The Top 10 Thread

[EDDIESHORETOEBLAKE]

My current top 10 would be something like this:

(1) Brashear
(2) McGrattan
(3) Godard
(4) Laraque
(5) Fedoruk
(6) Shelley
(7) Boogaard
(8) Cairns
(9) Orr
(10) Vandermeer

[Rob666]

01. Brashear
02. Laraque
03. Godard
04. McGrattan
05. Fedoruk
06. Boogaard
07. Shelley
08. Boulerice
09. Orr
10. Brookbank

[avsrock19]

1- Laraque
2- Brash
3- Cairns
4- Belak
5- Walker ( he's better than u think
many could fill 6 through 10 including
Fedoruk
Peters
Boulerice
Domi
[Mcgrattan]
and many more

[MACRULES]

1 Laraque
2 Brashear
3 Todd Fedoruk very under rated but defintly one of the top ten
4 McGrattan
5 Chara many wont agree but I think he cracks the top 5
6 Godard
7Derek Boogaard
8 Chris Simon hes probably one of the top 3 but he dosent fight that much any more so I'm bring him down
9 Wade Belak
10 Matt Walker

Taxie scoded Colton Orr Cam Janssenn Chris Neil

[nyisles15]

My list was made in haste and I apparently had different criteria for some players so here is my new and improved list.
10. Domi/McCarty
9. Fedoruk-Finally the lone heavyweight on his new team but I have seen him take some good poundings in the past mostly from Cairns
8. Belak-Good scrapper but hasn't done anything that has impressed me this year.
7. Asham/Tucker- best pound for pound fighters for their weights
6. Boogard-He's a huge guy but still needs work with taking on smaller quicker opponents
5. Brasheer- Good seasoned fighter that when cut can still fire away
4. Godard- He has filled in for Cairns nicely this year and has shown he is one not to mess with. Scored major wins vrs Brasheer and may this year.
3. McGratton- Has given Godard a run for his money this year and has shown a lot of toughness and grit.
2. Laraque- This guy is prob the strongest on the list and I think respect and fear alone scores him a lot of victories
1. Cairns- I still haven't seen anyone fight him and score a major victory except for godard but those two are great friends and Carins didnt want to fight to begin with but he is the ultimate heavy weight.

[BigGeorges37]

As of now, my top 10 would look like this:

1) Georges Laraque
2) Donald Brashear
3) Brian McGrattan
4) Eric Godard
5) Todd Fedoruk
6) Derek Boogaard
7) Jesse Boulerice
8) Jim Vandermeer
9) Andrew Peters
10) Colton Orr

[Habs # 1]

1) Georges Laraque
2) Todd Fedoruk
3) Donald Brashear
4) Eric Godard
5) Jody Shelly
6) Brian McGrattan
7) Jim Vandermeer
8) Derek Boogaard
9) Colton Orr
10) Jesse Boulerice

[BigE#12]

It is constantly changing BUT here is my TOP 10
1 McGratts
2 Laraque
3 Brashear
4 Godard
5 Fedoruk (sh it we miss him)
6 Cairns
7 Shelley
8 Simon
9 Boogard
10 Worrell

[Ruutu_isaweasel]

here is my list right now

1) Georges Laraque- not very active but we all know he can compete with anyone.

2) Eric Godard- a few suprising endings in a lot of his fights have impressed me.best fight card this year i think

3) Brian McGrattan-a couple wars with Godard, Orr, drops Domi...tough kid

4) Todd Fedoruk

5) Derek Boogaard

6) Jody Shelley

7) Donald Brashear*cou***gh*

8) Eric Cairns

9) Jesse Boulerice

10) Vandermeer/Hordichuk

.....honorable mentions To Janssen,Tucker, Boulton, Langdon

I think i have a pretty good list but i would like to hear some of your opinions on it and how it could be adjusted

[Oiler]

1- Georges Laraque
2- Eric Godard
3- Brian McGrattan
4- Todd Fedoruk
5- Derek Boogaard
5- Matt Walker
6- Donald Brashear
7- Cam Janssen
8- Jim Vandermeer
9- Barret Jackman
10- Jesse Boulerice

[suckerpunch]

Here's mine...

(1) Laraque
(2) Brashear
(3) McGrattan
(4) Godard
(5) Fedoruk
(6) Shelley
(7) Boogaard
(8) Cairns
(9) Orr
(10) Simon

[miamiexisle]

My Top 10: 1-Laraque 2-Godard 3-Brashear 4-McGratten 5-Cairns 6-Boogard 7- Fedoruk 8-Peters 9-Erskine 10-Simon

[spiderarms]

1) BGL
2) Brash
3) Godard
4) Gratts
5) Cairns
6) Simon
7) Orr
8) Boogey
9) Fridge
10) Shelley

We need the following things to happen to be able to stablize the top ten better this year:

*Orr needs to play and fight.
*BGL and Brash need to fight Gratts.
*Simon needs more activity.
*Cairns needs to step it up and get back into
last years form.

IF THESE THINGS HAPPEN, AN OUT RIGHT CHAMPION WILL BE EASY TO DETERMINE.
FOR NOW, PAST HISTORY IS PLAYING A BIG PART IN DETERMINING THINGS.

[shawna 24]

Last years

1. matt johnson
2. eric cairns
3. georges laraque
4. donald brashear
5. scott parker
6. reed low
7. wade belak
8. jody shelley
9. ryan vandenbussche
10. andrew peters

this years list...

1. georges laraque
2. eric godard
3. donald brashear
4. derek boogaard
5. todd fedoruk
6. brian mcgrattan
7. jesse boulerice
8. jody shelley
9. Jim vandermeer
10. andrew peters

[nyr2]

1. Laraque-heavyweight champ

2 through 6 or 7 could change on a nightly basis, but this is as of right now.

2. Godard-having a great season
3. Mcgrattan-great rookie, leaves himself open but still top 5
4. Boogaard-after losing a few has come back strong
5. Fedoruk-good showing as top guy in anaheim
6. Boulerice-always solid
7. Shelley-same as above
8. Janssens-possibly the best middleweight right now, would like to see him go with some heavys to see what he really has.
9. B. Jackman-really showing what hes made of, fights with anger
10. Peters-needs to fight more but still a top 10 guy

honorable mention to hordichuk, walker, vandermeer