The Top 10 Thread

[Merlin401]

Here's Hockeyfight.com's continually evolving top 10 list. Make sure you keep it updated, as only the most recent lists comprise the official top 10!

* Everyone list your top 10, and I'll compile the votes like the AP does
* The current top 10 will be displayed in this post
* REPOST your top ten whenever it changes (DO NOT EDIT), and I'll re-compile the votes whenever I can so it is always the updated opinion of the board.


Current HF Top 10 (11/10/08)
FINAL 2007-08 RANKINGS

Total Voters: 439
Votes Counted: Most Recent 60

Rank: Name (1st place votes).......Total Points
1. Georges Laraque, MTL (45)...............572
2. Donald Brashear, WAS (12)...............527
3. Derek Boogaard, MIN (3)..................402
4. Colton Orr, NYR .............................376
5. D.J. King, STL ...............................279
6. Brian McGrattan, PHX .....................245
7. Eric Godard, PIT ............................231
8. Wade Belak, FLA.............................181
9. Raitis Ivanans, LA...........................112
10. George Parros, ANA .......................111

ALSO RECEIVING VOTES: Cote (71), Shelley (50), MacIntyre (25), Hordichuk (24), Sh. Thornton (21), Peters (18), Boll (8), Andre Roy (7), Janssen (5), Fedoruk (3), Boulton (3), W. Brookbank (1), Koci (1)

[Non-NHL players also receiving votes: Scott Parker (22), Eric Cairns (5)]


Past Top 10 Lists (Back to 1975)

Visit this thread:
Lineage of the Heavyweight Champ & Top Ten Lists '75-'07

[BuffaloBrawler]

It's a floating top 10 so it could easily change:
Cairns
Brash
Laraque
Belak
Johnson
Oliwa
Worrel
Fedoruk
Peters
Boulerice

No Domi, Simon, or Parker. I haven't seen or heard enough from these 3 to warrant a spot.

[Flyers2001]

Brash
Cairns
Laraque
Johnson
Belak
Peters
Parker
Erskine
Simon
Worrel
Boulerice

[Odjick29]

1. Cairns
2. Brashear
3. Parker
4. Laraque
5. Simon
6. Belak
7. Peters
8. Worrell
9. Peat
10. Boulerice

[letsrock27]

For now...

1- Laraque
2- Brash
3- Cairns
4- Belak
5- Johnson
6- Peters
7- Simon
8- Oliwa
9- Fedoruk
10- Brookbank

[OLLBLUEEYZ]

Cairns
Laraque
Johnson
Brashear
Parker
Peat
Belak
Low
Peters
Vandenbussche

[MattBurger]

Cairns
Fedoruk
Parker
M. Johnson
Simon
Doull
Hordichuk
Belak
Shelley
Oliwa


I refuse to put Brashear or Laracque on my list because they dont fight enough, their cards are crappy, and they are involved in too many hugfests. Have course it's only my opinion.

[36crazyfists]

1-Cairns
2-Laraque
3-Johnson
4-Brash
5-Peters
6-Parker
7-Belak
8-Hordichuk
9-Oliwa
10-Boulierce

[Dr Hook]

1. Laraque (no losses this season, Edge to May in their fight this season)
2. Cairns (Active, Good Record)
3. Brash (good record, but not active)
4. Johnson (quite a turnaround for him)
5. Peters (best fight card in the NHL, good record)
6. Belak (mediocre season IMO)
7. Simon (Another turnaround, card needs a little better competition but who's complaining)
8. Parker (not having quite the season that he was expected to have)
9. Peat (Average season, decent card)
10. Boulerice (Good showing for him after KO, maybe he moves up after a few more fights)

[PinoyRon51]

Laraque
Brashear
Cairns
Peters
Johnson
Simon
Hordichuk
Oliwa
Shelley
Worrell( would be #2 if played tha whole year also if was in shape!)

[BigGeorges37]

So far this season:

1- Brashear: no losses, and some impressive wins
2- Laraque: no losses either(not even to May Dr Hook), but has been hampered by injuries and poor play which has seen him watch from the skybox on a few occasions
3- Cairns: some destructive wins, however early struggles against Peters, Buchberger and McKenna are the only thing keeping him from being higher
4- Johnson: impressive card, and some impressive wins- especially destroying Peters
5- Peters: impressive rookie campaign with some good wins over the likes of Cairns, Domi, Johnson, Langdon etc.
6- Erskine: good year so far, if only he could get more playing time
7- Belak: solid year, not as good as last season, but some good wins nonetheless
8- Simon: a good year from the former king
9- Parker: has shown flashes this season, but not enough to put him higher on my list
10- Boulerice: good comeback year for him after Downey smoked him last year

[O-Gnimh]

Brashear/Cairns
M. Johnson
Peters
Parker
Hordichuk
Simon
Boulerice
Peat
Worrell

[CairnsisGod]

Brash
Cairns
Laraque
Johnson
Belak
Oliwa
Simon
Hordichuk
Peters
Boulerice

[Sandman13]

1. Brashear
2. Cairns
3. Hordichuk
4. Laraque
5. Johnson
6. Simon
7. Peat
8. Peters
9. Oliwa
10.Belak

[DevsFan30]

1. Brashear
2. Cairns
3. Laraque
4. Johnson
5. Oliwa
6. Belak
7. Peters
8. Hordichuk
9. Boulerice
10. Shelley