NHL 250+ Fight Club

[BaddaBing Badda Boom]

NHL 250+ fight club rankings

Who would be the top 3 fighters if there were a 250 fight minimum to qualify? How do they stack up against the perrenial top 3 (you know who they are)

Grimson
McSorely
Berube
Brashear
Tiger Williams
Probert
Nilan
Kocur
Domi
Ray
Odgers
Buchberger

[mikebflorida]

McSorely-2
Berube-5
Brashear-3
Tiger Williams-8
Probert- 1
Kocur-4
Domi-6
Ray-7
Odgers-9
Buchberger -10


Is that what you're looking for? I just ranked them the same as my other rankings. Top 3 are pretty easy and the last 3 don't even fit in the top 50 so I gave the 8th spot to Tiger. Odgers and Buchberger were game warriors but not very good fighters.

[Golden Gloves22]

1. Probert
2. Brashear
3. Kocur
4. McSorely
5. Domi
6. Berube
7. Ray
8. Odgers
9. Williams
10. Buchberger

The first 4 are all in my top 10 anyways. 5-10..Id say Berube and Domi would fare the best against Probert, Brashear, Brown, Wilson...etc The rest - Odgers, Williams, Ray and Buchberger...not so much, no disrespect to em.

[I like Boobs]

Chris Nilan and Stu Grimson belong on there ahead of some other names.

Is this just another way of saying the same thing again?

[BaddaBing Badda Boom]

Originally Posted by mikebflorida

McSorely-2
Berube-5
Brashear-3
Tiger Williams-8
Probert- 1
Kocur-4
Domi-6
Ray-7
Odgers-9
Buchberger -10


Is that what you're looking for? I just ranked them the same as my other rankings. Top 3 are pretty easy and the last 3 don't even fit in the top 50 so I gave the 8th spot to Tiger. Odgers and Buchberger were game warriors but not very good fighters.

Yeah thx - Actually your top 3 of:

Probert
McSorely
Brashear

is what I am after.....

[BaddaBing Badda Boom]

Originally Posted by I like Boobs

Chris Nilan and Stu Grimson belong on there ahead of some other names.

Is this just another way of saying the same thing again?

Fair enough, that makes it even more interesting

[BaddaBing Badda Boom]

Hey folks lets add Nilan and Grimson to the mix. Some good back-checking by ILB. Thx

In no particular order:

Grimson
McSorely
Berube
Brashear
Tiger Williams
Probert
Nilan
Kocur
Domi
Ray
Odgers
Buchberger

[Stevens Lindros]

Originally Posted by BaddaBing Badda Boom

NHL 250+ fight club rankings

Who would be the top 3 fighters if there were a 250 fight minimum to qualify? How do they stack up against the perrenial top 3 (you know who they are)

Grimson
McSorely
Berube
Brashear
Tiger Williams
Probert
Nilan
Kocur
Domi
Ray
Odgers
Buchberger

Regular season-wise Brashear never hit 250 fights... Does this include pre-season?

[NameyMD]

I think you forgot Domi too. And I didn't think Bucky was in that many as well. Anyway an interesting and very exclusive little club to rank, here goes

Probert
Kocur
McSorley
Brashear
Domi
Berube
Grimson
Nilan
Ray
Odgers
Williams
Buchberger

[NameyMD]

hah, I read ILB's tribute to Kocur or rather his right and now I wanna put Kocur at #1, as I've been kinda thinking about it anyway. I'm sure most players would've rather fought a prime Probert before a prime Kocur and thus be sure to fare a little better, as in healthier.

[Churla22]

Originally Posted by BaddaBing Badda Boom

NHL 250+ fight club rankings

Who would be the top 3 fighters if there were a 250 fight minimum to qualify? How do they stack up against the perrenial top 3 (you know who they are)

Grimson
McSorely
Berube
Brashear
Tiger Williams
Probert
Nilan
Kocur
Domi
Ray
Odgers
Buchberger

Including Nilan and Grimson, I would go:

1 Probert
1a Kocur
3 Brash

[flex_buff_chest]

Poor Buchburger, 250 losses is not easy to take.

[BaddaBing Badda Boom]

Originally Posted by Stevens Lindros

Regular season-wise Brashear never hit 250 fights... Does this include pre-season?

Sure. If it was a sanctioned game that people paid to see and it was sponsored by the NHL ...

[mikebflorida]

Interesting note, the ONLY player I know of to have more than 250 regular season fights is Tie Domi.

I didn't count preseason or playoffs in my career totals on my rankings list.

I think it would be interesting to see who of the top 50 has the most playoff majors for fighting. Maybe I'll do that when I have time and list each guy and how many playoff fights they have.

[srehm1]

Is there any reason why we wouldn't count preseason or playoff fights? I've seen great great fights in both the preaseason and the playoffs-do they simply not count? Maybe a bit off topic but it's worth asking as this kind of thing has come up before. a fight is a fight in my book no matter when it happens. mikeB-you absolutely should count preseason and playoff fights in your rankings. man I can still remember that unbelievable war between grimson and vial in the preaseason or that fantastic probert-angelstad fight as well. there's no way i can disregard them because they happened in the preaseason. jonathan's epic bloodying of bouchard in the playoffs, the great series between gillies and o'reilly in that classic playoff series. wensink-nystrom-the list goes on and on.