Official hockeyfights.com All-Time Top 10

[jmiller]

quoteOriginally posted by Kocur 26
[brUmmm, he already has him at #1.[]


Daaaahhhh[razz]

[Jabba]

Thanks Kocur, and thanks to jmiller for the info - much appreciated - you two in particular make this site great

I've never seen anyone break this sh!t down in such a detailed (almost scientific) way as you guys and Eddie and Bert and Reaper; I must say you guys are unbelievable and make this site easily the best one going - keep up the great work

[Kocur 26]

quoteOriginally posted by Jabba
Thanks Kocur, and thanks to jmiller for the info - much appreciated - you two in particular make this site great

I've never seen anyone break this sh!t down in such a detailed (almost scientific) way as you guys and Eddie and Bert and Reaper; I must say you guys are unbelievable and make this site easily the best one going - keep up the great work


But you like me the best right???[]

[Big24]

Sorry about starting this topic elsewhere. Here are mine
1.Probert- no brainer
2.Brown- a 6'5 lefty
3.Grimson- great career value
4.Crowder- unbeatable for a month
5.Kocur- best punch ever
6.Gaetz- would have been King after Probert..
7.McSorley-best career value
8.Kordic- top 5 every year he played
9.Wilson- never really got ass kicked
10.Gillies- Overrated, but Cherry has him 1
Honorable mention-
11.Berube- great career overall (most
honorable too)
12.Fotiu- got whipped by Nystrom once so..
13.Nilan- changed the way guys fight
14.Richter-another 6'5" lefty (did you ever see what he did to Kocur?)
15.Semenko-see what he did to DeLorme??

[Big24]

I think Gillies was very overrated. He had such trouble with O'Reilly who was a guy who literally couldnt throw a punch right. I saw Bridgeman use O'Reilly's face like a speedbag once. Cochrane was scary too but I want to remind all of you that he rarely tangled with
the real Heavyweights. I also disagree that he beat Nystrom twice. I had BobbyNy winning the first one. Cochrane was the original "lose the Jersey" guy which gave him what I consider to be an unfair advantage over his fully clothed opponents-NO HONOR! For the most part I think all of your picks are great- most of you really know your ****.

[Joclance22]

Here's mine, for what it's worth...
1-Probie
2-Kocur
3-McSorely
4-Fotiu
5-Grimson
6-Wilson
7-Brown
8-Jonathan
9-Gillies
10-Domi

[EDDIESHORETOEBLAKE]

Thanks fellas . . .

[Odjick29]

Gaetz at #6....[?]

[EDDIESHORETOEBLAKE]

Now waitaminute Odjick29 Did we get YOUR Top 10 yet? []

[Odjick29]

Oh sorry, here it is

1. Odjick
2. Crowder
3. Hunter
4. Bonvie
5. Antoski
6. Probert
7. Vukota
8. Brown
9. Williams
10. Guerin

I WOULD make a realistic top 10 but I have not been a fan long enough to make a good one. I have not seen some of the guys mentioned in action, I have only seen guys from the 90's +. Therefore, if I made a list, it would reflect from the early 90's up until today. I'm only 22 so I missed out on a lot of classic action...

[Joclance22]

That's why you have to get some old fight tapes from the '70's & '80's.
quoteOriginally posted by odjick29
Gaetz at #6....[?]

[EDDIESHORETOEBLAKE]

I'm confused Odjick29 . . . is that your list? (you mentioned that you would make a "realistic" one if you could, which implies that the one you provided was NOT realistic) . . .

Aside from a few controversial guys (Guerin in particular), there are quite a few legitimate Top 10 all-timers on your list (and a couple guys that arguments could be made for) - hell, even your namesake has an argument [)] . . .

At any rate, I don't want to log it in if you didn't intend it to be "realistic"; I for one didn't think it was necessarily ill-informed by any means, so if you want me to log it in, let me know . . .

[Odjick29]

Sorry ESTB, that was not realistic, I was just messing around, I will make one but it is only going to reflect from the early 90's +....here is my REAL top 10

1. Probert
2. Brown
3. Grimson
4. Mcsorley
5. Kocur
6. Mckenzie
7. Odjick
8. Domi
9. Twist
10. Brashear

[Bert14]

Big24, just curious about your take on the Nystrom/Cochrane fights. Their first fight was a non-televised preseason game on Long Island and their second fight is the one on tape that most have seen. Which one did you think Nystrom won?

[Begbee]

Nice list Odjick29 and don't worry about the tapes you havent seen, Ive been trying to replace mine for months and the deals offered so far got me saying,'Wheres the love?'.