The Top 10 Thread

[steeldragon]

A little disconnected with all the going-ons in our wonderful world of hockey fights due to not having internet access at home, but whatever here goes.

1. Colton Orr
2. Derek Boogaard
3. Brian Mcgratton
4. Eric Godard
5. Georges Laraque
6. Matt Carkner
7. Steve Macintyre
8. Donald Brash*t
9. Wade Belak
10. Rick Rypien

I already disagree with my list. I think.

[fightingfan]

Originally Posted by steeldragon

A little disconnected with all the going-ons in our wonderful world of hockey fights due to not having internet access at home, but whatever here goes.

1. Colton Orr
2. Derek Boogaard
3. Brian Mcgratton
4. Eric Godard
5. Georges Laraque
6. Matt Carkner
7. Steve Macintyre
8. Donald Brash*t
9. Wade Belak
10. Rick Rypien

I already disagree with my list. I think.

brashear should be higher, godard lower, bgl lower. other than that it looks pretty good

[OneilltheGiant]

rypien might make top ten this year

He has no chance... The guy does not fight top fighters... If you where making a top 10 light-heavyweight list then yes he makes the top ten... A middleweight list then he makes the top 3......... But a list for the 10 best fighters in the NHL no chance...

[fightingfan]

Originally Posted by OneilltheGiant

He has no chance... The guy does not fight top fighters... If you where making a top 10 light-heavyweight list then yes he makes the top ten... A middleweight list then he makes the top 3......... But a list for the 10 best fighters in the NHL no chance...

he does and this is why...

the heavyweight division is struggling this year just like last year. we have heavies that have horrible records that you could stick at the bottom of the top ten like parros, ivanans, thornton, etc. or guys like janssen, rypien, asham who fight heavies once in awhile and have great records. IMO, these guys should be in it instead of the heavies with crappy records

[illukka]

Originally Posted by fightingfan

he does and this is why...

the heavyweight division is struggling this year just like last year. we have heavies that have horrible records that you could stick at the bottom of the top ten like parros, ivanans, thornton, etc. or guys like janssen, rypien, asham who fight heavies once in awhile and have great records. IMO, these guys should be in it instead of the heavies with crappy records

honestly middleweights or featherweights should not be on any top 10 list. if u count the entertainment value of them then yes but for a serious list it should be heavies only

[The Woodsman]

Originally Posted by fightingfan

he does and this is why...

the heavyweight division is struggling this year just like last year. we have heavies that have horrible records that you could stick at the bottom of the top ten like parros, ivanans, thornton, etc. or guys like janssen, rypien, asham who fight heavies once in awhile and have great records. IMO, these guys should be in it instead of the heavies with crappy records

Rypien doesn't fight heavyweights.

[jp4202003]

Originally Posted by moxie

Rypien doesn't fight heavyweights.

I know, its cause he's too small...

1) Boogaard
2) Scott
3) Orr
4) MacIntyre
5) McGrattan
6) Brashear
7) Godard
8) Laraque
9) Shelley
10)Carkner

[Banky]

see a lot of the same names here, and not a lot of justification. Laraque and Brash both don't deserve a mention on this thread anymore. i made this list of card, talent, activity, and success rate.

1.Booger
2.Mcgratts
3.Godard
4. Orr
5. Carkner
6. Scott- he should drop em more, and with some of the gentlemen listed above
7. Koci
8. Rypien- yes he is little but he is good regardless of his size
9. Boulton
10. Crombeen!! - i could name others but i i went with a different option.

[Killah_punk]

I don't got my Top 10 together yet as i will wait til towards the end of the season, but right now i would have McGratton in the top 3, he's rebounded nicely this season and he is entertaining to watch.

[OneilltheGiant]

Originally Posted by Banky

see a lot of the same names here, and not a lot of justification. Laraque and Brash both don't deserve a mention on this thread anymore. i made this list of card, talent, activity, and success rate.

1.Booger
2.Mcgratts
3.Godard
4. Orr
5. Carkner
6. Scott- he should drop em more, and with some of the gentlemen listed above
7. Koci
8. Rypien- yes he is little but he is good regardless of his size
9. Boulton
10. Crombeen!! - i could name others but i i went with a different option.

One of the worst lists yet....

[Banky]

Originally Posted by OneilltheGiant

One of the worst lists yet....

not at this point

[Knucklechucker]

Originally Posted by Banky

not at this point

Its top 3 worst lists.

[skacore]

1. Derek Boogaard
2. Brian McGrattan
3. Wade Belak
4. Colton Orr
5. Eric Godard
6. Georges Laraque
7. Matt Carkner
8. Jody Shelley
9. Raitis Ivanans
10. John Scott

[brawls16]

My Mid-season list would look like.....

As always, my list is a continued list, not just from this season.

1. Derek Boogaard
2. Brian McGrattan
3. Colton Orr
4. Wade Belak
5. Eric Godard
6. Donald Brashear
7. Matt Carkner
8. Jody Shelley
9. Shawn Thornton
10. Raitis Ivanans

The middleweights get my Honourable Mention: Cam Janssen, Jared Boll, Darcy Hordichuk and Rick Rypien! All beauties!

Steve MacIntyre would be Top10 if he knew how to play NHL caliber hockey. If he can stay up for a length of time, he's in my Top10.

Not Top10 at all!!
John Scott
Andrew Peters
Georges Parros
Riley Cote
Eric Boulton
David Koci
Georges Laraque

[Taubi]

In my opinion and actually "now"!!!

1. Boogaard
2. McGrattan
3. Godard
4. Carkner
5. Brashear
6. Orr
7. Scott
8. Belak
9. Shelley
10. MacIntyre (win over Brasher and Orr!)
----------

Laraque, Ivanans, Thornton, Parros, Koci and other Guys, are out of Bounds.

I love Rypien, Prust, Janssen, Hordichuk and Boll. The Middleweight-Class are more interesting this Year.