Who is going to be the Best Fighter and Scorer?

[Churla27]

I doubt Lucic will even score 15 goals this year, he's injured

[ScottRasner]

I think Rick Rypien shows from time to time that he can score, and even some times dangle. Not sure he can burrie enough to warrant himself being one of the elite "fighter goal scorers"

I think Lucic has the skills to be a 15-20 goal scorer with 10-15 fights a year.

If were talking a scorer that fights, every now and then, Iginla, hands down.

[BullyFan009]

Originally Posted by ScottRasner

If were talking a scorer that fights, every now and then, Iginla, hands down.

I would take Souray. I don't care if he's a dman.

[RedIce]

In terms of guys who have skill and will probably fight more than 10 times, Lucic tops the list. Guys like Rypien, Asham and Carcillo all have at least 3 points and 3 fights so far this year, and each could put up good numbers by the end of the season if they keep it up.

[dipandmitts]

Originally Posted by Ciccarelli

Sheldon Souray...can score 20 goals and fight heavyweights if he wants to.

my pick as well. i think he would,, if he had to , fight anyone in the league

[BrandonBoy]

Originally Posted by BullyFan009

I would take Souray. I don't care if he's a dman.

That goes for me too, he's tuff as nails, will fight anyone and do very well I might add and his cannon from the point always puts a good amount of pucks in the net.

Lets not forget Chara in this one as well. ( ill probably get pounced on for that though)

[Mr-Mustard]

Fighter who can score? Chris Neil.
15 games in he has 3 goals and 1 assist.
4 points, 4 fights.

[Killah_punk]

Originally Posted by Mr-Mustard

Fighter who can score? Chris Neil.
15 games in he has 3 goals and 1 assist.
4 points, 4 fights.

Mike Rupp has 4 goals, 5 points, and 3 regular season FM's and one from the preseason.

[moxie]

David Clarkson right now has 13 points in 16 games, basically on par with Iginla, but with 4 fights. Not sure if this kind of production will last all year with Clarkson or not, but he's tougher than Iginla, so I am giving him the edge for the time being. Not only is he pretty ****ing tough and able to produce at a fair clip for a player of his role, basically half of the goals he scores are game-winning goals.

With Matt Carkner on the team this year, I expect Chris Neil's numbers to get back up to where he belongs at around 25 to 35 points.

[moxie]

Originally Posted by Killah_punk

Mike Rupp has 4 goals, 5 points, and 3 regular season FM's and one from the preseason.

Don't expect that kind of pace to continue. As I mentioned in my previous post, Neil should be around 30 points this year, where as Rupp is a 10 point guy.

[Killah_punk]

Originally Posted by moxie

Don't expect that kind of pace to continue. As I mentioned in my previous post, Neil should be around 30 points this year, where as Rupp is a 10 point guy.

If he finishes with around 10 goals this year i will be happy.

[moxie]

Originally Posted by Killah_punk

If he finishes with around 10 goals this year i will be happy.

That is probably reasonable considering the good start he got this year, but he is usually only good for 2 or 3 per year. It would be interesting to look at his stats from NJ to see if his goals are in bunches, or if he produces at a steady clip.

[CanadianFlyer]

Originally Posted by Knucklechucker

Lucic, Iginla, Richards.
it all depends, how many fights do they need to be classified? how many goals?

Pop Quiz: 2 of these players will be on the Canadian Olympic team come February. Who are they?
Lucic isn't in the same galaxy as Richards & Iggy player-wise.

BTW - the best fighter in hockey for my $$$ is Cam Janssen. He's a f/&%$%'n rabid pitbull.

[Juha82]

Clarkson, Neil and Asham.
I say Clarkson.

[Magic66]

After the other night, I say

Bill Guerin