to pick up the win.

[NYR24]

Originally Posted by Philly Fan 27

so did dubi run from clarkson all game or what? didnt see any of it

No, but Clarkson challenged Prust and Bickel, who both declined, to prove that he is not a spot-picker.

[mainsail]

Originally Posted by NYR24

Boulton did not fight Scott. Scott followed him down the ice while issuing a challenge and Boulton declined. Can't say I blame him, but it does make him look kinda bad after playing tough guy with Prust last game.

Janssen fought Scott, and while Cam did a good job considering the size difference, Scott controlled the fight and gets the win.

My apologies, you are, of course, correct. Janssen fought Scott, not Boulton. However, "scared weasel," describing a guy who has been a warrior in this league for 12 years...please, he's seen and fought much worse than Scott. Getting back to the Scott Janssen fight...yes, Scott was certainly never in danger, but for all the hype he certainly didn't impress anyone. Are there folks on this board who are placing Janssen in the top 5...or even the top 10 now?

[Plateworker]

Carter vs. Dubi...all Carter here not the beatdown some are saying but not really close either. Dont know when Dubi sliced up his hand or if that caused him to not punch anymore but he loss none the less and this Carter kid seems alright...not a bad fighter either.

Scott vs. Janssenn...Scott controls the whole fight...2 things goods job by Bam bam to get hold of that right hand(that was probably why he was gassed at the end of the fight which he never is) and props for going with the big man again.

Boulton loses a lot of respect from me though I know he is tough and not scared of Scott but dude you knew he was forcing the issue with Janssen and you did nothing, why are you here then...Bam took one for the team how about you do the same or maybe he just likes to fight Prust and look good instead of looking bad. Clarkson is another one I dont see anyone calling him out after getting challenged time and again turning down Rupp and Prust numerous times..pretty lame on his part and I like him...

[hockey doc]

Originally Posted by rtocchet

"I guess the weasel will be saying crap in the media about Carter now"Kind of what you are doing to Dubinsky on this "media" site.

Yeah, this site is surely the "media", everything posted here gets into the newspapers and on ESPN. You're as dumb as Dopeinsky.

[rtocchet]

Originally Posted by hockey doc

Yeah, this site is surely the "media", everything posted here gets into the newspapers and on ESPN. You're as dumb as Dopeinsky.

Dopeinsky........HAHAHA!!!!! You are a clever one aren't you???? King of the one-liners!!!!!

loser

[pmcginty]

Originally Posted by hockey doc

Funny how Scott has to force Janssen to fight but can't force Chara or Lucic?

i was wondering that myself.i keep reading how scott 'forced' bambam to fight, yet he couldn't force a bruin?


clear win carter

draw

[NYR24]

Originally Posted by pmcginty

i was wondering that myself.i keep reading how scott 'forced' bambam to fight, yet he couldn't force a bruin?


clear win carter

draw

How are some of you guys twisting Scott forcing Janssen to fight and not forcing Chara or Lucic to fight as a poor reflection on Scott? Chara is the Bruins captain and an all star and Lucic is a good player and would not fight Scott unless Scott did something extremely dirty to a teammate. Neither of them have to fight Scott (though I wish they would). Janssen, on the other hand, is Scott's counterpart and it is his job to fight the heavies. If Scott did what he did to challenge Janssen to Chara or Lucic the Rangers would've been shorthanded.

Good for Janssen to accept the challenge, but Scott can't be expected to force a fight out of everyone.

[hockey doc]

Originally Posted by NYR24

How are some of you guys twisting Scott forcing Janssen to fight and not forcing Chara or Lucic to fight as a poor reflection on Scott? Chara is the Bruins captain and an all star and Lucic is a good player and would not fight Scott unless Scott did something extremely dirty to a teammate. Neither of them have to fight Scott (though I wish they would). Janssen, on the other hand, is Scott's counterpart and it is his job to fight the heavies. If Scott did what he did to challenge Janssen to Chara or Lucic the Rangers would've been shorthanded.

((Good for Janssen to accept the challenge, but Scott can't be expected to force a fight out of everyone.))

That was the point, Scott somehow manages to avoid forcing the issue with anyone capable of giving him a battle or (gasp) beating him, hence the weak fight card.

[pmcginty]

Originally Posted by NYR24

How are some of you guys twisting Scott forcing Janssen to fight and not forcing Chara or Lucic to fight as a poor reflection on Scott? Chara is the Bruins captain and an all star and Lucic is a good player and would not fight Scott unless Scott did something extremely dirty to a teammate. Neither of them have to fight Scott (though I wish they would). Janssen, on the other hand, is Scott's counterpart and it is his job to fight the heavies. If Scott did what he did to challenge Janssen to Chara or Lucic the Rangers would've been shorthanded.

Good for Janssen to accept the challenge, but Scott can't be expected to force a fight out of everyone.

believe me, if scott grabbed lucic it would be on, and that would be a great tradeoff for the rags wouldn't it? and what does chara being capt and an all star etc. have to do with anything? that would be the excuse had scott actually tried to excersise a muscle other than his jaw and fight him, because again, that would have been a fantastic trade off for the rags, the all star for the plug - but scott somehow couldn't 'force' either one of them. to trot out the old 'penalty' excuse by claiming that had scott done the same thing to chara or looch as he did janssen they would have tucked tail is complete bs.

he cant be expected to 'force' a fight out of everyone, but he didn't even try against the bruins. that's kind of the point.

[nyrgoal]

Originally Posted by pmcginty

i was wondering that myself.i keep reading how scott 'forced' bambam to fight, yet he couldn't force a bruin?


clear win carter

draw

Maybe if you saw any previous posts you would see that Bam Bam has nuts the size of watermelon and said even though he was told not to fight, Scott kept calling him out and he took one for the team.

Janssen is useless to the Devils offensively and I dont mean that negatively, we all know what he is there for.

Scott was after Chara a few times that game, even after the game, and Chara never answered the bell. But why would you expect Chara or Lucic to fight a 4th liner like Scott? I like Scott and all but its not like he was running around all game crushing guys.

But how about instead of you two flames just digging as deep as you can to make up little faults at the Rangers how about you worry about the game this thread was for. Rangers vs NJ

[dlangdon1]

dubinsky lost fight not as big of a beating as some people are saying but a definate loss.

scott won fight controlled most of the action, couldnt get his hands free to really throw right hand.

[Ciccarelli]

Win Carter
Draw/Edge Scott