The Top 10 Thread

[fightingfan]

Originally Posted by ShelleyFan45

Speaking of Gratton, I really hope he gets a full time gig in the NHL next year. I know he got hurt or he might have spent most of this season up with the Flyers, but I hope he makes the team out of camp next year or catches on somewhere else where he'll get to be in an NHL lineup every night. His fights are just so damn entertaining.

i dont know why everyone is all about gratton. yea he goes toe to toe but i never see power in his punches. i didnt like him in philly at all this year

[jkidd]

1. Eric Godard
2. Wade Belak
3. Donald Brashear
4. Colton Orr
5. Georges Laraque
6. Derek Boogaard
7. Jody Shelley
8. Raitis Ivanans
9. Michael Rupp
10. Matt Walker

Really tough year to put this together. A lot tougher than years past, IMO.

[OneilltheGiant]

Originally Posted by fightingfan

i dont know why everyone is all about gratton. yea he goes toe to toe but i never see power in his punches. i didnt like him in philly at all this year

It was great to have many tough guys in and around the team, but I was hoping for a top tough guy like we used to have in Brashear.. I think Philli need a top heavyweight next season, someone like Boogie or Belak, or even a guy like MacIntyre that's out to prove themselves..

[Nightshade88]

Originally Posted by jkidd

1. Eric Godard
2. Wade Belak
3. Donald Brashear
4. Colton Orr
5. Georges Laraque
6. Derek Boogaard
7. Jody Shelley
8. Raitis Ivanans
9. Michael Rupp
10. Matt Walker

Really tough year to put this together. A lot tougher than years past, IMO.

Nice top ten. I think was thinking about moving Laraque down because he didnt have a great season.

[SnowballIsChamp]

1. Donald Brashear
2. Wade Belak
3. Colton Orr
4. Eric Godard
5. Georges Laraque
6. Derek Boogaard
7. Cam Janssen
8. Andrew Peters
9. Raitis Ivanans
10. Darcy Hordichuk

HM’s

Shelley – Was a sure thing until February. He had a bad end to a strong season that pushed him off the top ten list.

W. Brookbank – Had a great start to the season and along with Shelley was on his way to the list. Then that scumbag Paul Maurice was hired and 2 days later Brookbank had his 6th and final NHL fight of the season.

Boulton – A strong season from Boulton. He could have been on this list if he had a few more heavyweight scraps that he didn’t get pounded in.

[Juha82]

Not a bad list Snowballischamp.
I still wonders Peters rank.
He did win couple/few guy but also he was weak later of season.

I think interesting list!

[fightingfan]

Originally Posted by SnowballIsChamp

1. Donald Brashear
2. Wade Belak
3. Colton Orr
4. Eric Godard
5. Georges Laraque
6. Derek Boogaard
7. Cam Janssen
8. Andrew Peters
9. Raitis Ivanans
10. Darcy Hordichuk

HM’s

Shelley – Was a sure thing until February. He had a bad end to a strong season that pushed him off the top ten list.

W. Brookbank – Had a great start to the season and along with Shelley was on his way to the list. Then that scumbag Paul Maurice was hired and 2 days later Brookbank had his 6th and final NHL fight of the season.

Boulton – A strong season from Boulton. He could have been on this list if he had a few more heavyweight scraps that he didn’t get pounded in.

not bad i would just take out peters

[tomales2]

Originally Posted by todd fedoruk 29

1.Wade Belak
2.Georges Laraque
3.Donald Brashear
4.Eric Godard
5.Derek Boogaard
6.Colton Orr
7.Shawn Thornton
8.Josh Gratton
9.Riley Cote
10.Daniel Carcillo

What?!!

[Philly Reign]

Donald Brashear is a friggen tool. He's nothing but a goon with absolutely no skill whatsoever. I like my fair share of stone-knuckled brutes, but I also enjoy a player who offers more to his team than just head hunting. I wouldn't mind seeing Brashear go face first at 100mph into the glass and watch his mouth explode and his teeth fly into the stands.

[Philly Fan 27]

Originally Posted by Philly Reign

Donald Brashear is a friggen tool. He's nothing but a goon with absolutely no skill whatsoever. I like my fair share of stone-knuckled brutes, but I also enjoy a player who offers more to his team than just head hunting. I wouldn't mind seeing Brashear go face first at 100mph into the glass and watch his mouth explode and his teeth fly into the stands.

brashear is one of the only full time enforcers who can take shifts ont he 3rd line. he actually might be the best skilled enforcer in the league.

[acdcrocksno1]

1 Donald Brashear
2 Laraque
3 Orr
4 Chara
5 Thornton
6 Cote
7 Asham
8 Boogard
9 Ivanans
10 Shelley

(why isnt carcillio in list?)

[OneilltheGiant]

Originally Posted by acdcrocksno1

1 Donald Brashear
2 Laraque
3 Orr
4 Chara
5 Thornton
6 Cote
7 Asham
8 Boogard
9 Ivanans
10 Shelley

(why isnt carcillio in list?)

Terrible list... No Belak no Godard and you have guys like Thornton, Asham, Cote and Chara who's not a regular fighter on the list...

[Philly Fan 27]

Originally Posted by acdcrocksno1

1 Donald Brashear
2 Laraque
3 Orr
4 Chara
5 Thornton
6 Cote
7 Asham
8 Boogard
9 Ivanans
10 Shelley

(why isnt carcillio in list?)

b/c everyone in the top 10 would kill carcillo

[Knucklechucker]

Originally Posted by acdcrocksno1

1 Donald Brashear
2 Laraque
3 Orr
4 Chara
5 Thornton
6 Cote
7 Asham
8 Boogard
9 Ivanans
10 Shelley

(why isnt carcillio in list?)

THis has to be a joke.

[clydefrog]

Originally Posted by Philly Fan 27

brashear is one of the only full time enforcers who can take shifts ont he 3rd line. he actually might be the best skilled enforcer in the league.

really? he 1 (ONE) goal and 6 pts and was a -6 in 63 games on the second best team in the east.

he started the season picking a fight with an 18 year old non-fighter and got KO'd in his last...

and now he has no job

not Donald's best season by far.....